Is Rashford better than the likes of Saint Maximin?
- Thread starter pocco
- Start date
No white text?
The way to beat AWB, and we've seen it repeatedly, is a decoy run where he follows the man and let the ball be played in behind him to a free runner. If it's just a straight 1v1 then even Mbappe had struggled against him.
Agreed. I struggled to think how beat AWB 1v1 and didn't realise this.
Nope. Rashford was given the goal.
We must petition a request to the club to release training videos of the battles between the two of them!
The knock on ASM is straightforward enough: Not a lot of end product. Also, not much of a plan B if he gets closed down one-on-one. Both were in evidence yesterday. Also, it must be maddening for strikers and attackers that he tends to want to make a second and third dribble rather than cross or square it - when and where are they supposed to make their runs? His unpredictability is a problem not just for the defenders, but also for them.
Rashford has a much much much better end product and is way more direct.
Reminds me of Adama Traore in a lot of ways. Great highlight reel and must be a nightmare for defenders to play against, but never really seems to have planned his next move out and doesnt have much of a lethal instinct, so ends up wasting his opportunity when he's in dangerous positions
ASM is just a BTEC Adama. Insulting to compare him to our Marcus.
So many people looking silly. Hahahaha
Strictly speaking, that's not really to beat him though? That's effectively a 2 on 1? Or is your point that a better/different FB wouldn't follow the first run but stay poised to block the pass instead?
That’s as may be, but it shouldn’t have been.
I mean, yeah, if you follow the old school concept of breaking down football to individual battles all over the pitch and the team who win more of them come out on top. In modern football it's more important to defend the space and it's the player's responsibility to keep watch of what's happening around him and realize when to leave his man to someone else - communicating that in the process.
Yeah you can beat any fullback in the history of the game the same way.
This is what I said about him and I believe ETH et al have improved his decision making quite a bit.
ASM is a throwback to the 90s maverick winger, similar in play style to funnily enough David Ginola who was at the game yesterday.
But he is no Ginola, who himself was fantastic and a player I wish we could have got, especially when Blomqvist‘s knee was destroyed beyond repair in 1999.
But he is no Ginola, who himself was fantastic and a player I wish we could have got, especially when Blomqvist‘s knee was destroyed beyond repair in 1999.
Good example. Reportedly, Jürgen Klinsmann used to tell Ginola off because of that unpredictability thing.
For reference, Rashford's about to score as many goals this season as Saint-Maximin has scored in his entire career. Saint-Maximin is older than Rashford. How is this thread even getting credibility?
Rashford could get 40 goals this season, 15 assists, make more political waves off the field and still there’d be a section of our fanbase who begrudge everything he achieves.
because people are fecking stupid thats why
He doesn‘t have the goal threat that Rashy has. Very good winger though.
How was this ever a debate? Even when Rashford was struggling for form last year, I think I'd rather have had him in the squad than ASM.
He is one of those players who looks scary on the ball when he's running, but I've realised recently that nothing genuinely productive happens with any regular reliability. When Newcastle's owners start to replace their current squad I originally thought that he'd be one of those sticking around alongside the likes of Trippier, but now it looks like he'll be shift alongside the others in that squad who won't have a place in the Saudi revolution.
He is one of those players who looks scary on the ball when he's running, but I've realised recently that nothing genuinely productive happens with any regular reliability. When Newcastle's owners start to replace their current squad I originally thought that he'd be one of those sticking around alongside the likes of Trippier, but now it looks like he'll be shift alongside the others in that squad who won't have a place in the Saudi revolution.
He shouldn't be compared to Rashford. He's not in that class. One of those tricky crowd-pleasers who ultimately flatters to deceive.
I saw that it had been changed when I made my post. Should've clarified that.
ASM is a midtable player. Fantastic skill but has never put it all together in terms of decision making and ultimately putting the ball in the net. If he could do those things he'd be a top class player, but the thing is, you can say that for a lot of forwards. It is end product that matters and that's why he's midtable and not at a top club.
Maybe if an ETH type manager got hold of ASM earlier in his career he could have been something special, who knows.
Maybe if an ETH type manager got hold of ASM earlier in his career he could have been something special, who knows.