I don't think either is great but I think Butland makes more concentration based mistakes, which automatically makes him worse for a top club.
Jordan Pickford
- Thread starter red thru&thru
- Start date
Emm he's quite good. Let's not be silly.
Anyway DDG going nowhere.
I don’t think he’s any better than our current backups. Romero is better and the only thing Pickford has over Parreira and Henderson is first team experience. IF DDG was to leave then I’d want those 3’to compete for number 1
If DDG leaves i'd be happy with Romero as no1.
That's understandable but let's not make out Pickford is garbage when he's actually a promising young keeper who had a decent season. Especially when you consider how poor Everton were.
He would deserve the chance
Same here.. Romero has more than show he is capable and has been extremely professional.
I don't agree and Everton fans are still far from convinced by him. If DDG were to leave, I would hope we would sign a far better keeper than Pickford. He's ok, but nowhere near as good as some of the hype around him.
I think the WC will be a moving experience for him.
He reminds me of Butland, in that he's been rated far beyond his actual ability. Although, the Butland hype seems a distant memory. Two decent keepers, but I don't think either are top four material.
I think Pickford has a higher chance to make the step up than Butland, because of his concentration levels. But yeah I mostly agree. Not good enough for us. Would be like Ben Foster all over again.
There's been a dearth of goalkeeping talent in England for a while now. Seaman was probably the best we've had for the last 20 years.
For people who have watched Henderson, where do people place him if he continues on that trajectory?
Spain boss confirmed as next Madrid manager...let the tapping up commence!
Its not that he is poor. He is very talented. But on our books we have far superior talent than him. Plus 3 youngsters just as good.
De Gea, Romero and Henderson are all better. Whilst Johnstone, Pereira and O'hara are just as talented
De Gea, Romero and Henderson are all better. Whilst Johnstone, Pereira and O'hara are just as talented
its the sort of goalkeeping you'd see from a pub team player, and you'd still think they've let themselves down horribly.Guess he will be backup for Henderson when DDG leaves
Before Judas takes flack for bumping a transfer thread this one is on me. Posted in the wrong Pickford thread, realised my mistake and deleted the posts. Not before he could reply though.
Guess he will be backup for Henderson when DDG leaves
