He's a young lad who just moved to one of the top clubs in Europe. Referring to him as a terrible buy in his first year here at the age of 19 is ridiculous to be fair. I'm willing to bet he will turn out to be an excellent left back for us in the future. Vidic and Evra struggled when they first came here and Shaw has arguably been more impressive at a younger age, in his debut season at the club. He does need to sort out his injuries in the future but the talent is undoubtedly there. Has all the attributes to make it here.