Played well but needs to cut down the unnecessary fouls.
46
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 10
- Goals
- 1
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 3
-
Hello, Guest! We have four new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting.
A new Odds or Evens competition is starting now. Click here to read the rules and message Damien to submit your eight players by 14th September 2024
A new Carabao Cup prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for round 3 which begins 17th September.
A new Champions League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 17th September.
A new Europa League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 25th September.
For Odds or Evens you have until the 14th September to submit your players. Submissions will be open for the next 6 days, 11 hours, 3 minutes, 13 seconds, and will close on Sep 14, 2024 at 12:30. -
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Jamie (@Vault Dweller) get the depressing job of reviewing United's 3-0 loss at Old Trafford to Liverpool. They discuss what went wrong, Casemiro's day to forget, and the pressure now on Erik Ten Hag. They also take some time to give McTominay a proper farewell, and give their overall thoughts on the Summer Transfer Window.
- Status
The red card dice rolls can't be happening every game with him.
Really like this kid but he needs to calm down a tad.
Should be getting all McTominays minutes now.
Should be getting all McTominays minutes now.
He is a nuisance for the opposition; never, ever stops pressuring and it leads to numerous turnovers or hurried passes that lead to interceptions. He’s much better on the ball than he’s showing, but that will sort itself out as he settles into being a part of the rotation. In the meantime, we need what he brings to the side as it enables others to better do their own jobs.
He needs to calm down some after bookings, still.
He needs to calm down some after bookings, still.
It's like he was trying to get sent off that second half 
But yeah clearly better than McT already
But yeah clearly better than McT already
Loves a nibble in the tackle.
He was good, along with Mount it was nice to watch some urgency and pressure from the front.
Will be hard for Hannibal to keep his place with players returning from injuries...but I would start him again at the weekend,
Will be hard for Hannibal to keep his place with players returning from injuries...but I would start him again at the weekend,
I like what he brings to the midfield.
Barely noticed him apart from wondering if he was about to get a harsh 2nd yellow for one of his many unwise challenges after being booked for a cynical foul.
I dont think he was lucky to not receive a red card but he would have been unlucky for receiving it. He shouldnt have gotten red carded but there was a chance. Hopefully he learns from that by being a bit less combative during a easy 3-0 game. That combative playstyle is part of him as a player though.
That's the thing. In a more even match or when we're playing for points that could really cost us.
Thought he was disappointing to be honest. With the amount of control we had on the game for a change I felt he should have had more of an influence. Didn't seem to be on the ball enough
Still a long way off what I believe he is capable off. He needs more games at this level to really express himself with his passing and carrying for me.
Too much of a time bomb, he's like a young Scholes but without the quality passing and positioning.
Exactly what I thought too he looked busy but didn't do much on the ball and gave a few fouls away.
Something really does seem to have clicked with him in terms of his temperament though, he felt like a ticking time bomb at times in the past but these last two games have shown he can reign it in and be a reliable option for the manager. Of course he ran things a little close tonight but it wasn't due to being riled up or reckless it was just an accumulation of small mistimed challenges that he'll get better at judging as he plays more.
Love what he brings. Needs to be more careful with the ball though.
No idea why the commentators kept going on about a red card either. He was never anywhere near one.
No idea why the commentators kept going on about a red card either. He was never anywhere near one.
Could’ve very easily got one for persistent fouling. Or just for kicking the ball away after they got awarded a free kick.
You gotta like him but at the same time, he'll get so many red cards a season if he was a regular... needs to chill. Not sure he'll ever quite make it as more than a squaddie here but that's fine. Plays in a role where you pretty much need to be a top, top player to be key here.
I love his energy and ability to carry the ball out of midfield but it seems like every game he is pretty close to getting sent off. Just makes some really clumsy fouls. Really needs to cut that out. I’m sure there was a game under Ralf where he again was close to getting sent off and Ralf mentioned it in an interview after the game and he wasn’t seen again.
Not the best of games, lucky not to be sent off. But very valuable experience gotten
Was it the Liverpool game,he just came on and smashed into them.
Tbh I didn't mind it for that game considering we were being battered and nobody else gave a damn.
Think he will learn with age some situations you can't win the ball so get goal side and cut off options rather than trying to win it all the time.
Hopefully
The manager trusts him now, especially out of possession. I reckon he will be used similarly to Garnacho. Him, Garnacho and Mainoo should get a fair share.
Loves a yellow card this lad.
Wasn't very good at all, but at least he ran and was a nuisance. But he needs to calm down. A walking red card, and that's not a new thing with him. Considering the quality of Premier League refs, this is not a good trait at all.
I think ten Hag did have a dig about the foul when he subbed him, seemed happy enough though. Just needs the maturity that comes with experience, hopefully.
The future is red for him, in cards and shirts .
.Good replacement for Fred’s role. But he could’ve had a second yellow tonight quite easily - and let’s be honest, if he played for an opponent we’d all hate the frizzy haired twat.
