Man Utd's REAL Problem: Discuss.

Bayer cheaters! pain killer injections should be banned!!! if they are injured should stay at home!
 
How the hell is it Fergies fault? The players are out on the field to do a job and the fact of the matter is, the player's just did not perform to their capabilitys and maybe they wanted the little bit more.On another note a plus point from last nights game was Forlan he played very well last night and deserved a goal.
 
Originally posted by ShAoLiN_ChRoNiC:
<strong>
My problem with this whole semi final was that we let them win. We let them have the ball, we watch them and hope that they give it us. Thats playing to their tune. That way we can only win if they let us win. Thats why we've lost so many games this year.
</strong><hr></blockquote>

I don't agree with some of what you said, but you're right about the above. Our teamplay when we didn't have the ball was a shambles last night. We just stuck eight men back on the edge of the area and hoped that Bayer would give us the ball if we let them pass it around long enough. They didn't. When we had it, they were pushing up as a unit and shutting the play down all over the pitch. That was the difference - if they'd given us the kind of time and space in their half that we gave them, we'd have scored about ten.

I don't think anyone should be accused of not trying, though - that's just too easy a thing to say after a bad performance, and the lads don't deserve it. Just hasn't been our year all round.
 
Originally posted by giggsgirl:
<strong>This defeat hurts very badly but I still maintain that despite the luck comments by Sir Alex Ferguson, excuse-making is not an appropriate response.

When the Red Devils won at Barcelona were we lucky? I think not - we never gave up and were rewarded by the killer goals of Teddy and Ole. Bayern Munich had their chances but they did not convert them, just as Manchester United did not convert their chances against Leverkausen.

The poor performance at Old Trafford in the first leg cost us a place in the finals. The score needed to be 3-1 or 3-2 our way and we would have been set up beautifully for the German leg.

I most emphatically don`t agree with Sir Alex that bad luck played a part. We should have had a goal buffer with which to go into that game. Yes, yes, I remember Turin but this is now - not the Treble Year.

You might as well argue that Bayern Munich should have won at Barcelona as they made far more scoring opportunities than Manchester United until towards the end of the game. That so called argument won`t wash with me. The team that converts their chances wins the game. Simple.

So lads - I am proud of the way you gave your all in Germany but it just was not enough. You should have made a meal of Leverkausen at Old Trafford. That is why you lost overall.

I am still proud to be a Red Devil but I don`t really want a litany of excuses coming from Old Trafford. Face the facts and move on and learn from them. Please.</strong><hr></blockquote>

This post seems closest to the truth, as I see it. And I understand those who are not over-impressed with Fergie's contribution.
 
Originally posted by b cridland:
<strong>How the hell is it Fergies fault? The players are out on the field to do a job and the fact of the matter is, the player's just did not perform to their capabilitys and maybe they wanted the little bit more.On another note a plus point from last nights game was Forlan he played very well last night and deserved a goal.</strong><hr></blockquote>


How can blame be layed on SAF? How about this phrase- If it ain't broke, don't fix it?

OGS and RVN had played brilliantly as a partnership the last 3 months. So why take OGS off, and play Veron in some strange position? I personally felt either:
1) Veron plays midfield along Keane with Butt on the bench;
2) Veron plays RW with Scholes on the bench;
3) Veron sits.
But SAF had to have the 28m man on the field at all times (probably not to admit he was wrong with the purchase). Veron may some day become an United legend, but on this day, his ass should have been on the bench. End of story.
 
Originally posted by Livvie20:
<strong>Every United player out there tonight wanted it. Sometimes it just doesn't happen. Or the other team play better.</strong><hr></blockquote>

I think I'd question if Giggsy wanted it as badly as Keano! Without Beckham and Gary Neville, we needed our 'star' players to perform and... brilliant as Giggsy can be... all too often... when we need a big game from him he fails.
 
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>Its simple. If Blanc leaves, we'll have to replace him. Other than that, the current squad should be left intact.</strong><hr></blockquote>

And not strengthen the defence?
 
