A Minnesota dentist who who lied to federal authorities about where he shot a black bear was placed on probation for one year and fined $2,939 Tuesday in federal court.
Walter J. Palmer, 48, of Eden Prairie, Minn., was hunting black bear in northern Wisconsin in September 2006 when he received a call from one of his hunting guides who spotted a large bear track near Phillips.
Palmer wasn't licensed to hunt bear in the zone established near Phillips but drove there with Trent C. Waggoner, 40, Minong. The bear was located and Palmer shot it with a bow and arrow, said Assistant U.S. Attorney Stephen Sinnott.
Not until after the hunting party, which included Chad W. Barth, 36, also of Minong, looked at Palmer's tag did they realize he wasn't authorized to hunt in the zone in which he had taken the 500-pound bear, said Sinnott.
"There was no evidence to indicate they didn't know they were hunting were they weren't supposed to be," Sinnott said after court.
Palmer compounded his problem by taking his guide's advice to take the bear carcass to Minong and register it where he was authorized to hunt. Palmer then took it to Minnesota and within weeks was questioned by U.S. Fish and Wildlife agents to whom he twice falsely stated that he shot the bear near Minong, Sinnott said.
"This is a case where the cover up is worst than the crime because if it he had immediately came to his senses and admitted what he had done, he would probably be facing a citation or a misdemeanor," instead of a felony, Sinnott told District Judge Barbara Crabb.
Sinnott asked Crabb to impose a "significant fine," given Palmer's financial "wherewithal."
Crabb said the fine reflects the trophy bear's $2,650 market value and the $288 fine specified in Wisconsin hunting regulations. She also considered the consequences a felony conviction will have on Palmer's ability to prescribe medications; possible disciplinary action Minnesota dentistry examiners could take and his loss of the right to possess firearms.
The fine was also similar to the amount Palmer paid Barth and Waggoner as hunting guides, Crabb said. Palmer also offered one of guides $850 to "keep quiet" about the unlawful registration scheme, but it was refused, Crabb said.
"Your desire for a trophy black bear made you disregard Wisconsin hunting laws," Crabb said.
Palmer apologized to the court, his family and friends for his actions.
Defense attorney Douglas Kelley said Palmer didn't set out to violate any hunting laws that morning but his unspecified diagnosis probably "pushed him into a corner" and caused him to "panic."
Last week Crabb fined Barth and Waggoner $288 each for aiding Palmer in transporting wildlife across state lines in violation of Wisconsin law, a misdemeanor.