charlenefan
Far less insightful than the other Charley
- Joined
- Aug 17, 2005
- Messages
- 33,052
I'm dead
I wouldn’t, can’t answer for everybody else.I could be wrong but I'd guess that, given the choice, most United fans would take Son ahead of Sancho in starting for United for the rest of this season.
Is Son worth £108m? No, of course not.
Yes, that’s true to an extent, but I do think both have the ability to go past defenders with pace and trickery from standing starts. Traore loves skinning left backs and dinking it in.Zaha and Traore play best on the counter with acres of space ahead of them (same with Dan James)
At the moment we don’t have that luxury as our opponents are not leaving us that space.
We need players like Sancho or Grealish that can unlock defences that sit deep.
That s why I m not convinced with Sarr either - He looks like someone who likes to attack space.
Maybe Brooks but not totally convincing either.
You make it sound like we’ve spent 24 hours a day locked in talks! The truth is we probably had discussions with intermediaries where Sancho agreed to join us but the fee was too high. We’ve probably outlined what we’d be happy to pay and are waiting to see if Dortmund back down. If they don’t then it’s no deal...Remarkable failure if this is the case. I can accept not wanting or being able to spend that much on Sancho. But spending all that time trying to bring him in, only to fall short with two weeks of the window left, is shockingly bad. At this point it’s hard to see who’s around that we could even go for. Either Woodward stumps up the cash, or this window looks like a huge failure.
If I was a scout at a major club you'd be damn sure I'd at least have one other option. I dont sit around and scout players all day on my free time, so I don't know better. You dont have to know how to do better to criticize, with that logic you can't criticize a song, a movie, a politician, a car or whatever. Call me an armchair expert because I expect my club to know better and act better.Give us some names. The only one I have seen discussed who is viable is chiesa
They won't be coming close to touching Bayern in the league this year but at least they get to feel high and mighty for a few months now after Bayern publicly belittling them about being a little brother selling club a few months ago.They can't be more emphatic than that. When do they play Bayern, will enjoy watching them get smashed.
If I was a scout at a major club you'd be damn sure I'd at least have one other option. I dont sit around and scout players all day on my free time, so I don't know better. You dont have to know how to do better to criticize, with that logic you can't criticize a song, a movie, a politician, a car or whatever. Call me an armchair expert because I expect my club to know better and act better.
Sorry for the nonsensical outburst, there's a lot of talk at the board level in this club and I'm just so fecking tired of it.
This is going to happen next summer. Maybe Klopp's next big buy. They haven't spent much this or last summer I believe.When he joins Liverpool/Chelsea eventually, and becomes one of the best players in the world, that would feel so good wouldnt it.
Well, now it seems like they aren't actually selling.They won't be coming close to touching Bayern in the league this year but at least they get to feel high and mighty for a few months now after Bayern publicly belittling them about being a little brother selling club a few months ago.
At least for an extra few months anyway before he's fed up and decides to force a step up in his career.
Lots of toys will be thrown out of the pramThis place is going to become even more toxic until October 5th.
Lots of toys will be thrown out of the pram
I know. What level do you think Zaha or Traore would or could potentially take us to?I kind of agree. There is definitely a risk with sancho, to the point I’m thinking would the money be better spent on getting Zaha and Traore who are proven in the premier league. Sancho I find slows down the tempo sometimes instead of just going at the defence. I would still be delighted if we signed him but it’s definitely a massive fee with risk to it.
I dont have the energy to look through the top 5 leagues for a winger, so I have to accept that you are correct. I was wrong and I take I everything I said. The main point I was making though is if Sancho is worth it, or if we should have spent time looking elsewhere. I certainly feel like we could have put energy into sorting out other areas that are important too.would you? Why not for fun go through say the top 5 leagues , only one hundred clubs and look at the rw options for price and ability. United would only be looking in them as we need a first xi player
Not even a whisper of another RW target which will at least give hope for someone else. Also means we have to be stuck on this thread till deadline.Lots of toys will be thrown out of the pram
IT IS HAPPENING AND I DON'T CARE WHAT YOU SAYIs this enough now for people to accept its not happening. It was never happening.
IT IS HAPPENING AND I DON'T CARE WHAT YOU SAY
Wish the club would just move past this transfer and focus on strengthening elsewhere asap. For short term cover I’d take perisic for smalling in a swap. sell James next summer to help finance a renewed and hopefully decisive move for Sancho then.
They've spent about £81 million on Thiago (£27 million with add-ons), Jota (£42 million) and Tsimikas (£12 million).This is going to happen next summer. Maybe Klopp's next big buy. They haven't spent much this or last summer I believe.
You make it sound like we’ve spent 24 hours a day locked in talks! The truth is we probably had discussions with intermediaries where Sancho agreed to join us but the fee was too high. We’ve probably outlined what we’d be happy to pay and are waiting to see if Dortmund back down. If they don’t then it’s no deal...
They will. And I think we will pay.You tell em!
For what it’s worth, I still think they’d sell if we paid the money
We'll buy Sarr for £64 million during the last week of the window.Not even a whisper of another RW target which will at least give hope for someone else. Also means we have to be stuck on this thread till deadline.
Sickening to be going into another season without a RW.