It can only be the Great Dane
Best United team - goalkeeper
- Thread starter Livvie
- Start date
I strongly feel, we have some divided opinions over here.
Gary Bailey was a better keeper than Barthez!
Can we have Lucky Les in the polls please?He was a funny, leggy but lucky goalie for us!!!
But Schmikes wins this hands down
But Schmikes wins this hands down
schmikes - he is also known to be very good at the hand ball game.
Even Gary Bailey deserves a plce in the polls...
I vote for Schmeichel.. But only because Tiabi isn't on the list.
cnuts
cnuts
what about that great Scots goalie we had on loan sometime back
Longlivekeano said:
Course he does -
shame on you livie for excluding him at the expense of Barthez this thread can be closed now, the great dane 'edges' it by 91 percent
Schmeichel
Has to be Schmeichel.
Schmikes!!
Over the last 50 years :
1 Schmeicel
2 Stepney
3 Gregg
4 VDS
5 Bailey
1 Schmeicel
2 Stepney
3 Gregg
4 VDS
5 Bailey
Barthez just edges it for me
Nick Culkin
Schmeichel of course, not just our greatest keeper ever but one of the very best to ever play for the club.
Oh and Barthez wasn't that bad. We did win the league 2 of the 3 years he was here.
Oh and Barthez wasn't that bad. We did win the league 2 of the 3 years he was here.
Barthez had the shinniest head i have ever seen. I think some of you are forgetting this whilst you decide who to vote for
Smikes. Honourable mention to Stepney. I quite liked Jimmy Rimmer also. Why isn't Taibi on the list?
No contest in this one............next!
Schmeichel for me.
Gary Bailey deserves a mention, IMO.
Gary Bailey deserves a mention, IMO.
noodlehair said:
Both of them?
Thats not fair, it's bound to be easier when there are two of them.
Julian Denny said:
I'd put Harry ahead of Stepney, but clearly Schmeichel beats them all hands down.
I think to be fair future polls need to have a few more options rather than an old one and three from the last decade
KaiserSoze666 said:
There's no point in putting in players who don't stand a chance. They were all eliminated in earlier heats.
what tossers voted for barthez??
Small Paul said:
Sorry. It was his shiney head that swayed me
where's Taibi?
That Danish fella.
REVELZ said:Tough choice, The Great Dane just edges it though.
at the tough choice partWhere's Gary Bailey? with his voodoo goal locks from the witch doctor he was unbeatable!
grahamo said:
Yes, I could have put him in, and Gary Walsh too.
Didn't see the point though...it's obvious who is going to win.
Rimmer (the name seems more unfortunate these days) was pretty good - probably better than that twat Robinson for example. Tho' he did make the biggest feck up I've ever seen when he played for us [ran off to the wing to clear a ball; sliced it at about 90 degrees into the penalty area where a WBA forward slotted it into the empty goal]kf said:
David Seaman?
Seamo made some feck-ups in his later days (largely due to his decreasing agility) but Rimmer's was something else.
Nem 7 said:
which seasons did he play for United then ? Can't seem to recall - remind us ?
Since The Great Dane only has 94% of the vote I assume that the Caf has a 6% insanity rate.
Lower than I suspected mind.
Lower than I suspected mind.
This reslitically told us what we already knew, i think this might of been the most one sided poll in the history of the forum.
The Great Dane, without a doubt. The best goalkeeper around.
Great Dane by a mile, was disappointed not to see Jim Leighton and Massimo Taibi in there though.