fergieisold
New Member
Anyone got the video of the goal? I could be wrong but how the hell some people are blaming him for it is bizarre. Looked to me like he nearly bailed Blind out with a great tackle that nearly stopped Costa.
Anyone got the video of the goal? I could be wrong but how the hell some people are blaming him for it is bizarre. Looked to me like he nearly bailed Blind out with a great tackle that nearly stopped Costa.
This. The kid was in the right place till Blind broke ranks ruining the whole shape and made everyone look out of position. That gamble by Blind should have only been made if his partners was next to him and not in a situation where your FBs end up being the last defenders.Only a small amount of blame for the goal in my eyes. Blind pushed out unnecessarily. CBJ had very little time to react, and he wasn't that far behind the defensive line.
Possibly the best crosser of the ball in the league.
He's got a left foot wand
Now we have the problem of when Shaw comes back obviously he gets fit and gets back in the team, what of CBJ, could we try him on the right?
Or could we try a Bale with Shaw and move him to the wing? And the CBJ can take LB?
It was both.. Borthwick-Jacko should've held the line..he was too busy watching Ivanovic(?) but hes inexperienced so it happens. Blind gambled and tried to intercept the pass, missed, then slipped trying to recover leaving Costa free.Well, imo he felt asleep and when other 3 defenders pushed forward he stayed and play Costa and Ivanovic onside.
Genuine question why do you think its Blinds fault?
He has, but he has to bear in mind that while whipping in a super dangerous cross along the edge of the six yard box would be great at most clubs and result in bags of goals, at United, he had to remember that Rooney and Martial will likely be behind the penalty spot. Hernandez would've thrived on his deliveries if he could stay onside.Possibly the best crosser of the ball in the league.
He's got a left foot wand
Why not the other way round? Because Shaw is by far the superior defender.Now we have the problem of when Shaw comes back obviously he gets fit and gets back in the team, what of CBJ, could we try him on the right?
Or could we try a Bale with Shaw and move him to the wing? And the CBJ can take LB?
I ll wait for Shaw's recovery and see the post-injury performances before I would say that. No one should have a position for granted.Why not the other way round? Because Shaw is by far the superior defender.
The world's at his feet. His defensive game will improve for the workout Willian gave him and he has a cool head.He's done well since he has come into the team. Fair play to him. Not sure how good he will het but he's made a promising start.
The world's at his feet. His defensive game will improve for the workout Willian gave him and he has a cool head.
And he's only just turned that!Definitely, and considering I hadn't even heard a thing about him before this season, is all the more impressive. Hard to believe he's only 19 and has been thrown in at the deep end. It was sink or swim for him really and right now he's swimming along quite nicely indeed.
Young lad has a couple of decent games and all of a sudden he's better than Shaw (QUOTE]
Who's said he's better than Shaw? I don't see any posts on this pageat least!this place is brilliant.
Young lad has a couple of decent games and all of a sudden he's better than Shaw (who was also crap and a waste of money at one point last season but has since then become the best lb in the world).
True but I just feel Shaw has that pace and agility that CBJ lacks, CBJ definitely has a better cross on him but Shaw has more of an ability to take players on which is suited to a winger I feel.Why not the other way round? Because Shaw is by far the superior defender.
Yup agreed, it's an interesting situation.True but I just feel Shaw has that pace and agility that CBJ lacks, CBJ definitely has a better cross on him but Shaw has more of an ability to take players on which is suited to a winger I feel.
There'd be room for both. You need backup and I'm sure CBJ may have a future centrally tooYup agreed, it's an interesting situation.
No, but he has been afforded more freedom to get forward than Shaw.He's better than shaw. Saying this to see how cassiusclaymore will react. :P
Not a single person thinks this. People just give credit to unexpected graduate youngster..this place is brilliant.
Young lad has a couple of decent games and all of a sudden he's better than Shaw (who was also crap and a waste of money at one point last season but has since then become the best lb in the world).
Hope you read the fine print thereNo, but he has been afforded more freedom to get forward than Shaw.
Besides, both are young and can add whatever skills they don't currently have. The basics are thereThere'd be room for both. You need backup and I'm sure CBJ may have a future centrally too
Not a single person thinks this. People just give credit to unexpected graduate youngster..
They were all injured. all of them.
CBJ might have earned his spot now, but he wasnt given a chance after our first and second choice got injured.
It took Shaw, Rojo, Young to get injured and even then Blind and Darmian were the preferred choice. Jones, McNair, Carrick have all been injured for large parts. Well.. McNair not for that long, but he was out for a good few weeks after rupturing his liver... which happened about the time CBJ and Tuanzebe were called up.
If I remember correctly, LVG even called Tuanzebe up to train with the squad before CBJ.
Van Gaal has given kids a chance. McNair and Blackett last season showed that.. But I really dont think he can get any credit for playing CBJ.
He had very little choice. There were plenty of injuries and whatever few players we had left were playing a lot at that time.
He pretty much had to look at the reserves for players and pick a left back from there.
CBJ got his chance and has made the most of it.
OK. So i didnt remember that and decided to look a that match report.CBJ came on against WBA in the 65th minute when we had Jones blind and rojo fit for the game. He could have not played him that game as we were protecting a 1-0 lead but chose to play him anyway. So yes he deserves credit.
A big moment for 18-year-old Cameron Borthwick-Jackson. He is on for his debut as Marcos Rojo goes off with what appears to be a minor injury. Can he help see this one out?
http://www.bbc.com/sport/live/football/34215408