Agreed. I assumed nobody took the caf player performance ratings too seriously until a few hours ago.
8
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 59
- Goals
- 14
- Assists
- 14
- Yellow cards
- 12
- Status
What’s weird about looking back on things that you wouldn’t remember rather than going with narrative? What’s weird is accepting the rating when it’s good and questioning it when it’s poor. This thread is full of weirdos. You fit in well.My favourite part of the post was when he prefixed it with "before the weirdos come in to counter my argument..." before then demonstrating peak weirdo behaviour by totting up each individual average match rating in an attempt to criticise his own player
Hypocrite. Sick of showing what a hypocrite you are. I’ll just leave your post there.What does this even mean? Every game fans watch and come back with an appraisal. There’s literally a thread for each players performance. Your only issue is that the game by game analysis doesn’t support your narrative.
If you're wanting to look back on things that you don't remember then surely in-game stats would be a better indicator of a player's performances? Why are you instead putting so much credence on the caf player ratings? I'm going to hazard a guess it's because Bruno's stats are pretty fecking good and therefore doesn't fit your narrative.
I've got no issues with player performance threads. They are a place for opinions and subjective analysis. My issue is when someone unironically tries to spin subjective views into objective, matter-of-fact findings, whilst at the same time trying to act like the smartest guy in the room for doing something so pointless.
I thought Bruno played best in that deeper role. I like us to buy a 10 to play with Bruno and casemiro then have Eriksen backup and a striker.
Overall Bruno is a bit hit and miss as a 10.
Overall Bruno is a bit hit and miss as a 10.
Unfortunately some player performance threads are full of nonsense from agenda driven posters who think Bruno Fernandes has had 30 poor games this season and has been outperformed by Shaw, Varane and Garnacho
Can't be really watching a game properly if they're posting on hereWhat?
Last edited:
Man Utd 2:1 Fulham
Very nice goal today.
Great composure but that pass to him was something else, that's gotta be one of the passes of the season by a United player
I actually thought he was one of the worst players for United in this game (sloppy passing, forcing it long), but he can finish a chance.
Last response to you on this….My memory of Bruno’s season is that he has had a lot of poor performances, in fact my memory overall is that he hasn’t had too many brilliant performances. So when you get posters saying he’s had a brilliant season and your recollection is different then in my opinion here is a good tool to look at how his performances were viewed game to game. If that logic goes beyond you then I can’t do anything about that but I refuse to go over the point again and again.
You crack on thinking that Bruno played fantastically yet fans came on here and for some reason, in a largely pro Bruno thread, decided individually with no connection to say he was poor, for some bizarre reason, they must all have agendas. It’s funny that some games where Bruno was fantastic that fans didn’t do this. It would be a wonder how they chose their games to do this when they weren’t basing it on Bruno’s actual performance
He’s alright this bloke
You crack on thinking that the caf player ratings are the best way to judge a player's performance, despite seeing posters on other threads admitting that they only bother giving ratings when we've lost and then everyone gets a low rating: https://www.redcafe.net/threads/lisandro-martínez-2022-23-performances.471684/page-163#post-30603257
119 - Bruno Fernandes created 119 chances in the Premier League this season, the highest on record (since 2003-04) by a @ManUtd player in a single campaign. Might drive you mad at times but he delivers
I didn’t go off the score. I went off the posts ffs. There’s plenty after every game good and bad. Hopefully you get it now. Please.
You tried quantifying reactive, emotional post-match comments:
Such a pointless endeavour when you could've quite simply looked at his in-game stats if you wanted true objective data.
I don’t judge by stats. I go to the game and watch them play. Bye.
Same here, which begs the question why you spent so much time trying to quantify the opinions of posters from 40 different individual games, when instead you could've just said "I haven't got the numbers to hand, but I think he's had more poor games than good games this season".
Spurs having 2 of the top 5 and feck all to show for it.
He's so so sloppy with his passing, even when he does contribute, I feel like he can do so much better.
Fantastic, he is a chance creating machine.
Apart from this, his defensive contribution is good too. His work rate is insane and he wins fair share of tackles, 80th percentile in tackles won and 93 percentile in ball recoveries (loose ball recovered).