Originally posted by lchk:
<strong>

And not strengthen the defence?</strong><hr></blockquote>

He thought that leaving everything unchanged we will somehow suddenly become better and then win the treble next season. ;)

Seriously speaking, when everyone is improving and only you stand still, you definitely will be left behind. We spent a lot to bring in Yorke, Stam and Blomqvist after we won nothing in 98. After that, everyone know what happened in 99. I sincerely believe that some major signing MUST be made this summer if we want to maintain any hope to challenge for trophies next season.
 
Originally posted by uranushk1:
<strong>

He thought that leaving everything unchanged we will somehow suddenly become better and then win the treble next season. ;)

Seriously speaking, when everyone is improving and only you stand still, you definitely will be left behind. We spent a lot to bring in Yorke, Stam and Blomqvist after we won nothing in 98. After that, everyone know what happened in 99. I sincerely believe that some major signing MUST be made this summer if we want to maintain any hope to challenge for trophies next season.</strong><hr></blockquote>

I won't even mind not having a major signing

At least a couple of good defensive bargains would suit me fine
 
Originally posted by lchk:
<strong>

I won't even mind not having a major signing

At least a couple of good defensive bargains would suit me fine</strong><hr></blockquote>

So let's get this straight Ichk, if we don't sign anyone at all, you will mind?

How will you express your outrage and what will you expect the club to do about it?
 
I really think everyone is overstating the magnitude of our failure to win the European cup. People keep talking about the treble winning side but seem to forget we had an amazing amount of luck to win it then. Christ, we were lucky as feck to come out of the Inter game at OT at 2-0, when it could so easily have been 2-2. We were lucky as feck to come out of the Juve game at home at 1-1 when they had so many chances to make it more, and I don't even need to mention the final (but I will anyway). Totally dicked on for 90 minutes and then score two. The simple fact is if you're going to win the thing you need luck, and as Fergie put it (and rightly so) we were a whisker away and luck didn't go our way. Real have bought a dream team and look like they're not even going to win their own league. That's football, and being overly philosophical is simply going over the top. I'm not saying we're a perfect team bal bla bla, as I know we need improvements. But some of the posts about selling eveyone except for 6 players is silly to the say the least. The EC was lost because we were unlucky and didn't get the rub of the green, unlike 99. The league was lost because of losses at home that should never have been i.e. West Ham, Bolton, Middlesborough. They came about through a combination of Fergie resting too many players and dips in form for too many of our players at once.
 
Originally posted by JSV:
<strong>I really think everyone is overstating the magnitude of our failure to win the European cup. People keep talking about the treble winning side but seem to forget we had an amazing amount of luck to win it then. Christ, we were lucky as feck to come out of the Inter game at OT at 2-0, when it could so easily have been 2-2. We were lucky as feck to come out of the Juve game at home at 1-1 when they had so many chances to make it more, and I don't even need to mention the final (but I will anyway). Totally dicked on for 90 minutes and then score two. The simple fact is if you're going to win the thing you need luck, and as Fergie put it (and rightly so) we were a whisker away and luck didn't go our way. Real have bought a dream team and look like they're not even going to win their own league. That's football, and being overly philosophical is simply going over the top. I'm not saying we're a perfect team bal bla bla, as I know we need improvements. But some of the posts about selling eveyone except for 6 players is silly to the say the least. The EC was lost because we were unlucky and didn't get the rub of the green, unlike 99. The league was lost because of losses at home that should never have been i.e. West Ham, Bolton, Middlesborough. They came about through a combination of Fergie resting too many players and dips in form for too many of our players at once.</strong><hr></blockquote>

Totally Agree, though we can't control lucks. The first priority next season is the defence, we need consistency badly. We need at least 1 CB, hopefully 1 more defender. The next will be a striker to replace Yorke. Ideally we can get a speedy striker, but I don't mind getting Di Canio. He offers something different, and can enjoy the role of Sheringham. And he can offer some more passion on field besides Keane.

Concerning team selection, I tend to agree we shouldn't rest the whole team at 1 game, and change at the next. If we want to integrate those fringe players and hope them do well in games needed, we should rest 1-2 players at most each time, letting the fringe players play together with the 1st team players, so that they can gain experience (esp. for those young players). They can hardly gain if they just play with some of the reserve players at those games.
 
Jesus. There is very little to complain about with your team.

