I think you see the protests as protests from United fans to improve the situation at Man United so we can challenge for silverware again. What you care about is whether this can help United to win the CL or PL again.
While for me its a symptom of a bigger societal issue.
That's the difference of our views.
We, the people, elect officials that make those rules, however. And a main theme in the protest now is to institute the 50+1 rule which would eventually mean elections for club leadership. So you don't like and trust the people who make the rules but you would trust the people who would run the club? Even if they are elected in the same way?
I wouldn't trust them one bit to be honest. But I do believe there might be greater accountability and at least a system in place to change club leadership if needed. The more participation we have, the more we can voice our opinion and the more power we have.
Same reason I prefer to vote for the leadership of a country AND still vote for the leadership of my state AND the "leadership" of my city.
Also, the players ("we provide" is a stretch, by that logic, we also provide the billionaires...) are treated very well. I don't see any injustice there.
Id argue most players are from very common backgrounds (lets just take the 3 best Ronaldo, Messi, Neymar) and (a very small minority that make it) are on a good salary but still not owning the "company".
So I am talking about the dichotomy between people who work and provide everything and people who just live off our work.
You can be treated very well as a player, but you are still just a commodity, a number on Ed Woodwards Excel Sheet.
As for the consumers, well, then take actions with your consumption. Stop supporting billionaires.
As a consumer and fan I am exactly doing that. Not consuming football, not buying overly expensive football jerseys etc.
And I am glad that football fans are also taking action to hurt those billionaires.
But as consumers we can only do so much.
What we can do however is take matters in our hands and I am glad that the fans are taking back what truly belongs to us.
What historically we did on the continent (I am not sure how you Brits were holding your nobility accountable) was to bring out the Guillotine. So we remind those who own the places we work at, the houses we live in, the clubs that we watch football at... that in the end we own all of it and we might come get it. Those fan protests are a way to remind our billionaire owners and overlords, that we the common people wont let them take us for idiots anymore.)