This reductive post relating mere isolated incidents contains a veneer of balance but is highly misleading when looking at the broader context.
Ronaldo is only the most glaring example in a long line of poor player management by United. Whenever United get a world class star, they ruin him. He plays 1 or 2 troubled years and then gets cut or quits in frustration.Take some recent examples: Lukaku, Di Maria, Pogba, Cavani, and now Ronaldo. These were players at the top of the world before coming to United. Moreover, they regained their world class form as soon as they left!
Some of you will no doubt say that it’s cause the Premier League is so difficult. Ego-stroking nonsense. These players regularly destroyed Premier League sides. Lukaku was world class in the Premier League itself for an inferior club that gave him less opportunities! Plenty of players from less competitive leagues come to the PL and quickly establish themselves as the best in the league. Examples: Haaland from Germany, Suarez from Netherlands, and Tevez and Mascherano from Brazil!
Speaking of Tevez, some will say it is because foreign players have trouble adapting to England or the city of Manchester or fish & chips but this is not the case. Tevez, who was vital in Man United’s last truly great side, was carelessly let go. He transferred to our rival on the other side of town and was perfectly happy and super successful there for years!
Ronaldo’s son died. Did you hardhearted fans consider that it might be a reason for missing preseason? How many of you have had children die? Is it a relevant fact or should the death of his infant be cruelly ignored? Despite being 37 years old, he has shown no indication of a catastrophic decline and his commitment to fitness is unmatched. This is not like Brazilian Ronaldo eating too much feijoada, getting fat, and sinking like a rock. CR7 needs a run out to regain form.
In sum, Man United has a history of ruining world class stars by being too tactically rigid, forcing them into bad positions, acting impatiently, haranguing and disrespecting them. Players are important - who would have thought? Tactics should be designed around the players you have, not on whatever strikes the manager’s fancy or fits his ideology. The manager should not get into personal petty disputes with his players. The club must manage them like people, not machines. They are part of a club but they also have particular situations, aspirations, and even families - god forbid! No top player will want to sign with United given our destructive history.
Here’s a quote by Cavani who has been well-liked and performed excellently in all clubs, except for one. “The club & fans in Valencia give me a tremendous desire to repay their kindness on the pitch.”
I’ve been patient with Man United’s egregious mismanagement for years but this is the last straw! Likewise, Ronaldo has been patient and the walk-off was a justified lashing out against the oppression wrought on him directly by the tyrannical ETH and sneakily supported by the club administration and rabidly by its fans. Look at how ETH treated Casemiro. That’s all you need to know about the man.
I fear Cristiano Ronaldo dos Santos Aveiro will play his best World Cup, score 7 goals, and forcefully etch his name in the great book of football history while Man United slides into perennial midtable ignominy.