Reading some of the career stories on this thread led me to download FM20 whilst it was on sale recently (the first one which I’ve played since being pretty hooked on it between FM06 and FM13), so I thought I should contribute.
2019/20 season:
I’ve started a game with Falkirk, who start in League 1 in Scotland. They were only relegated the season before last, so the expectation was to achieve promotion and the bookies had us as promotion favourites. As a result, I only made minimal additions to the squad and hoped that would be enough to win the league - the only transfer fee spent was £68k on Chris McKee, a highly-rated 17 year old striker from Rangers. Unfortunately, McKee turned out to be not quite ready for first team football and the ageing squad suffered a number of irritating recurring injuries as we finished second in the league. We went on to lose narrowly in the playoff semi-final against Clyde.
2020/21 season:
In my first full summer, I shifted a few of the older players and high earners, replacing them with 12 new faces, a combination of loans and free transfers. Some of the loan incomings were really great additions and certainly too good to be playing in League 1. The best of the bunch were Saul Shotton (ball-playing CB on loan from West Brom) and Yan Dhanda (a goal-scoring #10 on loan from Swansea), whilst Chris McKee started to show exactly why he was highly rated. He managed 12 goals plus 5 assists on our way to winning the league with a game to spare, ahead of second placed Dundee.
2021/22 season:
Ahead of the third season, I was pretty confident in the squad which had won promotion, so renewed all of the existing loan deals and mostly only added young, high-potential players identified by my scouts. In real life, Falkirk previously had a well-renowned youth academy and a good number of professionals playing in Scotland had come through the system, however they closed it down a few years ago in order to cut costs. In FM, the club’s board like to see players signed under the age of 23 with potential to play for the first team, as well as avoiding signing players aged 30 or over - requirements with which I am more than happy to comply.
The only transfer fee which I spent during this summer window was £60k on Fabio Lopes, a 19 year old Portuguese striker from Dundee. Although I had won the league and Dundee finished second, Lopes was the league’s top scorer by some distance and he appeared to be on an upward trajectory, so I felt that he was worth the cash. It turned out to be a great piece of business, as Lopes scored 22 goals in 29 league games (25 goals in 39 apps, in all comps), leading us to another league title and back-to-back promotions!
Unfortunately for Chris McKee, the form of Lopes meant that he was dropped to the bench most weeks, as the two teenagers competed for the single starting spot in a 4-2-3-1 formation. In the January transfer window, Hibs came in with an offer of around £100k for McKee and his agent informed me that the player might become unsettled if he wasn’t allowed to speak to them. I made a counter-proposal to Hibs’ offer and they came back with a structured deal of around £200k up front, a further £175k in instalments, plus £100k if McKee made a single international appearance (he’s from Northern Ireland, so the clause seemed somewhat likely to be triggered). I accepted the offer and during the next season, McKee was called up to his first international squad, triggering the bonus payment and adding to an already very tidy profit for the club.
The other big positives of the season were our impressive cup runs. We dominated the match and were unfortunate to lose 1-0 to Inverness Caley Thistle in the Challenge Cup Final and managed to reach the quarter finals of the Scottish Cup, where we lost 1-0 away to Aberdeen. In the previous round, we were drawn against Rangers and managed a credible 0-0 draw at home and then scored to take a late 2-1 lead in the replay at Ibrox, after Timothy Fosu-Mensah had been sent off for the hosts. Frustratingly, my usually reliable goalkeeper, Robbie Mutch, dropped a howler in the last minute to allow Isaac Success to equalise for Rangers, but we managed to win the penalty shootout to secure a famous victory.
2022/23 season:
In truth, I felt that we had perhaps reached the Scottish Premier League one season too early and that the squad may struggle to cope with the increase in quality of opposition. I was given a decent transfer budget of around £800k and around £10k per week in additional wage budget - huge sums compared to what I had worked with to date, but perhaps not sufficient to improve each area of the squad which needed upgrading. As such, I renewed most of the same loan deals again - the squad had been dominant in winning the league and many of those loan players were young, so should hopefully be improving and perhaps be enough for us to avoid relegation.
However, two vital additions were made to the squad with the signing of Teden Mengi on a free transfer from United (wow!) and Octavio Gomes, a 19-year old regen striker on loan from AC Milan. Gomes had been brought in on loan from Sporting Lisbon during the previous January window to take Chris McKee’s vacated spot on the bench, but then went on to score 6 goals in 11 games. I was unable to renew his loan after Milan spent £12m to sign him on a permanent deal, but I thought it was worth trying my luck to then immediately sign him on loan again from Milan. Milan accepted the offer and Gomes said that he had enjoyed his previous loan spell, so the deal was concluded quickly.
The season got off to a bad start, although the fixtures weren’t kind to us. We started with a disappointing 3-1 loss away at Hearts, followed by another draw with Rangers (unbeaten in three matches against Gerrard’s men at this point, so I think we might be their bogey team!). However, any positives which could be taken from holding one of the big teams to a draw were promptly negated in the next game, as a Diogo Dalot-inspired Celtic destroyed us 5-0 away from home - Eric Dier and Harry Winks were amongst the scorers too. Celtic seem to do great business in buying cheap European talent and then flipping them on to English clubs for a large profit after a season or two, a bit like real life I guess, so they have plenty of money and a strong squad. The heavy loss against Celtic was compounded by an agonising 3-2 loss at home against Hamilton, then a 1-0 defeat away at St Johnstone, leaving us bottom of the table with only 1 point from our opening 5 matches. It was looking likely to be a long and difficult season.
In response, I ripped-up my tactics based on the advice of my coaches, changing from our tried and tested 4-2-3-1 which had worked in the lower leagues, but now seemed to be leaking goals and not creating many chances for our attackers either. The coaches advised a vertical tiki-taka approach with a 5-2–1-2 formation, making the most of our strong wing backs, although also making the squad’s handful of wingers pretty much redundant. Given the terrible results so far, it seemed worth a shot - and it worked! We went unbeaten in the next 7 league games, winning 4 of them and conceding only 2 goals in the process.
Right now, we are in the mid-season break for the winter World Cup in Qatar (I initially looked at the large gap in my upcoming fixtures and thought the game had broken!) and we’re sitting 6th place in the league. I’m hopeful that this new system will be enough for us to stay up, but it will be put to the test immediately after the restart, with matches against Celtic then Rangers back-to-back. Also, at the end of this season, several of my players’ contracts are expiring and I know most of them are not really good enough for this level, so it’s likely to be an extremely busy summer of both incoming and outgoing transfers. It’ll be vital to replace the departing players with quality, in order to push on and hopefully cement our place in the top division.
On a side note, the 2022 World Cup final was a 0-0 draw between Denmark and Turkey, with Turkey going on to win a penalty shootout. I suspect there were some decent odds on that outcome at the start of the tournament…
If people are interested, I’ll provide an update at the end of the season.