For feck sake, you lot who are moaning are complete fecking idiots. Unfeckingbelievable. United have won everything in site and you cnuts are whinging. :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:
 
Originally posted by JSV:
<strong>I really think everyone is overstating the magnitude of our failure to win the European cup. People keep talking about the treble winning side but seem to forget we had an amazing amount of luck to win it then. Christ, we were lucky as feck to come out of the Inter game at OT at 2-0, when it could so easily have been 2-2. We were lucky as feck to come out of the Juve game at home at 1-1 when they had so many chances to make it more, and I don't even need to mention the final (but I will anyway). Totally dicked on for 90 minutes and then score two. The simple fact is if you're going to win the thing you need luck, and as Fergie put it (and rightly so) we were a whisker away and luck didn't go our way. Real have bought a dream team and look like they're not even going to win their own league. That's football, and being overly philosophical is simply going over the top. I'm not saying we're a perfect team bal bla bla, as I know we need improvements. But some of the posts about selling eveyone except for 6 players is silly to the say the least. The EC was lost because we were unlucky and didn't get the rub of the green, unlike 99. The league was lost because of losses at home that should never have been i.e. West Ham, Bolton, Middlesborough. They came about through a combination of Fergie resting too many players and dips in form for too many of our players at once.</strong><hr></blockquote>


exactly... every teams needs 'luck', even Real, who i thought were very lucky over the two semi final legs..

With a little bit of luck..ronnie's header might have edged an inch more over the line, or Forlans chip might have hit the back of the net or even better, Ole might have 'put the ball in the Germans net' again, with our last chance... but thats football, one team wins the other loses...its sport! no point moaning and whinging about it.. besides we don't have a God given right to win EVERY tournament we enter(now, that may come as a shock to some of our fans!)
 
Originally posted by Lanesra:
<strong>Jesus. There is very little to complain about with your team.

For feck sake, you lot who are moaning are complete fecking idiots. Unfeckingbelievable. United have won everything in site and you cnuts are moaning. :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: </strong><hr></blockquote>


innit...


they're spoilt bastards.
 
Giggzy you sound just like Barca99.

The irony.
 
Where can we get a better GK. We lost the match because Barthez was off his line and not tall enough. This would have been an easy save for RC. It was not a brilliant goal. Stop blaming the defense. FB should have dealt with that shot. It easy to look good behind 4 brilliant French defenders. Is there another great Dane out there with BMT.
 
<img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" /> C'mon then Elfie. What do you have to say about that ?
 
We have lost the art of counter-attacking in European games - remember 2 or 3 passes played at pace and with movement and in the net. Liverpool always drop a striker on the right or left wing because strikers are fast and direct. They scored plenty this way. I am not saying Utd should play like Liverpool because I love the way Utd play when we are on song

BUT if we insist on 4-5-1 then our strikers have to be more mobile and less central. Our midfielders also have to be willing to change their position and be more fluid. Too often this season we have looked flat-footed, passing plenty of the ball in the middle but going nowhere. If Alex gets this right we will be unbeatable (OK less beatable but I can dream, cant I?).
 
Originally posted by Due South:
<strong>Where can we get a better GK. We lost the match because Barthez was off his line and not tall enough. This would have been an easy save for RC. It was not a brilliant goal. Stop blaming the defense. FB should have dealt with that shot. It easy to look good behind 4 brilliant French defenders. Is there another great Dane out there with BMT.</strong><hr></blockquote>

Disagree about that goal in particular. Agree about Barthez being a bit iffy which doesn't help with an iffy defense.

Somewhere else I mentioned Cordoba. I think he is top class, double-winner of the Copa Libertadores with Boca and winner of the last Copa America in Colombia where Colombia didn't get a single goal in throughout the tournament. He is quality.

Currently on loan to Perugia because Boca could not afford his wages. Could come for less than Taibi did!
;) :D
 
Originally posted by Lanesra:
<strong>Jesus. There is very little to complain about with your team.

For feck sake, you lot who are moaning are complete fecking idiots. Unfeckingbelievable. United have won everything in site and you cnuts are whinging. :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: </strong><hr></blockquote>


Most people would agree with your first statement.

But moaning? Maybe it can be interpreted as such - but it's end of season analysis.

