Gary Neville at RB? No Way!
- Thread starter lchk
- Start date
What will happen to Gaz if we buy Steven Carr?? IMO he'd lose his place to the best RB in the EPL. We need more competition in all areas not just defence and it'll probably make them concentrate that bit more so less fuk ups!
Originally posted by lchk:
<strong>If we bought a better centre-half and with the emergence of O'Shea, then out he would go but that's not a likely scenario now is that?</strong><hr></blockquote>
So if we bought Chivu you wouldnt mind seeig Gary Neville being fuched out?
You also didnt want O'shea to get a look in this season, whats changed there?
My offer still stands for them quotes + some more O'Shea ones
Gazz's best performances over the last couple of years have been at centerback. even when stam was around. I think Fergie would be best suited using him to replace Blanc at centerback next season while we buy a World class right back to support Beckham. thus says the chief
Originally posted by RUnited:
[QB]
just because spurs are having one good season, it's not enough to justify carr's ability. i don't think he fits the criteria to be a full time right back at United. someone like Danny Mills maybe.
Originally posted by jmanu:
<strong>Originally posted by RUnited:
[QB]
hahaha, i've been in so much crap these past few weeks with so many lads this would not do more harm.
But anyhow, i think you misunderstood me.. i said Danny is better than Carr.. not that i wanted him here at OT.. i still think Gaz is best at it.
Originally posted by Murt:
<strong>
So if we bought Chivu you wouldnt mind seeig Gary Neville being fuched out?
You also didnt want O'shea to get a look in this season, whats changed there?
My offer still stands for them quotes + some more O'Shea ones
O'Shea's emergence is a pleasant surprise so that saves us money on one more central defender
So if someone like Chivu or Mexes comes in, well Gary better buck up or else.
All you have is a bunch of quotes - is that going to stop me from posting?
Originally posted by lchk:
<strong>O'Shea's emergence is a pleasant surprise so that saves us money on one more central defender
So if someone like Chivu or Mexes comes in, well Gary better buck up or else.
All you have is a bunch of quotes - is that going to stop me from posting?</strong><hr></blockquote>
Have i ever asked you to stop posting?
I just dont like how you can slag O'Shea and Gary Neville off one minute and suddenly their good again
If chivu came and made a few unforced errors like Gary did how would you react, start all over again and want the new crowd out too?
Originally posted by Murt:
<strong>
Have i ever asked you to stop posting?
I just dont like how you can slag O'Shea and Gary Neville off one minute and suddenly their good again
If chivu came and made a few unforced errors like Gary did how would you react, start all over again and want the new crowd out too?</strong><hr></blockquote>
This has nothing to do with a few unenforced errors.
This has to do with the quality of a player.
If the club replaces them with a player of better quality, I would certainly not object to it - improvement is a continuous thing and nobody's place should be guaranteed at OT.
seems like ichk and murt have been arguing in every single thread!
get a room you two!
get a room you two!
I believe that G Nev is a fairly good player. But I believe that O Shea and W Brown have more talent than him and on the long run they may pip his place and throw him on the bench.
I think that Manutd should stop playing players for their reputation ( more on Blanc rather then Gaz) and start playing those players who are in form and have the talent to suceed.
If O Shea do a mistake he will learn of it and grow stronger out of it. If Blanc at 37 do a mistake ( he do loads of them) wat will Manutd recover from it??
I think that Manutd should stop playing players for their reputation ( more on Blanc rather then Gaz) and start playing those players who are in form and have the talent to suceed.
If O Shea do a mistake he will learn of it and grow stronger out of it. If Blanc at 37 do a mistake ( he do loads of them) wat will Manutd recover from it??
I'll rather have G Neville in the team anytime anyday! <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" /> <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" />
Points in favor of G Nev
1 More experienced
2 His influence in the defense
3 his communication with Becks
VERDICT G Nev is a fairly good defender. Wat he lacks in technique and Physical power he compensates it with his charisma and telepatic comunication with Becks. G Nev is a great talker wit a Red devil's heart. Unfortunately heart and charisma may not always be enough, just ask Edmundo and Goater.
Against G Nev
1 Lack of strength
2 pace
3 technique
VERDICT Gnev is not a Cafu or a R Carlos. He cannot do those elegant overlapping and can be caught single footed if bullied with strenght technique or pace. O Shea and Brown do not have such problems.
Verdict at the moment I would keep him BUT No one should be given an automatic place. If i was SAF i would try and if successful consider my options on the right flank.
1 More experienced
2 His influence in the defense
3 his communication with Becks
VERDICT G Nev is a fairly good defender. Wat he lacks in technique and Physical power he compensates it with his charisma and telepatic comunication with Becks. G Nev is a great talker wit a Red devil's heart. Unfortunately heart and charisma may not always be enough, just ask Edmundo and Goater.
Against G Nev
1 Lack of strength
2 pace
3 technique
VERDICT Gnev is not a Cafu or a R Carlos. He cannot do those elegant overlapping and can be caught single footed if bullied with strenght technique or pace. O Shea and Brown do not have such problems.
Verdict at the moment I would keep him BUT No one should be given an automatic place. If i was SAF i would try and if successful consider my options on the right flank.