Kraftwerker
Formerly RedAddict
Definitely Van Gaal's best signing IMO.
Hard to believe at the time he would be so influential.
Hard to believe at the time he would be so influential.
Well it took him half the season to realise the 3-5-2 and shoehorning Rooney/RVP/Falcao in the team wasn't working, so lets see how long it takes him to work this one out. Probably at least 3 months.
You say that though, but he clearly is a natural defender. He reads the game like the best and intercepts extremely well, if he wasn't there is no chance he would do so well at CB. obviously his limitations are his pace but because he reads the game so well he makes up for that difference, and he is actually stronger than we all thought, he rarely gets muscled off the ball.If you're going to defend by keeping the ball I can't think of many I'd rather have at the back. He's not the natural defender Pique is but he's doing the same job for us.
Every game there is at least a goal that starts with him or where he plays an important part. He is very important to the buildup. I had my doubts like everyone else, but it looks like this LVG chap knows what he's doing after all.
This also shows why we weren't interested in the likes of Otamendi this summer, we needed a ball playing CB. If we could have got Ramos, Hummels or some other CB with excellent passing they would have been invaluable to us, like having Blind on steroids.
Absolutely, he has to win every header, every physical challenge, no striker is allowed to get in behind him or we will hear he hasn't got the pace or strength to play there. It happens to every defender, if they perfect then nobody would score any goals.LvG deserves serious credit for this. Majority of the people weren't convinced by him when it started but I think his performances this season have proved a lot of people wrong.
What's funny is that he's not allowed to have a below average game on here. One mistake and the moan brigade will be out in full force.
Its the internet..many people do not want to be wrong..and will stick to an opinion no matter what..I thought playing him there was a ridiculous decision , considering his pace and strength, but I think I failed to consider his other strengths in making that judgement. His ball playing abilities fit our defense to the t and he fits the formation well. I was wrong.I think it's a little telling that if you look at the caf's average he is clearly below Darmian, Smalling and Shaw despite scoring a great goal, three assists and helping keep 6 clean sheets. He is judged more harshly than those others because certain people were convinced he couldn't do a job and every thing he does at CB is under the microscope.
Yeah but I'd sooner draw the comparison with Frank de Boer. In many ways a very similar player to Daley. Same height, fairly slow, but great vision and passing.He plays a similar role to what Rijkaard played for ajax in 1994/95 imo
You say that though, but he clearly is a natural defender. He reads the game like the best and intercepts extremely well, if he wasn't there is no chance he would do so well at CB. obviously his limitations are his pace but because he reads the game so well he makes up for that difference, and he is actually stronger than we all thought, he rarely gets muscled off the ball.
In pre season I really did dread the idea of him being our main CB, but now I couldn't imagine us without him at the back, he just gives us a completely different option, almost like a quarterback.
Smalling also does a great job of covering him, in the 1 striker systems they both work extremely well together.
I'm more impressed with him every game. One of our most improved players since LVG took over for sure. Great to see.
Do you think he's worked it out yet? Or should we give him a couple more months to get on the same page as you?
His best form for us was in his first few months here. I think he won one or two player of the months back then and until february or march people were calling him our player of the season so I have no idea how did you come up with that.
If he wasn't a good natural defender how would be look so solid all the time? Arguably Phil Jones isn't a natural defender in my eyes, everything he does is rushed or panicked.I think you're being extremely generous there.
His great games at the start of last season were always against teams that had 10 behind the ball, put no pressure on us and let us have all the possession. But he always struggled in high intensity physical games.
This season he had no problems marking the likes of Benteke and Gestede, I don't understand how you can't see the improvement?
I would still be nervous playing him vs better teams and better (and bigger) strikers, but he's done very well so far.
Ouch! You're cruel.Do you think he's worked it out yet? Or should we give him a couple more months to get on the same page as you?
No bigger strikers in PL then Gestede and Benteke and he has handled both of them quite comfortably.
It was our midfield that failed to deal with Mane appropriately. He was getting far too much space in the final third when Blind was occupied with Pelle. It seems to be that if a player scores a goal against a defence with Blind in it, it must be Blind's fault and therefore exposes him as not good enough at CB. Even top class centre halves get beaten, and sometimes by not very good players.Yet he struggled vs the size of Gomis and against the pace of Mane.
It was our midfield that failed to deal with Mane appropriately. He was getting far too much space in the final third when Blind was occupied with Pelle. It seems to be that if a player scores a goal against a defence with Blind in it, it must be Blind's fault and therefore exposes him as not good enough at CB. Even top class centre halves get beaten, and sometimes by not very good players.