Imo we need to strengthen the defence, and play an attacking formation, at least at home.

Is that moaning?
 
Originally posted by Due South:
<strong>Where can we get a better GK. We lost the match because Barthez was off his line and not tall enough. This would have been an easy save for RC. It was not a brilliant goal. Stop blaming the defense. FB should have dealt with that shot. It easy to look good behind 4 brilliant French defenders. Is there another great Dane out there with BMT.</strong><hr></blockquote>

Can't agree with that. It's a deflected shot which came down from high. Most goalkeeper couldn't do much thing about it.
 
Originally posted by Dans:
<strong>Giggzy you sound just like Barca99.

The irony.</strong><hr></blockquote>

I already got used to that. Every time we lost there are some people came out to try to stop other people from discussing why we lost. But I never saw them successful in doing that.
 
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>We lost because we were outplayed (slightly) over two legs. Pure and simple.</strong><hr></blockquote>

So you think we shouldn't change anything in the summer (if Blanc stay), but then under everything unchanged will we suddenly become able to outplay them next season? ;)
 
Originally posted by uranushk1:
<strong>

So you think we shouldn't change anything in the summer (if Blanc stay), but then under everything unchanged will we suddenly become able to outplay them next season? ;) </strong><hr></blockquote>

I reckon we will, since they're losing Ballack. ;)
 
Originally posted by uranushk1:
<strong>

I already got used to that. Every time we lost there are some people came out to try to stop other people from discussing why we lost. But I never saw them successful in doing that.</strong><hr></blockquote>

i can remember everyone saying Fergie's lost the plot after only two months into the season.... <img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />


fickle bastards.
 
Originally posted by uranushk1:
<strong>

So you think we shouldn't change anything in the summer (if Blanc stay), but then under everything unchanged will we suddenly become able to outplay them next season? ;) </strong><hr></blockquote>

Absolutely. Look at the stark difference between our first two games against Deportivo and our last two. The entire team settled down and began to gain confidence between those four matches.
 
Once a red always a red. Man United for ever, through the good times and the bad times. We just have a defence of a middle table club and the attack of world beaters. Make what you will of that.The statistics prove me correct. We bu one or 2 world class defenders and we are laughing. Someone like Lucio from Leverkusen would be a great buy. Also Ze Roberto. Let's see what signings we make pre-season.
United for EVER.
 
The tactical error in the second game was not to go for 4-4-2 and risk a high-scoring encounter. (Big Ron also said a week ago we needed to commit our forward players and go for goals).

As many have said on this site, we weren't actually beaten, but given the away goals from the first leg the chances of us going through after a low-scoring game were poor. Better to go into the game with the attitude that we would need to score at least two and maybe three...Ole and Ruud together had earned the right to take the field chasing that target.
 
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>

Absolutely. Look at the stark difference between our first two games against Deportivo and our last two. The entire team settled down and began to gain confidence between those four matches.</strong><hr></blockquote>

So why a team that have gained so much confidence two weeks ago are now outplayed by Bayer?
 
Originally posted by giggzy:
<strong>

i can remember everyone saying Fergie's lost the plot after only two months into the season.... <img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />


fickle bastards.</strong><hr></blockquote>

So what? Although I was not the one who say Fergie lose the plot in early season, seeing how we spent 50m and won nothing, losing nearly 25% of the league matches this season, people said Fergie lost the plot have more true than people said Fergie was god and should not be critized. ;)
 
Originally posted by uranushk1:
<strong>

people said Fergie lost the plot have more true than people said Fergie was god and should not be critized. ;) </strong><hr></blockquote>

<img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />


aye, they were right...yep, it looked like he lost the plot, in a mere few weeks, after a decade of success...

'kin muppets. <img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />
 
There are 2 kinds of fans that should try to take it easy sometimes.

The glory hunters who bash the team at the merest sign of failure.

The blind faithful who will never see the bad side and slam those who do.

Mortal enemies I reckon.

I'm a football analyst and I love to analyse Man Utd because I know them better than I know any other team.

I once said I was annoyed at our our Welsh genius for not trying his best and people slammed me. Turns out I was right, but it wasnt his fault - it was Fergie telling him to take it easy to protect his hamstring. I dont expect him to play perfect every game, but I saw him holding back so I say so. I'm not blind.

