Erling Haaland / signs for Dortmund

Status
Not open for further replies.
Obviously i'd love it if Haaland came to Utd, but i can see why he would choose Dortmund.

Even if he only went for a couple of seasons, Raiola would then get an even bigger money move for him to Utd (or any other big European club) if he performs well.

However, there is of course the flip side that we're offering Raiola a tasty 'agents fee' to have him now?
 
Rozay said:
Not in favour of this deal. Sancho is the next forward we should be going after. Signing a 19 year old back up striker when we already have an 18 year old back up striker, one who is scoring goals when given the chance, makes little sense to me. 3 strikers after one spot is not an ideal scenario. Yes, Greenwood can play on the right, but you would hope that is only temporary , however, unless Haaland is totally terrible, I don’t think it possibly can be. And I think Greenwood is a bigger talent than Haaland personally, or as big a talent anyway.
Click to expand...
The obvious casualty is Martial, too lazy and inconsistent, Haaland or no Haaland I cannot see Martial retaining his 1st choice status for many more months
 
Rozay said:
Not in favour of this deal. Sancho is the next forward we should be going after. Signing a 19 year old back up striker when we already have an 18 year old back up striker, one who is scoring goals when given the chance, makes little sense to me. 3 strikers after one spot is not an ideal scenario. Yes, Greenwood can play on the right, but you would hope that is only temporary , however, unless Haaland is totally terrible, I don’t think it possibly can be. And I think Greenwood is a bigger talent than Haaland personally, or as big a talent anyway.
Click to expand...
Why can't we go for both? I wouldn't worry about Greenwood but we can't accept that Martial will be our first choice for the next few years. He just doesn't have the consistency to be first choice striker for us and the only reason he is now is because we have no other obvious first choice. If Greenwood continues getting his chances and scoring when he does, I can honestly see him displacing Martial very soon. We're a club in rebuild and when you can improve on a position you do.
 
Zed 101 said:
The obvious casualty is Martial, too lazy and inconsistent, Haaland or no Haaland I cannot see Martial retaining his 1st choice status for many more months
Click to expand...

So if he is not first choice, what is he? Second choice? That still leaves one teenage striker looking for scraps? Or are they both better than him, and he’ll be third choice? Then what, we sell him, and have two teenage strikers that’s it?
 
Seems weird to call Haaland a back up striker when our main striker is Martial, who really on his output should be a backup striker.

If we go into next season with Martial as our main striker it would be baffling, unless of course the second half of the season it finally clicks for him, thats unlikely though.
 
dev1l said:
Ornstein usually has a good track record with United transfers, no?
Click to expand...
I can't comment on that as I know very little about the british media landscape. I just wanted to weigh in on the notion of Dortmund leaking information to Bild since I would assume that if they were to do anything of the sort it would be to a different news outlet. I am actually advocating against Bild being a credible source here so that should be good news for you guys ;)
 
Judas said:
Seems weird to call Haaland a back up striker when our main striker is Martial, who really on his output should be a backup striker.

If we go into next season with Martial as our main striker it would be baffling, unless of course the second half of the season it finally clicks for him, thats unlikely though.
Click to expand...
Martial is so talented but at times can’t be bothered to break sweat to cover or chase.
 
dwd said:
Is Fjortoft reliable?
Click to expand...
He works regularly on German football TV.

He probably does hear snippets and news from people in the clubs - we know Dortmund are interested so that isn't a shock.

When the final decision comes down to it, I doubt anybody will know before the people closest to the clubs (unless it's leaked).
 
