Donny van de Beek image 34

Donny van de Beek Netherlands flag

2022-23 Performances

View full 2022-23 profile

4.7 Season Average Rating
Appearances
10
Goals
0
Assists
0
Yellow cards
0
Status
Not open for further replies.
The summer 2020 transfer window is the biggest example of United having zero strategy in the market.

Van de Beek, Amad, Pellistri, Telles, Cavani. A random collection of players, only one of which really helped us (and him only for a short while).

Donny's time at United has been a complete waste for everyone involved. I wish it wasn't so. However, how can you deny it now? He's got the coach who nurtured him and he still can't produce..?
 
The holy trinity 68 said:
Van De Beek is the number 1 worst signing in United history.

Pogba is miles ahead, he was great once upon a time. AWB had good periods, Sanchez has slightly good spells, Newcastle comeback comes to mind.

Donny has done absolutely nothing.
Click to expand...

I’d argue Schneiderlin takes that title but if Donny doesn’t manage a decent game till the end of this season then he can definitely be in with a shout.
 
FrantikChicken said:
I’d argue Schneiderlin takes that title but if Donny doesn’t manage a decent game till the end of this season then he can definitely be in with a shout.
Click to expand...

Agreed on Schneiderlin being a disaster. I was so excited for Schmidfield too. What a let down that turned out to be.

Speaking of let downs - Donny looks completely lost. He was a weird purchase at the time and has somehow been worse than even his detractors at the time could have imagined.

Hopefully he can find some sort of role in there with ETH's help and contribute going forwards because at the moment I'd rather see the likes of Iqbal given the minutes to be honest.

It's a shame.
 
Just looks completely disinterested and unwilling to work.

In fact it's more than likely his ability, he's out of his depth, Davy Klassen standard.
 
He's absolutely terrible. Has no personality or belief in himself at this level. Most of the time when someone says X player is like playing with 10 men it is an exaggeration, but with this fella it ain't. In the course of the game he does very little. Doesn't even run hard like Lingard and Pereirra did!
 
Nothing player.Probably a candidate for the worst UTD signing in the EPL era.
He just does nothing. He can not even be shit on the pitch so that you can say "ok, he is shit".
Coward.
 
FrantikChicken said:
I’d argue Schneiderlin takes that title but if Donny doesn’t manage a decent game till the end of this season then he can definitely be in with a shout.
Click to expand...
As much as he was terrible, didn't we manage to rip off Everton and recoup most of the money we paid to Soton for him.

We'll be lucky to get even half of Donny's transfer fee back.
 
Like Schneiderlin, I was initially excited about having him but my god he looks so lost on the pitch and you’re frustrated as to how someone who looked good at a similar level suddenly looks so ineffective.

Clearly another player who’s great for a certain level of club but out of depth if they moved up the ladder.

Need to cut him loose sadly. Alarm bells were ringing after being so anonymous for an absolute dogshit Everton team that teetered on relegation last season.
 
Did he peak on his debut sub appearance where he scored when we lost?

Can't think of anything other than that :lol:
 
I don't think I've ever watched a player struggle to get involved in the game as much as him. I've seen a bunch of shite players play for us but they at least tried to make things happen, they just weren't capable.

I didn't think it was possible to be less involved than Cleverley buy Donny has successfully achieved that. He's a player you can predict exactly how his 90mins will go.
 
El Jefe said:
I don't think I've ever watched a player struggle to get involved in the game as much as him. I've seen a bunch of shite players play for us but they at least tried to make things happen, they just weren't capable.

I didn't think it was possible to be less involved than Cleverley buy Donny has successfully achieved that. He's a player you can predict exactly how his 90mins will go.
Click to expand...

He needs to visit Specsavers. Maybe it might help at pointing him on where to go.

We essentially played with 9 men against villa.
 
Made my mind up on him a long time ago and nothings changed... Has zero stand out quality.
 
How the hell did he carve out a top level career and played for 2 massive clubs? Not only that he had an agreement to sign for Madrid too. Like what the hell? What is he even good at? Caf experts tell me he is so good technically, makes amazing runs etc. And that’s enough?