This season has hurt more than most. Because we are the best club in Europe, with the best set of young players coming together that I have ever seen. But I am annoyed because we aren't the best team in England nevermind Europe. This season we have been truly surpassed. We cant blame it on luck or have anymore excuses - we've been beaten too many times for that. Losing out isnt what hurts though. When Arsenal won the double - we played ok and we lost - thats life.

What hurts most of all is that I dont feel like I'm watching Man Utd anymore. Sometimes yes, but most times - no. One thing that seperated us from Europes elite was our verve and our team spirit, we had a style that wasnt typical English yet it wasn't continental. Unfortunately that has evolved toward the continental mentality and we've lost some bite. I hate it when people deny this cos it belittles the performances of '99.

Anyone disagreeing with me should go and ask Keane. Is he happy with the season? Hell no. So why should I sit here and say "Well, it wasnt that bad, we're a better team than we were in '99". Or "We're as good as...".

Anyone else disagrees should go watch the videos of '99 and of years gone by and compare it to this year. The players play as individuals now. Fantastic individuals at that which creates some great moments, but a great team is what comes first. If we played the old way and had Ruud instead of Cole/Yorke - we'd be unstoppable.

Go and watch the actual game of football, not just Man Utd but other teams too. You will see a sense of purpose that is missing far too often at OT these past 3 seasons.
 
OK I realise I was quite harsh saying that they didnt try. Of course they tried.

I realise I'm being an wanker for criticising our beloved team and players and am being a spoilt brat.

But thats not how I really feel. I dont mind a bad game. When Giggs misplaces his through pass - too bad. Its not an easy thing to do. When Barthez blundered - its understandable.

But when our players find it beyond their abilities to close down the opposition, be it Ipswich or Real Madrid - I get pissed off. When you see two players leaving it for each other time after time after time. Short passes that are played TOO short - always happens. WHY?

Basically, before we concentrate on intricate passing moves and multimillion pound superstars - we need to get the basics right. The attitude, the killer intinct etc. They're alone worth £50 million in my book.
 
Originally posted by ShAoLiN_ChRoNiC:
<strong>There are 2 kinds of fans that should try to take it easy sometimes.

The glory hunters who bash the team at the merest sign of failure.

The blind faithful who will never see the bad side and slam those who do.

Mortal enemies I reckon.

I'm a football analyst and I love to analyse Man Utd because I know them better than I know any other team.

I once said I was annoyed at our our Welsh genius for not trying his best and people slammed me. Turns out I was right, but it wasnt his fault - it was Fergie telling him to take it easy to protect his hamstring. I dont expect him to play perfect every game, but I saw him holding back so I say so. I'm not blind.

This season has hurt more than most. Because we are the best club in Europe, with the best set of young players coming together that I have ever seen. But I am annoyed because we aren't the best team in England nevermind Europe. This season we have been truly surpassed. We cant blame it on luck or have anymore excuses - we've been beaten too many times for that. Losing out isnt what hurts though. When Arsenal won the double - we played ok and we lost - thats life.

What hurts most of all is that I dont feel like I'm watching Man Utd anymore. Sometimes yes, but most times - no. One thing that seperated us from Europes elite was our verve and our team spirit, we had a style that wasnt typical English yet it wasn't continental. Unfortunately that has evolved toward the continental mentality and we've lost some bite. I hate it when people deny this cos it belittles the performances of '99.

Anyone disagreeing with me should go and ask Keane. Is he happy with the season? Hell no. So why should I sit here and say "Well, it wasnt that bad, we're a better team than we were in '99". Or "We're as good as...".

Anyone else disagrees should go watch the videos of '99 and of years gone by and compare it to this year. The players play as individuals now. Fantastic individuals at that which creates some great moments, but a great team is what comes first. If we played the old way and had Ruud instead of Cole/Yorke - we'd be unstoppable.

Go and watch the actual game of football, not just Man Utd but other teams too. You will see a sense of purpose that is missing far too often at OT these past 3 seasons.</strong><hr></blockquote>

I reckon either murt or sarah will give you a hiding on this one - just a matter of time

;)