Lightbringer
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2016
- Messages
- 1,986
I am getting slightly panicked about nothing being announced yet I would hate to not see anything come out of this.
There was talk about the US getting around to staging competitions to keep the players in the States. Could be whats holding them back?
Can the title be changed so it’s clear this is Uniteds women’s team?
Ahh baited. Thought this was more youngsters being snapped up.
Always nice when they start to join in on a storyThe BBC are now saying this is happening.
We can hope but let's start with saying it takes us closer to the top 3 and maybe a cup.Is this big enough to propel United to title challengers?
Always nice when they start to join in on a story
We can hope but let's start with saying it takes us closer to the top 3 and maybe a cup.
The big three all have really top class starters, and City and Chelsea have strengthened not just their starting lineups but their squads this year. City are expected to sign Lucy Bronze and Alex Greenwood before the window closes as well.
There's no doubt though that the signings would put us firmly on the map for women's football, and should give us a real quality boost. Plus, they will definitely give us a new mental edge, and as older experienced players they'll give our young forwards like Lauren, Ella, Ivana that bit more time to develop.
Enough to turn us into champions? Hmmm, I always think we're going to defy the odds and come out on top, so yeah, why not
We can hope but let's start with saying it takes us closer to the top 3 and maybe a cup.
The big three all have really top class starters, and City and Chelsea have strengthened not just their starting lineups but their squads this year. City are expected to sign Lucy Bronze and Alex Greenwood before the window closes as well.
There's no doubt though that the signings would put us firmly on the map for women's football, and should give us a real quality boost. Plus, they will definitely give us a new mental edge, and as older experienced players they'll give our young forwards like Lauren, Ella, Ivana that bit more time to develop.
Enough to turn us into champions? Hmmm, I always think we're going to defy the odds and come out on top, so yeah, why not
Hmmm, well she's certainly a "take no prisoners" character and that can include refs. I don't think she's got a bad history of red cards though - just the odd one.Eventually I found some stuff which mostly seems to be Heath shouting at refs, fouling woman left and right and generally being a American female Roy Keane. Is this any sort of true reflection of her character?
Don’t really watch the US national woman’s team so thought I’d do some searching on the scouting database that is YouTube.
I see someone mentioned there was some sort of fan fiction that these two are in a relationship, I can confirm this is still going strong. I had to muddle through a tonne of videos on that subject and people micro analysing looks and passes during games to depict conflict in the relationship.
Eventually I found some stuff which mostly seems to be Heath shouting at refs, fouling woman left and right and generally being a American female Roy Keane. Is this any sort of true reflection of her character?
She seems to be screaming at people a lot and I do wonder how this competitive nature would be taken by the ladies. Seen James and Zelem get stuck in to people but none of them seem the vocal in your face type.
I haven't watched US football either so I caught a bit of Tobin Heath and Christen Press on youtube like you did (had to navigate around and avoid all the Preath vids). Heath seems quite skillful on the ball and more importantly is a forward so I don't get the Keane comparison. She's physical, yes, but not some all action midfielder. They both look quality though and can play wider as well.
I think they'll be a good addition to our team in terms of quality and I think they're a level above what we have. My bigger concern is that neither of them is a midfield general or a commanding CB, which is what we seem to be lacking.
I think if we’re aiming to break into top three, it’s the attacking situation that is the biggest difference. Katie Zelem, Jackie Groenen, Hayley Ladd and Lucy Staniforth is good coverage in midfield, and Abbir McManus and Millie Turneris a good CB pair.
Jane Ross and Sigsworth are not anywhere near the level of Sam Kerr and Pernille Harder, though, and Lauren James and Ella Toon need to continue improving to get there. It would also be good to take some of the pressure off Leah Galton.
I'd personally like a more commanding player than Ladd in midfield. It'd allow Zelem and Groenen to attack more. I've not watched much of Staniforth so cannot comment.
I'd also prefer one of McManus or Turner to be more physical. They've both pacy and hardworking, but I feel as though it's a tough game for them against more physical forwards.
I haven’t kept up with the women’s game in the US in awhile but I recall there was a fascination to assume that these two are in a relationship together. Fan fiction and analysing how they’re interacting with each other seemed to be a massive talking point.
well, those are interesting takes. I thought Ladd was one of our best players last season. Zelem is the captain type creatively, still young but growing into taking all the more responsibility it seems to me. What kind of leadership do you miss in Ladd?
I see the point about being bullied somtimes for McManus and Turner. Wouldn’t you think though that shutting out that is the differnce between first and second place, while the difference between third and fourth is more about scoring more goals against the medium quality teams in particular?
My comparison to Keane was more for the screaming shouting, arguing and fouling people with pretty blatant hacks. Not positionally.I haven't watched US football either so I caught a bit of Tobin Heath and Christen Press on youtube like you did (had to navigate around and avoid all the Preath vids). Heath seems quite skillful on the ball and more importantly is a forward so I don't get the Keane comparison. She's physical, yes, but not some all action midfielder. They both look quality though and can play wider as well.
I think they'll be a good addition to our team in terms of quality and I think they're a level above what we have. My bigger concern is that neither of them is a midfield general or a commanding CB, which is what we seem to be lacking.
Again haven’t watched the US woman’s team bar a couple of games but are they really that much better in quality? Game experience is probably a lot better but and I know I’m basically a James fan boy at this point but talent wise reckon she’d walk in to any team I’ve seen Including internationals. Just needs to up the experience and decisions/effort she puts in on the pitch.
Lauren will most likely get more and more gametime, she is still only 18 and had some injuryproblems as well. They are probably being careful with herPersonally I'd start James up front and Heath and Tobin on either side if it was up to me, with Galton rotating in for either James or whoever plays on the left. I thought James was fantastic in that role against Chelsea in the cup last season. Lot of quality on the ball + a lot of pace as well.
I'm actually unsure why she doesn't start more often. Fitness seems like the only reason that I can think of. Quality-wise, I'd start her ahead of Siggy. Ross is a backup striker by my reckoning.