Gooooners Vs Toooon

[Fergiesarmy]

Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>I thought it was one of the worst penalty decisions all year. </strong><hr></blockquote>

i agree that i dont think it was a penalty watching a replay, but at first glance i thought it was one looking at the angle campbell tackled him from.

i think it was a tough decision to make on the spot and wouldnt call it one of the worst pen decisions all year.

i saw two worse ones not given in cardiff!

 

[BHManUNut]

Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>I thought it was one of the worst penalty decisions all year. Campbell looked to clearly disposses Robert. It was all ball and no contact with the player. Robert looked to fall in anticipation of a collision with Taylor. Poll was far behind the play and made the wrong call.
</strong><hr></blockquote>

OK. Not going to argue with you, I didn't see him touch the ball, but,...... I was three sheets to the wind last night anyway and a couple of hours later I wasn't able to see me pint!!!!

 

[geordie1]

Totally agree, FA. It was a tough decision and looked a certain peno without a minute inspection of the replay.

Raoul, for a truly awful penalty decision I refer you to the one Robert won against Fulham. I would have taken it, mind, but it almost seemed just that van der Saar saved.