The guy doesn’t have any passing range, can’t carry the ball, can’t run with it, doesn’t have a good vision, can’t impose himself at all, can’t dictate the play, isn’t physical, isn’t aggressive, doesn’t have a good shot in him, can’t take set pieces and free kicks, isn’t tricky or a speedster. Is he a silent dominating midfielder then? Is that it?
 
I agree with anyone and everyone that labeled him a "Nothing player" he needs to be put out of his misery. If we can get 15m for him I'll call it good business.
 
We need to let him go and perhaps he can kickstart his career somewhere. He's never going to get a run of games or be trusted long enough here now. Looks like needs a full season of playing to get back to some kind of match and mental sharpness in another country.

A spare wheel signing that's always flat as a pancake when you go check and need it.
 
Trash player but if we sell him we will have more work to do for depth.
 
Very very sad for him. It's not working out. Should leave the club soonest.
 
Luckily his contract expires on 2024, so if we don't find a club to sell maybe loan until his contract runs out so we can save the wages.

Maybe some team from the bundesliga or the Eredivisie would take him.
 
It's confusing of why EtH couldn't get a decent performance from a player he has done it before.

Although, I'd say that it's common sense to give more chances to your 40m investment, for more than 2 games (under a new manager).
 
Isotope said:
It's confusing of why EtH couldn't get a decent performance from a player he has done it before.

Although, I'd say that it's common sense to give more chances to your 40m investment, for more than 2 games (under a new manager).
Click to expand...

Not supporting VDB's performance here, but our overall gameplay was "pass the ball to Ronaldo, even if it's going to be a crappy pass". Ronaldo is basically dragging the entire transition & attack down with him and is a major liability to our team. I'd love to see VDB in a game without Ronaldo up front & how he performs?
 
bringbackbebe said:
Not supporting VDB's performance here, but our overall gameplay was "pass the ball to Ronaldo, even if it's going to be a crappy pass". Ronaldo is basically dragging the entire transition & attack down with him and is a major liability to our team. I'd love to see VDB in a game without Ronaldo up front & how he performs?
Click to expand...

Perhaps Ronaldo was affecting his game, but how do you explain his almost non-existent presence, though? Even if he played shit, he'd get more respect if he played like a madman with something to prove. Just like Fred or Bruno on their bad days.
But who knows, man. I want to see more of him, maybe not as a starter but with decent amount of game time.

When he left Ajax, I remember Ajax's fans were singing his name. You don't get that when an average player leaving.
 
Last edited:
AR87 said:
Starting him, especially with Ronaldo up top, in the PL was suicidal. A nothing player who should never get a minute for us again unless there is quite literally nobody else available to play.
Click to expand...

I have said it in the ETH thread. Starting Ronaldo with Donnie is like a hollowed-out bullet but firing backwards. Reverse effect
 
Ishdalar said:
He had better stats than Antony at Ajax and you can see how much Antony was signed for.

Issue being that Antony's game is about doing things with the ball, something that can be used in basically every team in the world, Van de Beek's game is without the ball, he's supposedly to be a 3rd man in the shadow that always makes the right decision in a quick way.

He's a player that excels at being invisible, that's something that creates obvious problems when he can't be involved and his teammates don't trust him enoguh (with reason at this point). It's like his superpower is seeing in the dark and then you put him 24/7 in a room with light, he stops being special.
Click to expand...
Honestly this is the most insightful thing I’ve read about him. Beek can basically do one thing - if - everyone else around him has been drilled into providing that moment for him.

I’ve given up on him after today.
 
Wing Attack Plan R said:
Honestly this is the most insightful thing I’ve read about him. Beek can basically do one thing - if - everyone else around him has been drilled into providing that moment for him.

I’ve given up on him after today.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I think he'll do okay when we sell him if the right team buys him, but my guess is he'll have a couple of decent moments where he and Martial link up okay and then he's done here after this season as we'll sign a proper #8 like Frenkie or Bellingham but sadly more likely someone not quite as good like Koopmeiner, Caqueret, Mac Allister, De Paul or Neves. and make Eriksen the backup 10.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.