The Shadow of What was Lost (The Licanius Trilogy #1)
- James Islington
Overall: +7
An interesting read that'll fulfill all the fans who liked WoT, but in the end book 1 does not set itself apart from being a WoT inspired work rather than a new work of its own. But it does just enough to make you continue the series.
Freshness: +6
A standard coming of age fantasy novel. Young protagonists coming into power, unknown foe to be defeated, legendary sword to be acquired, unstable political situation...all the standard trope for this genre has been covered. The author manages to give the proceedings a twist to keep things novel and this works a great deal to this not looking like a WoT clone. The world building feels very familiar from get go. Magic system is intriguing, but nothing revolutionary. Power within yourself, power drawn externally fighting with magic compulsion vs controlling, seeing vs foretelling, angreal vs vessels....there are many similarities again to WoT.
Characters: +8
The protagonist duo is nothing new. Usual kid with mysterious past coming into his powers, his friend is a powerful bureaucrats. But rather than plug them into one quest, the way author split their paths was nice. Davian becoming harder and the out of blue beginning of relationship between Caeden and princess, just felt off and not organic. The character which elevates this is Aarkein Devaed. Very promising character with lots of complexity and highly intriguing. Am looking to get to know him more.
Writing/Plot: + 7
Writing style is good. Author keeps the pages ticking without being a drag. Although the books feels slightly bloated as characters are in finding out stage, but nothing to be a detriment. The books at the end felt like a intro/place setter rather than the first step to a journey.