Kalvin Phillips

Status
Not open for further replies.
ZolaWasMagic said:
Well not really, because according to Bluemoon, suddenly Phillips is twice the player of Rice. :lol: :lol:

Clearly, its not true
Click to expand...

Yeah, I was just doing my Paul Merson maths.

Double, double it again and then feck it, just throw an outrageous number on it after that.
 
Interesting signing especially for that kind of fee.. We’ve had quite a few naysayers but I think he would have done well for us. Hopefully he flops at City.
 
Now that he is at City, great player :)

In all seriousness, he is a good player and would have been a nice player to have here on our weakest position. But would have always been difficult with his Leeds ties, i think we realised this soon in the window that he isnt too keen and City being in as well.
 
Personally I think he’s shite. Glad City have wasted their money on him as I’m certain he will be a flop. Nowhere near good enough on the ball for a top team.
 
TrustInJanuzaj said:
Personally I think he’s shite. Glad City have wasted their money on him as I’m certain he will be a flop. Nowhere near good enough on the ball for a top team.
Click to expand...
Will he get game time quite regularly though? I think he might and under Pep he will do well. Big move in a WC year. I guess the hate for city by Leeds fans is not the same as it is for United or he was planning this move all along.
 
SeanyC said:
Will he get game time quite regularly though? I think he might and under Pep he will do well. Big move in a WC year. I guess the hate for city by Leeds fans is not the same as it is for United or he was planning this move all along.
Click to expand...
I don’t see him playing. He’s another Ake.
 
Backup for Rodri. Nothing to see here.

But would this move jeopardise his chance for WC though?
 
City can afford to spend £50 million in back ups.

A snip for what they would have spent on Dec Rice. Not a patch on Gundogan.
 
The saddest part of it is, he goes there and barely even in their top 3 CMs.

If he came to United he'd be one of our top 5 players, and I don't think he's anything special at all.

He'll certainly improve their tactical foul ability, but I'd expect cover for Rodri above all else because if there's player in their team they don't need an upgrade on then Rodri isn't the one.

It's annoying, because Leeds in the PL is fun. It's funny to see them relegated of course, but you'd rather play that game than not. With Phillips and Raphinha off it's basically a resignation imo.
 
Seems like a good squad depth signing, seems like a sensible move for City. Not sure about Phillips though, this could cost him his starting spot in the national team if he ends up with as few minutes as Aké for example.

Might also be a sign that they have given up on de Jong?
 
NoLogo said:
Seems like a good squad depth signing, seems like a sensible move for City. Not sure about Phillips though, this could cost him his starting spot in the national team if he ends up with as few minutes as Aké for example.

Might also be a sign that they have given up on de Jong?
Click to expand...

They were never in for him
 
NoLogo said:
Seems like a good squad depth signing, seems like a sensible move for City. Not sure about Phillips though, this could cost him his starting spot in the national team if he ends up with as few minutes as Aké for example.

Might also be a sign that they have given up on de Jong?
Click to expand...
To be fair they never need de Jong, but they do lack defensive cover in midfield after Fernandinho is gone.
 
NotoriousISSY said:
The saddest part of it is, he goes there and barely even in their top 3 CMs.

If he came to United he'd be one of our top 5 players, and I don't think he's anything special at all.

He'll certainly improve their tactical foul ability, but I'd expect cover for Rodri above all else because if there's player in their team they don't need an upgrade on then Rodri isn't the one.

It's annoying, because Leeds in the PL is fun. It's funny to see them relegated of course, but you'd rather play that game than not. With Phillips and Raphinha off it's basically a resignation imo.
Click to expand...

Was it Rio Ferdinand who advised his life would be not worth living if he went Leeds to United?

Maybe heeded the call.
 
RedRonaldo said:
To be fair they never need de Jong, but they do lack defensive cover in midfield after Fernandinho is gone.
Click to expand...

This. 100%

Must be nice to spend £45m fr a backup. Guess with oil prices at sky high prices, he could be their ball boy if called upon.

From captain of Leeds to backup at city. Only shows the different levels Leeds are at
 
TenOuttaTenHag said:
Was it Rio Ferdinand who advised his life would be not worth living if he went Leeds to United?

Maybe heeded the call.
Click to expand...
Oh don't get me wrong, I never thought Phillips to United was feasible. Just the concept that City can drop £45m on a player who doesn't necessarily improve them whilst we're sat waiting for Christian Eriksen to decide if he fancies United or Brentford :lol:
 
NotoriousISSY said:
Oh don't get me wrong, I never thought Phillips to United was feasible. Just the concept that City can drop £45m on a player who doesn't necessarily improve them whilst we're sat waiting for Christian Eriksen to decide if he fancies United or Brentford :lol:
Click to expand...

