Jamie Carragher

UnrelatedPsuedo

I pity the poor fool who stinks like I do!
Joined
Apr 15, 2015
Messages
10,582
Location
Blitztown
What do people really see in Jill Scott as a pundit? Her analysis is very weak and opinions are as standard and safe as it gets. I have seen YouTube fan channels put out more nuanced opinions!

It's like watching paint dry.

Pundits should be highly opinionated and not people who sit on the fence trying to be politically correct all the time. It's easy to just say a few nice things, smile and leave.

Look at Roy Keane. I don't agree with everything he says, but he's definitely not afraid to make his point regardless of whether people like it or not. That's what punditry is all about. You can't be a pundit and be terrified of online trolling. The likes of Keane and Carragher aren't afraid of trolling. Their controversial comments on big names like Haaland and Ronaldo proves that.

Also, there's a certain level of tactical insight and analysis which these ex-players simply cannot provide. For that, you need the big managers. Mourinho was brilliant at Sky while he was there. His tactical knowledge and analysis of games was impeccable.

Carragher is definitely a far superior pundit to Jill in terms of insight and entertainment. Carragher and Neville are a nice balance of insight and entertainment. Keane and especially Micah Richards are in it for the entertainment factor rather than analysis.

The American show, CBS Golazo is all about entertainment and having a good time with the lads. Kate Abdo is absolutely fantastic(easily one of the best presenters) and has great camaraderie with Henry, Richards and Carragher. It's fine for laughs and banter but the analysis on that show is laughably bad and they know it. That is exactly what CBS is going for. They only care about the viral clips, entertainment factor and clicks.
Jill Scott isn’t great in the studio but she’s brilliant as a talking head on Gary Neville’s podcast. Far better than Gary or Jamie were in the beginning. She shows genuine curiosity and isn’t afraid of just asking an open question. No agenda or ego getting in the way of saying she doesn’t know. It’s really refreshing.

She’s a wonderful addition to that show. Gets on brilliantly well with Ian Wright too. Lowers the shouty banter dynamic and they spend far more time on topic than any of the others.
 

Sir Marcus

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 25, 2021
Messages
234
Jill Scott doesn't seem to have much knowledge. Carragher was talking about his penalty for England against Portugal on the overlap and Jill seemed to have no idea it happend.
To be fair, I’m not really endorsing Jill Scott as a amazing pundit. Just saying that these guys talk about football as ex professionals, imo it really isn’t a job where this a huge or noticeable difference between the best and worst, and certainly not a big enough difference to overlook high profile spitting incidents for example.
 

Sir Marcus

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 25, 2021
Messages
234
Jill Scott isn’t great in the studio but she’s brilliant as a talking head on Gary Neville’s podcast. Far better than Gary or Jamie were in the beginning. She shows genuine curiosity and isn’t afraid of just asking an open question. No agenda or ego getting in the way of saying she doesn’t know. It’s really refreshing.

She’s a wonderful addition to that show. Gets on brilliantly well with Ian Wright too. Lowers the shouty banter dynamic and they spend far more time on topic than any of the others.
Yeah, well put.
 

Isotope

Ten Years a Cafite
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
23,787
Agreed with Carra there. But, didn't know Klopp such a playa.
 

tenpoless

No 6-pack, just 2Pac
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
16,563
Location
Ole's ipad
Supports
4-4-2 classic
Will anyone think of Rafa? poor man is now forgotten. He didn't win the most trophies but he was a relationship legend too, only replaced by a newer relationship legend (bellend).
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
6,975
Supports
Hannover 96
Did he really predict Dortmund to beat Madrid? That was never happening.
He became a bit of a fan after his visit in Dortmund for the match against PSG. I am quite sure that that sympathy played a big role in that prediction.
 

VictoriaRed

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Mar 17, 2018
Messages
196
He is a moron. Nev must fire his ass. His contributions on the overlap are piss poor; what a clown.
 

Rozay

Master of Hindsight
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
27,439
Location
...
He will still tweet next season how ‘Man Cuty have been the best team in Europe for the last 5 years’. In fact, he usually goes a step further and bizarrely claims that ‘City and Liverpool have been the two best teams in Europe for the last 5 years’. While Real win the CL every year and Liverpool struggle to finish in the PL top two more often than not in the last 5 years.
 

Gabriel Djemba-Bebe

Full Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2018
Messages
2,771
He will still tweet next season how ‘Man Cuty have been the best team in Europe for the last 5 years’. In fact, he usually goes a step further and bizarrely claims that ‘City and Liverpool have been the two best teams in Europe for the last 5 years’. While Real win the CL every year and Liverpool struggle to finish in the PL top two more often than not in the last 5 years.
He stopped pushing that narrative when Liverpool fell off a cliff and finished 3rd. To try saying with a straight face that Liverpool vs City is the greatest rivalry in PL history is about as laughable as claiming Chelsea vs City is the greatest PL rivalry because Conte won 1 title around the same period Pep won multiple titles with City.
 

Chipper

Adulterer.
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
5,871
No way he actually said that?
Trying to be fair, he did say "almost". He's also a reverse Pep in a way. The thing about people saying Guardiola has never had anything but the best players/resources. Klopp hasn't, and I don't think it attracts him. He might have been able to get that kind of gig post-Dortmund, definitely could now.

Dortmund and Liverpool fans certainly loved him and I'm not sure they'd have swapped him.
 

Golden Nugget

Full Member
Joined
May 7, 2011
Messages
2,246
I mean there’s a lot to dislike and criticize Carragher for - but I don’t think getting predictions wrong warrants criticism