Rozay said:
So if he is not first choice, what is he? Second choice? That still leaves one teenage striker looking for scraps? Or are they both better than him, and he’ll be third choice? Then what, we sell him, and have two teenage strikers that’s it?
Click to expand...
I would sell or trade off Martial, he is too much of a luxury, but he will do until the end of the season, by that time if we sign him hopefully Haaland will have shown his metal, can review at the end of the season, but right now players signing options are scarce, seems like Haaland will move in January to take a chance seems like a no brainer, it is certainly not going to weaken our team, whereas going the rest of the season with Martial no.1 and Greenwood no.2 is begging for disappointment IMO
 
For me if this is a thing, it's probably already sorted.
 
do.ob said:
I mean in this case Bild were the ones to break the release clause which now basically everyone assumes to be true. Ornstein on the other hand wrote "it is believed (by whom?) that United have been given encouragement (what does that even mean? did he smile at Solskjaer on Friday?) in an article that's not even centered on Haaland, but a watering can piece, where he offers/pretends to have inside information for the whole league. You'd think that if he actually had worthwhile and (sort of) exclusive info on such a hyped up transfer he'd write a separate article about it to highlight his ITK status and collect more clicks, instead of hiding a non-commital throwaway comment within his weekly know-it-all piece.

Within a couple of hours we had Ornstein saying his piece, a local Salzburg paper releasing a pay-walled article with the headline "Salzburg fighting to keep Haaland, but Leipzig have the best chance", we had Bild claiming he's probably bound for Germany and we had this tweet from a well respected Norwegian sports journalist :


Though to be fair one of the Dortmund Twitter ITKs claimed it was done deal on sunday and I wouldn't put it past good old Jan Aage to have taken inspiration from him.
Click to expand...

Do Dortmund know how to develop young players? They seem to flop as they age?
 
Paul InceUlt said:
Anyone else who interpreted Ole’s remarks on what Haaland wants to do and what he’s going to do as if he’s made a decision that’s based on what he ought(Raiola) to do, not what he really wants? Maybe I’m being a bit paranoid here....
Click to expand...

Ole's quotes sound like we're definitely not getting him.
 
Judas said:
Seems weird to call Haaland a back up striker when our main striker is Martial, who really on his output should be a backup striker.

If we go into next season with Martial as our main striker it would be baffling, unless of course the second half of the season it finally clicks for him, thats unlikely though.
Click to expand...

I feel pretty certain we won't go into next season with Martial as first choice striker.
 
Swarm said:
I can't comment on that as I know very little about the british media landscape. I just wanted to weigh in on the notion of Dortmund leaking information to Bild since I would assume that if they were to do anything of the sort it would be to a different news outlet. I am actually advocating against Bild being a credible source here so that should be good news for you guys ;)
Click to expand...
Maybe it s Raiola then leaking info...:)
 
Rozay said:
Not in favour of this deal. Sancho is the next forward we should be going after. Signing a 19 year old back up striker when we already have an 18 year old back up striker, one who is scoring goals when given the chance, makes little sense to me. 3 strikers after one spot is not an ideal scenario. Yes, Greenwood can play on the right, but you would hope that is only temporary , however, unless Haaland is totally terrible, I don’t think it possibly can be. And I think Greenwood is a bigger talent than Haaland personally, or as big a talent anyway.
Click to expand...

Always baffled by comments like this. Very different players, different positions. Also very unlikely sancho will come here now... He has his pick of clubs in world football. Also, let's say we hope for sancho, does that mean we should turn down opportunies to sign other players? Or do NOTHING until we either sign Sancho or someone else does?
 
dev1l said:
Maybe it s Raiola then leaking info...:)
Click to expand...
Entirely possible, I am not claiming Bild don't have any information, I just don't assume that any Dortmund representative leaked information to them.
 
cyberman said:
Do Dortmund know how to develop young players? They seem to flop as they age?
Click to expand...

It's hardly Dortmund's fault that some players (and the clubs who buy them) seem to believe they are better than they actually are. Or that some players join clubs that don't fit them.

If a player leaves the club it's up to him to pick a suitable new home and make it work there.
 
Sportwitness is now quoting a somewhat credible salzburg newspaper, saying the Solskjær trip seems unsuccessful because Haaland is most likely going to Bundesliga.

Cant seem to link it.
 
EngimaMK said:
How reliable are SW though?
Click to expand...

Not sure but that article is woeful. He "probably" won't go to Utd as he might go to Red Bull Leipzig, but then again he might go to Dortmund but he could also stay at RB Salzburg is the general jist of that article
 
EngimaMK said:
Always baffled by comments like this. Very different players, different positions. Also very unlikely sancho will come here now... He has his pick of clubs in world football. Also, let's say we hope for sancho, does that mean we should turn down opportunies to sign other players? Or do NOTHING until we either sign Sancho or someone else does?
Click to expand...

