I was privileged enough to see George's first United game in 1964, and attended every home game, and several away, until 1967. He was without a shadow of doubt the greatest player I have ever seen live but as amazing as the footage is in this video, it hasn't captured his most incredible moments for United; they're just not on film. Soon after his debut, opposing teams had to put three or four men on him and not even that worked. For example, at home to Everton in the Autumn of 1965, he received the ball on the touch line, right up against the halfway flag. He immediately went past three Evertonians as if they weren't there and headed for the penalty area beating another two on the way. A solid line of defenders forced him out to the corner flag -- we were all shouting "Pass the f-ing ball!" since he was notorious at that stage for keeping it to himself for long periods because no one could get near him or take it off him -- he then dribbled his way past another three Evertonians out of the corner, and headed back to the penalty area near the half circle there, going past another two or three on the way. We were still yelling "Pass the f-ing ball!" when he hit a thunderbolt past the Everton goal-keeper. For a half second there was no reaction from the crowd; I have never seen that at a football match before or since. What we had seen just hadn't quite sunk in. Then the whole place erupted as we realised we had all witnessed the goal of our lives. None of that was captured on film. But that is just one example of many, it just happens to be greatest moment. But, by the 1966-67 season, it was becoming clear to all that he had lost half a yard of pace, and defenders who couldn't get near him in 1965 were doing so more frequently. There is one scene in the above video -- at
02:21 -- where George is headed toward the penalty area (in a game against Chelsea), and Ron 'Chopper' Harris tries to bring him down with one of his infamous scything tackles. He catches George but George rides the tackle and scores. A year earlier, Harris would not have got near him. Had United looked after George as well as they look after their players now, he'd have gone on to be the greatest player anyone has ever seen, anywhere. I have absolutely no doubt about that. Given the two or three years he had at United at his peak (the rest of his years there saw only a shadow of the great player he had once been, until he left United in 1974), and before the steep decline set in, he was easily one of the greatest ever, but his lifestyle prevented from becoming the greatest the world has ever seen.