List of GOATs

Andycoleno9

snowflake obsessed matchday malcontent
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
32,158
Location
Croatia
After watching MJ's The last dance i was thinking about greatest players in other sports. So my list ( i didn't include sports which i don't watch like cricket, baseball etc..) would be:

Football: Lionel Messi
Basketball: Michael Jordan
Tennis: Roger Federer / Serena Williams
MMA: Fedor Emelianenko
Boxing: Muhammad Ali
Handball: Ivano Balic
Hockey: Wayne Gretzky
Am. football : Tom Brady
F1: Michael Schumacher
Athletics: Usain Bolt

GOAT in general: Michael Jordan

Feel free to add a sport.
 
Tom Brady shouldn't be anywhere near these discussions. Invalidates the entire thread. Mods please lock this.
 
Andycoleno9 said:
After watching MJ's The last dance i was thinking about greatest players in other sports. So my list ( i didn't include sports which i don't watch like cricket, baseball etc..) would be:

Football: Lionel Messi
Basketball: Michael Jordan
Tennis: Roger Federer / Serena Williams
MMA: Fedor Emelianenko
Boxing: Muhammad Ali
Handball: Ivano Balic
Hockey: Wayne Gretzky
Am. football : Tom Brady
F1: Michael Schumacher
Athletics: Usain Bolt

GOAT in general: Michael Jordan

Feel free to add a sport.
Click to expand...

Good choices, except fo Fedor.
 
Raoul said:
Good choices, except fo Fedor.
Click to expand...
I was thinking Miocic or him but prime Fedor was a monster.
How do you know that you are old? When you make a list like this and put all retired people on it. Ha ha. I nearly put Il Fenomeno but said to myself; "No man, don't go too far"
 
Cricket is easy. Don Bradman. Don't think anyone in any other sport managed to achieve the astronomical feats he did in cricket.
 
Andycoleno9 said:
I was thinking Miocic or him but prime Fedor was a monster.
How do you know that you are old? When you make a list like this and put all retired people on it. Ha ha. I nearly put Il Fenomeno but said to myself; "No man, don't go too far"
Click to expand...

The trouble with Fedor is he never fought in the UFC, where all the best fighters compete. Therefore its hard to put his career in the GOAT category for lack of consistent quality opposition.
 
altodevil said:
Tom Brady shouldn't be anywhere near these discussions. Invalidates the entire thread. Mods please lock this.
Click to expand...
thumb_tom-brady-crying-real-after-losing-at-super-bowl-52-50569287.png
 
Andycoleno9 said:
After watching MJ's The last dance i was thinking about greatest players in other sports. So my list ( i didn't include sports which i don't watch like cricket, baseball etc..) would be:

Football: Lionel Messi
Basketball: Michael Jordan
Tennis: Roger Federer / Serena Williams
MMA: Fedor Emelianenko
Boxing: Muhammad Ali
Handball: Ivano Balic
Hockey: Wayne Gretzky
Am. football : Tom Brady
F1: Michael Schumacher
Athletics: Usain Bolt

GOAT in general: Michael Jordan

Feel free to add a sport.
Click to expand...
This is subjective so won't talk about what's wrong with your list.

However you lose all credibility when you list athletics as a whole.
 
No way Jordan is the overall sport GOAT for me. His sport is/was just too niche and US-centric.
 
Multi-discipline: Jim Thorpe
Badminton: Lin Dan
Gridiron: Jerry Rice
Pool: Efren Reyes
Lifting: Naim Süleymanoglu
Rugby: Richie McCaw
Skating: Yuzuru Hanyu
Gymnastics: Simone Biles
Squash: Jahangir Khan
Chess: Magnus Carlsen
Surfing: Duke Kahanamoku
Table Tennis: Ma Long
Wrestling: Aleksandr Karelin
Swimming: Michael Phelps
 
Jippy said:
No way Jordan is the overall sport GOAT for me. His sport is/was just too niche and US-centric.
Click to expand...
He is maybe only undisputed GOAT. In nearly every other sport there is some debate. But not about basketball. Only some kids who never watched MJ will say LeBron James.
 