Allow me to unbaffle you. They are different players, so what? They are both strikers, of which we play one, whom they would, I imagine, both like to be. Despite whatever you have seen in the Austrian league, both players are teenagers and require games to develop into the full version of themselves. With one senior striker (despite his unpopularity on Redcafe at the moment), they will likely play the role of understudy. Both are top talents, and should be the sole understudy.

Now, Jadon Sancho. He has his pick of clubs. Okay, so what? None of us are qualified to say he is ‘very unlikely’ to come here. Of those who may perhaps know something, the story is not that we are the least likely option at all.

Lastly, because we hope for Sancho does not mean we should turn down opportunities to turn down other players. What would be sensible is if we cannot get Sancho, we go for another player who can offer a similar contribution to Sancho. Basically, if we have a first choice winger we want, get the second choice one if we can’t get him.

Aguero/Jesus = Iheanacho leaving.
Vardy/Iheanacho = Slimani leaving.

We need two strikers. We also have Rashford who, in an emergency, can move across and play as a 9. We do not need more than two. There is no indication that Ole Solskjaer shares this week’s Redcafe position on Martial. The fans may want him sold, yet all indication is he is an important player. I suspect Haaland will be given the chance to overtake him as a rotation option/deputy. Because he will be offered that chance, Greenwood will not. Do you guys expect us to play a different 9 every game for 5 months or something? It won’t happen. Martial will start most games. And if he doesn’t, he will come off the bench in them. He’s not going to suddenly be ostracised by Ole. Just let Greenwood play when Martial doesn’t, and if he can overtake him by end of the season, great.
 
Definitive a younger version of Lukaku. Lukaku just gain too much weight getting older. Same type of player and prefer foot.

If United buy him. I think and suggest United and Ole has to drop the nr.10 and go for 2 strikers up front. Why?
Because you only use the nr.10 role. Only you have the players and qualities of Cantona, Zidane, Platini, Kaka and Dele Alli. If not, better go for 2 nature really good strikers up front.

Example:

Sancho/James - McTom - Pobga/Kristoffer Olsson - Rashford + Greenwood/Haaland - Martial/Rashford.

Instead Ole is using Lindard, Mata and Perreira in that role. You can see why United are struggling.

Rashford, Martial, Greenwood and Haaland should be 4 good enough CF options in the future.

But i will just remind the Ole and club. Have and buy another really good nr.8, beside Pobga as the creative cm. If not even Messi will struggle in this team without Pobga and a Kristoffer Olsson level above. Not talk about Haaland will struggle. Because without noone feeding you with the trough passes and build up the attack from the deep, the top service. How will you score?United without Pogba problem this season. The lack of top qualities from the deep cm areas.
 
Re. : Ole s comment " the player know where he s going to".
Some months ago a Barcelona official said the same thing about DeLigt when there was still lot of speculation about the player.
 
You know there's a TW window close by when the "Are SW reliable?" questions start to pop up again. Like the sparrows of transfer windows.
 
Judas said:
Seems weird to call Haaland a back up striker when our main striker is Martial, who really on his output should be a backup striker.

If we go into next season with Martial as our main striker it would be baffling, unless of course the second half of the season it finally clicks for him, thats unlikely though.
Click to expand...

I mean he hasn't been pulling up trees but given it's his first season back as a striker and he's been injured for a period then i think 6 goals from 12-13 starts is pretty good.
 
stevoc said:
I mean he hasn't been pulling up trees but given it's his first season back as a striker and he's been injured for a period then i think 6 goals from 12-13 starts is pretty good.
Click to expand...

Yeah but he's also inconsistent in performances and always has been. I don't think he's one we can rely on over the course of a season when you consider his injuries on top.
 
ShinjiNinja26 said:
Click to expand...

Replace with Norwegian flag..

EntireDescriptiveGermanshorthairedpointer-size_restricted.gif
 
Every country has their own journalist saying he's close to join them.

Let's just see what happens.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.