Pep’s Barcelona played impressive football for years (albeit boring to some). Liverpool’s most impressive football resulted in nothing and they’ve mostly played very meh stuff since despite the results.
Also agree that our best two Fergie sides were better in every way.
A Champions League title?Liverpool’s most impressive football resulted in nothing
They didn’t play their best football that season. They played well in some games obviously.A Champions League title?
Which year was their best year then? They're playing worse this season, despite the results.They didn’t play their best football that season. They played well in some games obviously.
Yeah I agree. Never understood the 'boring' label some tried to place on them.It was people just annoyed their matches were so one-sided. If the opponent took the game to them then the match was very exciting... the opponent would just be derided for being "naive" by the very same detractors of Barcelona's style.
What on earth?Who'd win?
I think Peps Barcelona were the best club side in the world, Xavi, Iniesta, Messi - incredible. I think it's the best side he ever created.
Geez Dumbstar. Winning has made you soft!We honestly wouldn't. Sure we'd target their softer backline with, ahem, accurate high velocity distance kickballs, but ultimately our midfield would be torn apart like a papermache toy in rain. With peak Messi doing the rest VvD and Alisson would not look as great as they are.
Yes, but that was the end of their peak. They’re team from 09-11 was almost unstoppable - yes they lost to Jose’s Inter in 2010, but this Liverpool team lost to Simeone’s Atletico. If we hypothetically said both teams were playing at their absolute best for this hypothetical match then no one can touch Xavi, Iniesta and Messi.People here talk about Pep's Barca as if it was a team composed of aliens that never lost a game. They're the best team I've ever seen but they weren't unbeatable, they finished 9 points behind Mou's Madrid in 2012. This Liverpool team would give them loads of problems for sure.
Honestly that might actually work. I'd argue the Inter first leg in 2010 or the Madrid cup final in 2011 would be how to do it though.
Still, Barcelona are obviously better but Liverpool could cause them problems exactly the same way plenty of teams did cause them problems. A not so great United team making the 2011 final thanks to a good draw and getting demolished when Barca were at their very peak is clouding people's judgement here to think the gap was always that big between them and the rest when it obviously wasn't.
Madrid weren't that great at the time and they still pushed them during those years. Pep was 4 years at Barca, in that time Madrid only had 7 less points than Barca.
The 2011 CL final is hardly clouding people's judgement in here since we got just as demolished in 2009 when we had one of our best teams ever. That's the game that changed my (and I'm sure many others) perception of both teams since I thought we were the best team in the world and had a great chance to win but was shocked to see how much better they actually were. In 2011 I expected us to lose since we had a worse team and Barca had somehow stepped it up a notch further.
Are you sure you're remembering things right?? That's not true at all, you didn't get demolished in 2009 like in 2011. In 2011 there was a huge gap in quality, in 2009 they were better but it was a quite an even game despite Pep getting the better of SAF that day. United were playing John O'Shea at starting right back and a midfield 3 of Carrick, Anderson and a 35 year old Giggs and it was still competitive... possession was even and United actually had more shots. In 2011 Barca had more possession and it was 19 shots to 4, they were very different games.
United were better than Chelsea and look how Chelsea did in the semis against the same team in 2009.
The way I see it is that none of those Barca players had the technical ability to deal with Liverpool's press. There's also the fact that Pep's team wasn't known for being good at pressing either and even if they were Liverpool's midfield is too technical to be pressed. Liverpool easy win with them having 80% possession or more.