Got the ball, shouldn't be a pen
FA Cup Semi Finals - 22/23 April - Brighton vs Man Utd
- Thread starter The Corinthian
- Start date
Not a penalty. I take it back.
No.
How is that a penalty?? Got the ball.
Oh it's been given and not much scrutiny eh? Ffs
never a penalty... and what about the offside?
Where’s VAR
Eh? So they just won’t bother applying the rules?
Ridiculous decision.
Mad that Haaland isn't taking this.
His favourite day is wednesday.
It can't be just me that things he got the ball
FFS ref check the screen. flood gates will likely open after that lucky penalty now
1-0. Game over.
What is the point of VAR if that doesn't get overturned. If it was United, we'd get 1000 replays and complaints
Probably because he missed his last one
utter bullshit pen, he got the ball first
What an insane foul to give away.
Can switch this off now then
That's that then.
So he got the ball and akanji was offside, but it’s not an obvious error?
So this is the new season from hell after Liverpool’s CL and PL wins. Life as a United just keeps getting better post SAF 
penalty or not, cant fault the taking of it, it was perfect, was never being saved.
city always get the decisions, why the surprise?
Never a pen, not even checked by the bent officials.
cnuts.
cnuts.
Another VAR abomination as Abu Dhabi’s doped up project score at a Wembley FA Cup Semi. The state of modern football.
Either way, that was such a stupid swipe at the ball. As soon as he swung at it, you knew Silva would throw himself to the ground.
We probably don't get the pen in the first place tbf. We've had way more obvious ones turned down this season.
I don't think it should matter if you get a tiny touch on the ball - Silva was still in possession of the ball, and your man clattered him.
He usually scores them in low pressure situations
So this is the new season from hell after Liverpool’s CL and PL wins. Life as a United just keeps getting better post SAF
Thankfully we've got a nice and easy cup game tomorrow to cheer us up.
Just you and any other who let their bias get in the way of facts. It's a clear pen. The defender genuinely thought he could clear it, but hacks Bernardo Silva instead.
I thought it was a clear pen on first viewing, typical striker challenge in the box but replay shows he toes the ball and barely contacts with Silva who makes a dramatic fall.
It really should've been a VAR on pitch review as ref would've had second thoughts seeing those replays.
That there wasn't just shows how wrong the implementation is.
Actually surprised Man. City have gone as full strength as they have given the Arsenal game upcoming.
Forget bias, I thought it was a penalty on first view
On the replay it shows he gets the ball. Are you saying the defender only hit the player and not the ball?
Yeah, him and anyone with eyes. He got the ball, so stop Vardying
It’ll be a long while before we can cheer if they win the treble. We have to make the final and give ourselves a shot at silverware and stopping them.Thankfully we've got a nice and easy cup game tomorrow to cheer us up.
Bruno wouldn't get a penalty for that
Sheik on the phone
"Hacks" 
Need to get Case to drop Madrid some motivational messages because honestly that's our only hope