GOAT Athletes Five Stars Draft | FINAL poll added

Who has picked the greatest team? (Read post #145)

  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .
This has gone off the rails a bit, @Šjor Bepo might be nursing a bit of a hangover ;)

Looks like it's @ctp 's go, and Bepo picked Graf before Brodeur, so I think the board is:

1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Christiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias
 
Nikola Karabatić

7796189525_nikola-karabatic-avec-les-bleus-le-28-janvier-2018-a-zagreb.jpg
 
Sorry for the mess, got under influence of my first pick
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias

@Skills
 
Johan Cruyff

1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias

@Šjor Bepo
 
altodevil said:
Assume he still wants Brodeur?
Click to expand...

Yeah, I think it's probably fair to say so. Might as well go on ahead with yours.

1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias

@backofthenet
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky, Pele
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias

@RedTiger
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky, Pele
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan, Cris Cyborg
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias

@V.O.
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky, Pele
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan, Cris Cyborg
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin, Ronda Rousey
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias

@crappycraperson
 
V.O. said:
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky, Pele
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan, Cris Cyborg
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin, Ronda Rousey
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias

@crappycraperson
Click to expand...
Did you want cris by any chance?
 
RedTiger said:
Did you want cris by any chance?
Click to expand...

Nah, was always going for Rousey based on star quality and impact on the sport even if Cyborg may be and Amanda Nunes definitely would be better pure fighters :)
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky, Pele
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan, Cris Cyborg
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin, Ronda Rousey
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias, Megan Rapinoe, Sir Alex Ferguson

@V.O.
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky, Pele
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan, Cris Cyborg
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin, Ronda Rousey, Angelo Dundee
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias, Megan Rapinoe, Sir Alex Ferguson

@RedTiger
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky, Pele
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan, Cris Cyborg, Vince Lombardi
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin, Ronda Rousey, Angelo Dundee
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias, Megan Rapinoe, Sir Alex Ferguson

@backofthenet
 
Interval said:
Any team with Fergie wins by default. Sorry folks. Absence has really made the heart grow fonder
Click to expand...

I thought about picking someone else for a moment then realised how foolish that was. Just searching for his images nearly brought a tear to my eye :(
 
Interval said:
Any team with Fergie wins by default. Sorry folks. Absence has really made the heart grow fonder
Click to expand...

On a United forum especially, that could very easily be a big factor! The man who trained and cornered Muhammad Ali, George Foreman, and Sugar Ray Leonard along with 12 more world champion boxers doesn't have a bad CV either though. ;)
 
V.O. said:
On a United forum especially, that could very easily be a big factor! The man who trained and cornered Muhammad Ali, George Foreman, and Sugar Ray Leonard along with 12 more world champion boxers doesn't have a bad CV either though. ;)
Click to expand...
I was thinking of going with Tysons ex trainer but decided to go with the man who inspired Fergie instead.
 
Surprised to see nobody take Mayweather as a villain, and nobody bother with any drivers (Senna, Schumacher, maybe even Valentino Rossi). Pele falling to the dregs of the last round maybe shows where people view him post-Messi and Ronaldo as well.
 
V.O. said:
Surprised to see nobody take Mayweather as a villain, and nobody bother with any drivers (Senna, Schumacher, maybe even Valentino Rossi). Pele falling to the dregs of the last round maybe shows where people view him post-Messi and Ronaldo as well.
Click to expand...
Was very close to taking Pele when I picked LeBron. The latter fit better in prescribed categories.
 
It was Mayweather or Ronnie for me. Went for the the one who is actually the best ever in their sport. Which I think is what the main point of the game is. So I was surprised at some choices.
 
V.O. said:
Surprised to see nobody take Mayweather as a villain, and nobody bother with any drivers (Senna, Schumacher, maybe even Valentino Rossi). Pele falling to the dregs of the last round maybe shows where people view him post-Messi and Ronaldo as well.
Click to expand...
Na mate, it's all because of the 2 female picks who also have to fit criterias.
 
altodevil said:
It was Mayweather or Ronnie for me. Went for the the one who is actually the best ever in their sport. Which I think is what the main point of the game is. So I was surprised at some choices.
Click to expand...

The only one that baffled me was Brodeur, because even if for some strange reason we were forced to have an ice hockey keeper, I'd have Dominik Hasek instead. :lol:
 
RedTiger said:
Mate, I hope you didn't pick Ronnie as a villian because you'd be hard pressed to find any snooker fans who dislike him.
Click to expand...
A showman who overacts and misbehaves. The nastier you are the more they love you? Yeah I took Ronnie for that, for sure.
 
V.O. said:
Surprised to see nobody take Mayweather as a villain, and nobody bother with any drivers (Senna, Schumacher, maybe even Valentino Rossi). Pele falling to the dregs of the last round maybe shows where people view him post-Messi and Ronaldo as well.
Click to expand...
Who you calling a dreg?

Seriously though, I was amazed that he was available. Am thinking I may have problems with a couple of the categories mind.
 
1. ctp - Serena Williams, Lionel Messi, Michael Phelps, Nikola Karabatić, Magdalena Neuner
2. Skills - Michael Jordan, Carl Lewis, Nadia Comaneci, Billie Jean King, Johan Cruyff
3. Šjor Bepo - Diego Maradona, Bill Russell, Janica Kostelic, Steffi Graf, Martin Brodeur
4. altodevil - Usain Bolt, Tiger Woods, Simone Biles, Mia Hamm, Ronnie O'Sullivan
5. backofthenet - Muhammad Ali, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Richie McCaw, Katie Ledecky, Pele, Bill Bellichick
6. RedTiger - Wayne Gretzky, Martina Navratilova, Cristiano Ronaldo, Jahangir Khan, Cris Cyborg, Vince Lombardi
7. V.O. - Don Bradman, Babe Ruth, Margaret Court, Alexander Karelin, Ronda Rousey, Angelo Dundee
8. crappycraperson - Roger Federer, Sachin Tendulkar, LeBron James, Babe Didrikson Zaharias, Megan Rapinoe, Sir Alex Ferguson

@altodevil
 
So we picking a manager/coach this round? Can be from the sport we already used?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.