ermmmmmm..how does this work then

DJS said:
Unless you're a mind reader, you dont always weaste.

I know my own intentions when i post, better than anyone else. And my post where i stated that i felt Carrick was overpriced wasnt intended to provoke, it was an expression of my opinion.

By your definition, the vast majority of posts could be deemed as wummery, as they could be considered 'provocative' if you look at them from that perspective.

You know i'm right here weaste.

You know it's wummery by the context it is in, it's quite clear whether a post is a simple critique or simply meant to provoke or stir the shit, quite clear.
 
WeasteDevil said:
You paid 14m (exactly the same) for Cisse, I didn't see you complaining about that.

Why would i complain about Cisse on a Carrick thread?

You're being daft here weaste, if there was a thread about Cisse, i might well express my views on him in it.

But the thread was about Carrick and i expressed an opinion, which got me banned from the MU forum.

Basically says that we're allowed to post opinions...as long as they're in line with those of the status quo....
 
WeasteDevil said:
You know it's wummery by the context it is in, it's quite clear whether a post is a simple critique or simply meant to provoke or stir the shit, quite clear.

Clearly not weaste, because mine wasnt intended to...yet it was perceived to have been intented to provoke.

As i say, i know my own intentions. And being wrong once in a while is not a crime, or anything to be ashamed of fella.
 
SmashedHombre said:
quiet non united fan and go make ret his tea. (its dinner by the way ret you northern tard.)
No No NOOO! dinner is at 12.
 
DJS said:
Clearly not weaste, because mine wasnt intended to...yet it was perceived to have been intented to provoke.

Was it me who did you on that occasion? I don't think so.
 
WeasteDevil said:
Don't start you uncultured Hullite.
You are the 2nd person to say that to me today the 1st been someone trying to tell me to read viz instead of kerrang, irrevlevant i know.
 
retirantmobs said:
You are the 2nd person to say that to me today the 1st been someone trying to tell me to read viz instead of kerrang, irrevlevant i know.

Kerrang has gone gay. Only an uncultured Hullite would read that
 
WeasteDevil said:
Was it me who did you on that occasion? I don't think so.

No, i didnt think it was. You're one of the mods who actually listens and doesnt always assume he's always right.

Clearly though, you're not all reading from the same hymn sheet and such inconsistencies make things a bit ridiculous, i'm sure you agree.
 
WeasteDevil said:
We are talking about dinner vs lunch vs tea here, not Viz vs Heavy Metal magazine, correct, irrelevant, and nice to see you back BTW.

DJS, am I wrong to class this https://www.redcafe.net/showthread.php?t=128318 as wummery?

I'd love to answer that Weaste, but as i'm sure you'll remember, i cannot view it.
 
WeasteDevil said:
Evidently I do, and now you are wumming the Admin/Help forum, lets not go there.

do you not see the point.

other fans join here to see rag opinions, it is probably the best place to get them too.

as opposing fans we join in, have a laugh, we have our opinions too, they might not be the opinions you are looking for but they are valid. as football fans we all see things differently.....in terms of united i rate brown a better defender than rio, i think scholes is wonderful and probably the english player of his generation, i rate fletcher as an above average prem player....................

,,,,but, because im a blue if have an opinion it is wummery........

if you want this place as united site just for united fans say so, introduce a test to prove they are rags if you must.

most will fail :smirk:
 
DJS said:
i'm sure you agree.

I possibly do, but people do read things in different ways don't they? Some people are more touchy than others on certain matters.

GB for example hates the transfer forum and everyone who ever posted in it to death. It doesn't bother me at all.
 
Does anyone actually remember what this thread was originally about by the way?
 
The Kippax Kid said:
do you not see the point.

other fans join here to see rag opinions, it is probably the best place to get them too.

as opposing fans we join in, have a laugh, we have our opinions too, they might not be the opinions you are looking for but they are valid. as football fans we all see things differently.....in terms of united i rate brown a better defender than rio, i think scholes is wonderful and probably the english player of his generation, i rate fletcher as an above average prem player....................

,,,,but, because im a blue if have an opinion it is wummery........

if you want this place as united site just for united fans say so, introduce a test to prove they are rags if you must.

most will fail :smirk:


There is nothing wrong with having a laugh, posting to provoke is different. Provoke threads regaring United should be started in the football forum, there is no problem about that.
 
What you should do weaste, is lift the ban and impose a 'clean slate' policy.

No one can then have any excuses and if they step out of line, they are justifiably re-banned, having been sufficiently warned.

That would be the right and fair thing to do.

No doubt then, that the idea will be dismissed out of hand, due to an apparent fear of any independent thought that doesnt follow the chosen mantra.
 
The Kippax Kid said:
and then they get moved to the united forum so we can no longer join in


that was the point of my thread.


if posted by a non rag, it should not be moved

The thread was posted by a celtic supporter as far as I remember that had access to the United forum, you didn't start the thread. People without access to the United forum that start threads about United in the Football forum should not have their posts moved, I agree with you on that.
 
WeasteDevil said:
The thread was posted by a celtic supporter as far as I remember that had access to the United forum, you didn't start the thread. People without access to the United forum that start threads about United in the Football forum should not have their posts moved, I agree with you on that.

:D

thanks weastie :angel:
 
I'm moving all transfer related threads to the transfer forum, even though no one is allowed in there anymore

That's just the kind of guy I am