Lentwood
Full Member
Added Newcastle, since they are often identified as a team who suffered badly from injuries in 2023/24. Like United, they underperformed significantly compared with 2022/23.Wanted to provide some context...
Pau Torres started 27 / 38 games
Konsa started 35 / 38 games (some at RB I know)
Diego Carlos started 20 / 38 games
Lenglet started 14 / 38 games
Mings started 1, as did Callum Chambers
At LB, Lucas Digne started 27 / 38 and Moreno started 11 / 38.
So Villa effectively used four players at CB and two at LB.
Now for the car-crash that is United...
Martinez started 8 / 38 games
Varane started 16 / 38 games
Maguire started 18 / 38 games
Lindelof started 14 / 38 games
Kambwala started 3 / 38 games
37 year old Johnny Evans, signed on a free from relegated Leicester started 15 / 38 games.
Casemiro started 5 / 38 games at CB.
Luke Shaw, our first choice LB and arguably 5th choice CB started 12 / 38 games.
Malacia, our 2nd choice LB, started 0 games...in fact, didn't play a single minute.
It's been widely publicised that United have used 14 different CB combinations...if we wanted to take an even deeper dive, we could look at how many times we had to change our CB partnership in-game.
Martinez was subbed off 6 times from those 8 starts.
Varane was subbed off 4 times from those 16 starts.
Evans was subbed off 7 times from those 15 starts.
Lindelof was subbed off 7 times from those 14 starts.
At LB, Shaw was subbed off 5 times from 12 starts and, as we know, Malacia didn't play at all.
Again, I repeat...much of this is our own fault and this is not a defence of EtH, who I have advocated sacking since Palace at home...but it is impossible, physically impossible for a team to have a "good" season when you're fielding a different CB combination every single week, and that CB combination is having to change again almost every week in-game!
For what it is worth...Saliba started 38 / 38 for Arsenal and Gabriel 36 /38
I am not for one second saying United aren't miles behind Arsenal...but I'd be willing to bet that if you gave them, with their squad, our defensive injuries this season, they'd do equally as poorly.
Fabien Schar 36 starts from 38 games
Sven Botman 17 starts from 38 games
Lascelles 16 starts from 38 games
Paul Dummet 5 starts from 38 games
Dan Burn started 33 from 38, presumably mostly at LB.
Keiran Trippier started 28 from 38 at RB.
So again...nothing really like United. Schar was basically an ever-present and Botman and Lascelles started 33 games between them.
LB and RB were basically covered by first-choices Burn and Trippier, with Livramento and Hall (both £30m purchases) acting as natural understudies.
For this to be comparable to United, there would be no 'regular' at CB, there would have to be an extended period in which Schar, Botman, Lascelles, Dummet and Burn were all injured at the same time and none of those players could have started more than 16 games.
Believe me..I'm no EtH defender, but we have been absolutely destroyed by injuries this season.