I thought he was awful today, constantly out of position
23
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 27
- Clean sheets
- 5
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 5
- Yellow cards
- 11
- Status
We should be so lucky, the guy has been here 8 years and has been nothing but a failure. We need to move him on asap.
He is a shocking state physically but he lacks brains to play for a top side. He needs to be benched with Harry.
Horrible. Can't believe how the quality has dropped.
Pains me to admit it, but Jose was 100% right about him.
How many good seasons has he had here?
Really bad performance. He was so frustrating to watch at times.
Dreadful. Same as usual. Zero urgency. So slow in possession and pathetic, lazy flicks to nobody in particular. After a terrific season last year, he is fast becoming another player we have to upgrade on.
Shaw duped us into thinking he is a top level LB, aka Robertson or Davies.
he is not, it was just a purple patch that he lucked into and it landed him the starting LB spot at England
he is not, it was just a purple patch that he lucked into and it landed him the starting LB spot at England
He was treading water after about 30 mins, and continues his run of playing people on for goals. I don't even rate Telles, but I'll be happy to see him back.
Horrible season, no excuses at all by now.
Another player I wouldn't mind leaving, decent at times but we can't have players living off one great season where we won nothing.
Someone needs to pull him aside and teach him to stay in line with the defenders, the amount of times he stays deep and plays players onside is criminal.
Another player I wouldn't mind leaving, decent at times but we can't have players living off one great season where we won nothing.
Someone needs to pull him aside and teach him to stay in line with the defenders, the amount of times he stays deep and plays players onside is criminal.
Good first half but fecking lazy in the 2nd half, come on Luke, get your shit together.
8 years at United. Just not good enough. In that time we have spent 12mil on a 28 year old from Porto to challenge him. Pathetic how we have ignored so many positions in the team.
Hopefully Telles is back in next game. Had enough of Shaw.
Is it just me or have him and Maguire had a lot of communication issues down the years that they've been here? From screaming "wake the feck up", to tackling each other to faulty offside lines. Either way it's another goal conceded 
Sad to know we'll be going into next season with him at left back because the club isn't ruthless enough
Lazy as feck when he constantly gets caught out of position.
Back to his normal level. He is quite garbage. Football ability aside, he is just not professional. Rooney is currently in a better shape than him.
I am actually really disappointed. I thought we'd seen the last of Chippy Tits after last season, but here we are again.
He's lucky Telles isn't much better.
He's lucky Telles isn't much better.
Luke wasn’t terrible today, but I’d like to see Telles brought back.
not sure this is an upgrade either. We’re in terrible shape all together
Get Telles back in. I don't think it's a Euro hangover, with Shaw he's been mostly on the wrong side fitness/build since 2015. Last year he was just under or on the limit but this season he's looking very laboured and just on the wrong side and gone over into a downward trajectory. Probably the same with Maguire.
We've had many players get slightly too large and lose the extra bit of agility which affects everything they do. Seem to start with Tony V.
This season has hit our players like a brick due to poor mentality in my view.
We've had many players get slightly too large and lose the extra bit of agility which affects everything they do. Seem to start with Tony V.
This season has hit our players like a brick due to poor mentality in my view.
Last edited:
Keeping everyone onside
Fooking disaster
Fooking disaster
Proving Jose and Ralf correct at this point
Always way out of position and always playing people onside. Really poor.
He was awful today, slowed the play down cause he isn’t fit enough to go full on for more than 30mins, for a professional athlete his stamina is pathetic.
Bang average at best.
Just like Maguire, a massive, massive hindrance to the team.
He's tactically and positionally very poor but he used to have a burst of pace to get himself out of the muck, which he doesn't have anymore.
He's so unfit it's embarrassing. Refuses or basically can't, because he's too unfit, overlap consistently in the 2nd half of any match and that leads to our back line being pinned in our own half, which brings the opposition onto us all half.
Needs selling in summer
He's tactically and positionally very poor but he used to have a burst of pace to get himself out of the muck, which he doesn't have anymore.
He's so unfit it's embarrassing. Refuses or basically can't, because he's too unfit, overlap consistently in the 2nd half of any match and that leads to our back line being pinned in our own half, which brings the opposition onto us all half.
Needs selling in summer
Is it just me or have him and Maguire had a lot of communication issues down the years that they've been here? From screaming "wake the feck up", to tackling each other to faulty offside lines. Either way it's another goal conceded
I think it's a total lack of communication across the back 4. Always one of them that breaks rank and causes a problem. The keeper and the back 4 just don't work together as a unit.
Need a real leader in there to call the shots and keep the players in check.
Looks like last sesson was the purple patch. Top players either improve year on year or at least keep a similar level of performance between seasons. Shaw is incapable of the consistency and motivation to continue to better himself.
He's regressed in his attacking and defensive duties and his lack of urgency when he has the ball is infuriating.
He's regressed in his attacking and defensive duties and his lack of urgency when he has the ball is infuriating.
I'll be glad to see Telles back
Tactical awareness terrible. Has been the same all over this time, even during his purple patch, or when he has his best season.
Broke our offside trap constantly all the time. Example of his best season last season was second leg against Roma for one of the goal. And that game we were all over the place defensively, which he's not the only culprit.
Darmian can be weak physically, weak in defend one on one, slow. However, there is a reason someone like Conte likes him for squad option for Inter. His tactical discipline is spot on. I couldn't remember a instance that Darmian ever played opposition onside during his time with us, which he didn't play much. Why was he not off the pace, rusty? It's about awareness and discipline.
Broke our offside trap constantly all the time. Example of his best season last season was second leg against Roma for one of the goal. And that game we were all over the place defensively, which he's not the only culprit.
Darmian can be weak physically, weak in defend one on one, slow. However, there is a reason someone like Conte likes him for squad option for Inter. His tactical discipline is spot on. I couldn't remember a instance that Darmian ever played opposition onside during his time with us, which he didn't play much. Why was he not off the pace, rusty? It's about awareness and discipline.
Last edited:
So just Shaw, Maguire, Dalot, McTominey, Pogba, Rashford and Ronaldo that need replaced from the first 11 in time for next season
Similar to Maguire, he seems to have lost a crucial second in his reaction time. Pauses and dithers at key moments when decisiveness and speed is necessary.
Can't believe he was an assist machine last season. He looks so lost out there.
Can't believe he was an assist machine last season. He looks so lost out there.
Luke Shaw playing their goal scorer onside again.
Holds the ball way too long. I have no idea how on earth he was so good last season and so poor this one.
Can't defend him after that game. I don't think Telles is good enough, but I'd put him back in for a bit. There have been way too many games where he has played the opposition onside for them to score against us.
This guy was so good last season, but is rapidly consigning himself to unfit (literally) to wear the shirt. Been rubbish, and seemingly in some sort of competition with his captain this season.
Its clearly rangnicks fault. Same with us missing open goals.
- Status