I really think he's got what it takes, maybe I'm a little bias due to how much I liked him for the youth teams but I think he's gonna be a very good player for us.
Haha yeah we would hate him. But he’s doing well and his ceiling is much higher than what we’ve seen so far.
His future is red, role model is FredThe future is red for him, in cards and shirts
Good match, but calm the feck down.
Reminds me of Thiago Motta. He will only get better. Hopefully.
He seems to already have a bad reputation with refs. His first yellow was very harsh for what is a very common and not dangerous foul at all, the kind that Rodri or Fabinho do all the time and never get booked for.
But once you’re tagged as an agressive player, it’s hard to get over it, same as Case last season.
I like his agression because he’s not a violent player, he just gets into a lot of duels.
Regarding his overall performance tonight, he kept tidy. Pressed a lot, tracked his players and played simple passes. I would’ve liked to see him take a bit more risks in the attacking phases but it’ll come with time
But once you’re tagged as an agressive player, it’s hard to get over it, same as Case last season.
I like his agression because he’s not a violent player, he just gets into a lot of duels.
Regarding his overall performance tonight, he kept tidy. Pressed a lot, tracked his players and played simple passes. I would’ve liked to see him take a bit more risks in the attacking phases but it’ll come with time
I thought he was quite sloppy, to be honest. I didn’t like his decision making with the ball and his short passes were often a bit off.
He did good work without the ball.
He did good work without the ball.
He did okay but he seems to be playing within himself. He's a player who normally plays with more freedom where his passing and dribbling/carrying ability is more pronounced. But he seemed to play the game tonight very safe, where it seemed like he was instructed to keep it simple. But hopefully in the next games we see him play with more risk and endeavour. Because that's the type of player he is and hopefully we see more of the creative side of his game in the near future.
If you followed him coming up, you’ll know he played from deep and where he’s playing now is the more foreign position. That being said, he’s not going to get any playing time from deep until he can go games without cards - you cannot get away with playing deep with the threat of a red always looming over you; even Patrick Vieira proved that with his reds until he calmed down.
Once he shows more composure and judgment in his tackling, we’ll start to see him getting minutes in his actual position. Until then, he’s going to have to bide his time and actually prove his mettle in terms of common sense and fastidiousness to doing the aggression and tackling without overcooking it.
You play him and play him and get it out of his system, or better to say, have him learn to keep a handle on it. There are countless top players who had this problem who reined it in (Keane, Vieira, Rooney immediately come to mind), so there’s nothing unique in it and we just have to make a concerted effort with his PT.
Once he shows more composure and judgment in his tackling, we’ll start to see him getting minutes in his actual position. Until then, he’s going to have to bide his time and actually prove his mettle in terms of common sense and fastidiousness to doing the aggression and tackling without overcooking it.
You play him and play him and get it out of his system, or better to say, have him learn to keep a handle on it. There are countless top players who had this problem who reined it in (Keane, Vieira, Rooney immediately come to mind), so there’s nothing unique in it and we just have to make a concerted effort with his PT.
Promotees are notoriously on tenterhooks in terms of expression; safe and sure until you earn the manager’s trust and are assured you won’t get hooked for weeks/months, and then comes the expression.
Trust and faith is a vital component in becoming a permanent fixture and I’d bet Hannibal is one on a tighter gagging than usual because of his infamy as a hothead and instinctual player.
I hate when people start comparing him to Fred already, he's not even close as good defensively, always seems to be half a stride slower. Didn't quite give me the right impressions of him today. He's much more creative than that but ETH wanted totall control at the expense of creativity today.
So if he convinced him along with other palyers palying boring football, taking no risks turning with the ball, I am happy he proved himself useful, because he's got potential. But I think due to his slightly average first touch, I think he's gonna be aiming for that 6/8 hybrid role, rather than attacking one, he's got good vision and a pass from the back. Also it's his second senior start, so should improve when he gets up to pace after bulding match day rhytm and fitness.
Always hard for a youth player to get going and transitionto senior football. Stupid yellow at the beginning though!
So if he convinced him along with other palyers palying boring football, taking no risks turning with the ball, I am happy he proved himself useful, because he's got potential. But I think due to his slightly average first touch, I think he's gonna be aiming for that 6/8 hybrid role, rather than attacking one, he's got good vision and a pass from the back. Also it's his second senior start, so should improve when he gets up to pace after bulding match day rhytm and fitness.
Always hard for a youth player to get going and transitionto senior football. Stupid yellow at the beginning though!
I completely agree.
The AM role is absolutely crucial, especially out of possession in a team that wants to play the game in the opponent's half. And knowing your role as a player out of possession in that particular area is vital to thwart the opponent's quick transition which can expose the vulnerabilities in the whole system. So for me that role is why we signed Mason Mount because he has the out of possession game to enhance the system tactically due to his intelligence, tenacity and athleticism. We got trounced in a number of games last season and one of the reasons was that opponent's would comfortably bypass Bruno centrally.
- Status