Invictus said:
Multi-discipline: Jim Thorpe
Badminton: Lin Dan
Gridiron: Jerry Rice
Pool: Efren Reyes
Lifting: Naim Süleymanoglu
Rugby: Richie McCaw
Skating: Yuzuru Hanyu
Gymnastics: Simone Biles
Squash: Jahangir Khan
Chess: Magnus Carlsen
Surfing: Duke Kahanamoku
Table Tennis: Ma Long
Wrestling: Aleksandr Karelin
Swimming: Michael Phelps
Click to expand...


One of most ridiculous records you'll likely to see. Would have loved to seen him make the switch to MMA. If Fedor is considered one of the GOAT's with his back ground in Judo and Sambo. Imagine Karelin with his Greco-Roman wrestling. What could have been..
 
Organic Potatoes said:
Just because Brits aren’t any good at it doesn’t make it niche. :p
Click to expand...
It's niche compared to say football and we're shite at that too.
Andycoleno9 said:
He is maybe only undisputed GOAT. In nearly every other sport there is some debate. But not about basketball. Only some kids who never watched MJ will say LeBron James.
Click to expand...
That's like saying Phil Taylor is the undisputed darts GOAT and maybe kabaddi has one. Doesn't automatically translate into them being the world's greatest sportsperson ever.
 
Football : Messi
Basketball: Abdul-Jabbar , due to not being overrated due to being the poster boy of Nike and most recently Netflix
Tennis: Nadal . Federer only has style of playing going for him.
Boxing: Ali
Athletics overall Bubka
F1: Lewis Hamilton

GOAT overall extremely difficult to judge. Probably Ali
 
Bo Jackson as the GOAT athlete in general? Not the GOAT in one sport, but managed to become a high-level pro in both baseball and American football, which is a ridiculous achievement.
 
Red Stone said:
Bo Jackson as the GOAT athlete in general? Not the GOAT in one sport, but managed to become a high-level pro in both baseball and American football, which is a ridiculous achievement.
Click to expand...
Might’ve been without the hip injury. Best athlete ever in the NFL and MLB possibly.

I’m biased, but on overall athlete I’m agreeing with @Invictus on Jim Thorpe.
 
Red Stone said:
Bo Jackson as the GOAT athlete in general? Not the GOAT in one sport, but managed to become a high-level pro in both baseball and American football, which is a ridiculous achievement.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't disagree if not for the fact that he only had half a career. Definitely the best athlete I've ever seen.
 
GuyfromAustria said:
Biathlon: Ole Einar Bjørndalen
Click to expand...

I think only US and UK sports counts. Usually does on the Caf atleast :lol:

Bjørndalen is Goat by a mile.

Was thinking about Cross country, skijumping and alpine aswell.
Stenmark maybe in alpine, but Tomba and Aamodt are up there.
Ski jumping i don't know that much about, but Finland, Germany and Norway are usually good, historically.
Cross country...Probably Marit Bjørgen and Bjørn Dæhlie.
 
Thinking of the only sports where there is little to no debate:

F1 - Ayrton Senna
Surfing - Kelly Slater
Skateboarding - Tony Hawk
Swimming - Michael Phelps
 
Hide and Seek: John Cena
 
Hound Dog said:
GOAT overall extremely difficult to judge. Probably Ali
Click to expand...

I don't know if you can say he's the undisputed GOAT even in boxing. SRR is arguably better although he fought at a different weight class and he didn't quite have the unpredictable movement and speed of Ali. He was an excellent counter-puncher and seemed to get better the longer the fight went on.

Duran, Mayweather, Marciano, and Louis all have good arguments to be called the best as well (although I think they aren't).
 
11101 said:
Thinking of the only sports where there is little to no debate:

F1 - Ayrton Senna
Surfing - Kelly Slater
Skateboarding - Tony Hawk
Swimming - Michael Phelps
Click to expand...

Schumacher and Hamilton have surpassed senna.
 
11101 said:
Thinking of the only sports where there is little to no debate:

F1 - Ayrton Senna
Surfing - Kelly Slater
Skateboarding - Tony Hawk
Swimming - Michael Phelps
Click to expand...
:lol: :lol: :lol:

Also Senna is a questionable choice for GOAT in the F1, let alone someone to have the "little to no debate" tag.
 
Ivano Balic :nono:

Handball: Nikola Karabatic.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.