Tbf to Eriksen it's about moving his family to a new place and away from what the kids grew up in. After his life changing episode, money won't be everything to them anymore.
 
NotoriousISSY said:
The saddest part of it is, he goes there and barely even in their top 3 CMs.

If he came to United he'd be one of our top 5 players, and I don't think he's anything special at all.

He'll certainly improve their tactical foul ability, but I'd expect cover for Rodri above all else because if there's player in their team they don't need an upgrade on then Rodri isn't the one.

It's annoying, because Leeds in the PL is fun. It's funny to see them relegated of course, but you'd rather play that game than not. With Phillips and Raphinha off it's basically a resignation imo.
Click to expand...
He wouldn’t be one of our top 5 players not even close. Ronaldo, Bruno, Rashford, Sancho, Varane, Maguire, De Gea, Shaw, VDB are all clear. They have all had spells in their career that Philips can only dream of currently.
 
Ridiculous career choice to turn down other clubs to “play under Pep”. He’s not going to play. It’s like Scott Parker going to Chelsea. He’s just going to waste away on the bench before stepping down a level and reviving his career just as it’s winding down.
 
Brwned said:
Ridiculous career choice to turn down other clubs to “play under Pep”. He’s not going to play. It’s like Scott Parker going to Chelsea. He’s just going to waste away on the bench before stepping down a level and reviving his career just as it’s winding down.
Click to expand...
That’s just code for “money” isn’t it?
 
Brwned said:
Ridiculous career choice to turn down other clubs to “play under Pep”. He’s not going to play. It’s like Scott Parker going to Chelsea. He’s just going to waste away on the bench before stepping down a level and reviving his career just as it’s winding down.
Click to expand...

He's 27 this year, getting a massive salary increase and guaranteed trophies every season. Easy choice.
 
The worse part about this transfer is that it was bad enough when Phillips was at Leeds that southgate would constantly pick him in England first 11 alongside rice in a conservative midfield and now that he is playing for city there is no chance that southgate will drop him now from that first 11
 
If we tried to buy him, we'd have spent the entire Summer on the deal AND we would've paid 50% more.
MCFC's other summer signing is Haaland for around £50M. We'd have paid at least double and spent the entire summer on that deal.
Our transfer negotiation team are abysmal. They ALL need to be fired....and that includes the newish members of staff, who are currently messing up the De Jong transfer. We'll pay a huge price for him, offer him the biggest wage and we'll spend the entire summer negotiating that terrible deal.

Qudos to MCFC. They are well run and it shows in the off season as well as in season.
 
Imagine the unreal banter he could have with Grealish on the bench, though
 
DWelbz19 said:
Imagine the unreal banter he could have with Grealish on the bench, though
Click to expand...

They can compare bank balances and swap their medals for the countless trophies they'll undoubtedly win. Sounds like a sweet deal to me!
 
He was always going to City, pity its just buggerd up his England duties because he will hardly play. Like Grealish, and before them a load of other English players. Maybe it's to fill there quota of them . Good luck to him any way I wasn't bothered about him at OT . Every time I've seen him he's been average only with Rice at International level he's looked better , that level though is lower than the Premier.
 
Ayoba said:
He's 27 this year, getting a massive salary increase and guaranteed trophies every season. Easy choice.
Click to expand...

Speaking of branch warmers getting (medals) trophies, I often wonder when I see 3rd choice goalies/rarely used subs going tonto on trophy day.

Fair play to them for enjoying the day, but do they really feel they have played a part.

Taking Roy Keane as an example, 1999 CL.
He done the business against Juve to get to the final, as we know, sat it out. He (and Scholes) were said to have felt frauds lifting the trophy. On the basis they didn’t achieve it.

Which was wrong imo. They were the vehicle to the final.
But a player with minutes only, getting an EPL medal. Different story.
 
Whilst he's not as good as rice, he's clearly a good player. He'll win trophies there and not stick out like a sore thumb.
 
Offside said:
Where do these terrible takes come from? Definitely don’t watch football.
Click to expand...

I watched them, in the same team all of last summer. Declan Rice spent all of it hiding somewhere at LB between Shaw and Maguire, while Phillips was the closest thing England had to a CM.
 
The next Ross Barkley or Danny Drinkwater.

Won't feature enough week in week out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.