WireRed
Full Member
You're saying that Evans and Smalling haven't both gotten a lot of play time? You want to play with fewer options than before and give those two a bigger role right away?
Sorry but no. Smalling is still very inexperienced and you see a nervy mistake from him every game. It just hasn't cost us much yet, except for the soft penalty.
Evans has been an under average performer this season and that's basing it on a player like him, not Rio or Vidic quality. He's been a liability this season. So the progress I thought he made last season might be a one off deal and not a permanent thing. You just don't know. And with a CB and a GK I don't want to take that chance. If you do you have an Arsenal on your hand.
Smalling shouldn't panic. He's only 21. Evans is only 23 and has got 44 league games with us and 18 with Sunderland. It's uneasy that he's got 130 games under the belt, 18 of them in Europe, with Smalling outperforming him and being so less experienced. You'd think that a player 2 years your junior would be the needed kick up the butt and I hope he proves that the next season.
But unless Rio is guaranteed to be fit next season we should ponder a CB buy. Not to rival Evans and Smalling but to rival Rio for his position.
Most of all I hope that Rio will do a Nesta and get rid of his problems.
Let's get it straight though, Rio will be on the books next season. That gives us 5 quality CB's in our ranks(Vidic, Evans, Rio, Brown, and Smalling), that is more than enough cover except in extreme circumstances. You can't go and chuck £10m or more on a player on the grounds that we might need him if ALL our CB's are unavailable, it's just not something you can legislate for. The cheap, over the hill signing is just pointless aswell.
On Evans, adversity is something most young player's go through, but the talented and mentally strong ones come through and end up better player's. I've no doubt that Jonny will do the same, that's why I see signing someone else as futile. He was class in 08/09 and most people forget, was Vidic's principal partner in our 14 straight clean sheets. He covered Ferdinand extremely well for most of last season, hence our impressive defensive stats in 2009/10. This is his first blip in form, but he'll come good again and become one of the pillars upon which Fergie's next team is built on and the world-class defender we know/he's shown he can be. Bringing someone in would just slow that process considerably aswell as impact on Smalling's impressive development since being given his opportunity, an opportunity he'd have not been given had we had a Shawcross/Cahill/has-been in the squad.