Hopefully he starts scoring goals, he has missed some very easy chances. Also as a team if we are clinical then he will cross 20 assists (in all competitions) easily.
Yea this. He’s got insane numbers but his habit of misplacing easy passes is so frustrating. If he improves on that he can easily become one of the best around.
Everytime he has the ball, it feels like he will either create a chance or lose it. He doesn't do in between often.
He's one of the players that will benefit drastically from having someone like Kane in the team.
On the other hand, i dont think he gets enough credit for the other side of his game. His work rate is insane, his availability is almost a joke and his leadership has been a huge plus this season.
He's one of the players that will benefit drastically from having someone like Kane in the team.
On the other hand, i dont think he gets enough credit for the other side of his game. His work rate is insane, his availability is almost a joke and his leadership has been a huge plus this season.
Cool finish and he showed unusual composure in the move before the first goal.
Statistically an amazing season for him yet again but always a frustrating player to watch regardless. I wish he wasn't so gung-ho and reckless at times.
63 goals conceded. More than all but 5 other clubs.
If we get him a world class striker his assists will go of the chain.
Still not sure how he'd work with Harry kane dropping into his areas all the time.
I suppose he could run ahead of him like his goal today
Still not sure how he'd work with Harry kane dropping into his areas all the time.
I suppose he could run ahead of him like his goal today
How is he regarded on the continent? Surely those numbers must be very impressive even if we forget what strikers he's dealing with?
Bruno's off the ball movement is very good, I think it should work really well. Kane dropping deep and picking up passes with Rashford and Bruno making runs.
I dont think he can. He seems scared to hold on to the ball, he must release it immediately with either a final ball, a flick or a pass. I think he is not confident enough to play or run with the ball, and that seperates him from other top #10s. The catch is, even if he has a bad game, he will contribute, and that's why he is so important. Without him in the team, we kinda look clueless, because atleast he has the balls to play the risky pass.
@HarryKane
I love this version of Bruno. For me, this was his best season at Old Trafford, now that he is starting to play with a little more control. There was a big improvement in that regard. He still has that incredible creativity, but isn’t all at sea when momentum shifts the other way. Hopefully he can contribute a few more open play goals next season again, as he’s definitely capable of that.
He’ll be the next club captain and it will be well deserved.
He’ll be the next club captain and it will be well deserved.
I’d love to see his stats during the Ronaldo experiment and post the Ronald’s experiment. I felt at the timethat the problems in them playing together were a bit overstated but since Ronnie left it really felt like Bruno went up a couple of levels.
Really excited now to see what next season brings from Bruno if we can get a proper dynamic forward in front of him.
I do get some of the frustration from him but take him out that team and the drop off is absolutely immense.
Really excited now to see what next season brings from Bruno if we can get a proper dynamic forward in front of him.
I do get some of the frustration from him but take him out that team and the drop off is absolutely immense.
Is he playing with more control? That doesn't seem reflected in the stats, even yesterday his passing accuracy was 63%. He had some games in the last couple of months where he was more composed on the ball. There are still too many games where like half the time he seems to pick the wrong option. Yesterday was exactly like that till we scored the first goal.
He's the most important player in our attack, I'm still not sure though whether this is a good thing or not.
He's the most important player in our attack, I'm still not sure though whether this is a good thing or not.
His passing can be hit or miss which can infuriate a lot of fans.
It's a good thing he plays further up the pitch and not in front of the defence with the amount of sloppy and untidy passes he plays.
For me overall he's had a good season.
Apart from his footballing qualities I love him because even if he does have a poor/average game his work rate is still high and never hides or shy away from the ball. Always available for selection and a team player.
The manager knows what he's going to get from him week in and week out.
Good run and finish from him yesterday.
It's a good thing he plays further up the pitch and not in front of the defence with the amount of sloppy and untidy passes he plays.
For me overall he's had a good season.
Apart from his footballing qualities I love him because even if he does have a poor/average game his work rate is still high and never hides or shy away from the ball. Always available for selection and a team player.
The manager knows what he's going to get from him week in and week out.
Good run and finish from him yesterday.
- Status