OK, I'll try again.
Best United team - central midfield
- Thread starter Livvie
- Start date
What's going on here?
Edwards, Keano, Robbo
Edwards, Keano, Robbo
I have never seen Edwards play, I'm old but not that old. Robbo by a country mile and Keano
I never saw Edwards either, but I've heard enough about him to reckon he's up there
FFS SHUT UP ABOUT 50s PLAYERS!!!
I'm sure I've left someone out.
I'm sure I've left someone out.
Veron?? even though he never lived up to expectation...
I voted for Charlton, Robson, Keane and Scholes
I couldnt vote for just one because we had a great mid players
I couldnt vote for just one because we had a great mid players
You should only be allowed two choices really.
I've gone for Bobby and Keane. Scholesy is one of my favourite ever players, but Bobby was the more complete player.
I've gone for Bobby and Keane. Scholesy is one of my favourite ever players, but Bobby was the more complete player.
Now that's a tough one!
Robson is one of the biggest reason why I Man Utd is my team.
Scholes has been my favorite player last 10 years or so...
And you can't leave Keane out. But I have to
Scholes and Robson for me...
Robson is one of the biggest reason why I Man Utd is my team.
Scholes has been my favorite player last 10 years or so...
And you can't leave Keane out. But I have to
Scholes and Robson for me...
Didn't they used to say about Crerand that if he played well, United played well? He must have been very influential.
Scholesy and Keano
Mainoldo said:
No, I meant someone important.
Unfortunately, I think it's either multiple voting, or just the one vote. Otherwise I'd have made it 2 votes only.
That was tough. Had to go for robson and Keano in the end.
Sorry Scholesy
Sorry Scholesy
I went for Scholes and Keano. They both played an integral part for us in our domination of the premiership in the 90s
Keane
Robson
Scholes
Charlton
Robson
Scholes
Charlton
Livvie said:No, I meant someone important.
Good list, altho I would have gone for Remi Moses and Neil Webb over Gerry Daly. And it's a pity that the 40 year limit rules out Johnny Giles - Busby's biggest mistake.
On th voting, it has to be two only surely - so I go for Keane and Charlton to give balance.
You can vote for as many as you like!
Would have loved to say Crerand, but I've never seen him play. Has to be Robbo for me, followed very closely by Keano.
Scholes, Keane, Robbo, Crerand and Charlton.
I feel sorry for Nicky Butt being in that list
So sorry I might vote for him
So sorry I might vote for him
Reckon Scholes may well be the most talented of the lot too, though he doesn't have the drive or other qualities of the likes of Keane and Robbo
Psmith said:
I've voted for all.
My final formation would turn out to be gay.
These polls are fecking wank and a waste of time.
My top 4 would be :-
Keane
Charlton, Robson & Scholes.
Keane would be an automatic first choice with any of the other 3, but having to pick one of them - after long and careful consideration it would be Charlton.
Keane
Charlton, Robson & Scholes.
Keane would be an automatic first choice with any of the other 3, but having to pick one of them - after long and careful consideration it would be Charlton.
Pointless having them really if you are allowed more than two votes.
Private Pyle said:
You're an amusing chap. If it were Christmas you've be like Slabberneezer Scrooge.
keano..
Billy Bollocks said:
Not really - there should still be two players who have more votes than anyone else.
Being able to have just two votes would be better, but I don't think it can be done.
Private Pyle said:
I'm going to start a poll on whether to put you on invisible.
Looks like Keano is tops and a favourite like Robson is remembered
It's so hard to leave any of the big four out...
You couldn't dream of leaving Keane or Charlton out of an all-time team, but to let Scholes and Robson go... not easy.
You couldn't dream of leaving Keane or Charlton out of an all-time team, but to let Scholes and Robson go... not easy.
Charlton and Robbo.
Keano and Robson for me !
Really tough one this, would have liked to see Edwards in there, I am not old enough to have seen him play, but have seen grown men reduced to tears when eulogising about him. He would have got a vote from me. However had to be two of either:
Keano
Robbo
Scholesy
Sir Bobalot
not in any particular order but all have records and abilities that no one can argue with.
Keano
Robbo
Scholesy
Sir Bobalot
not in any particular order but all have records and abilities that no one can argue with.
Private Pyle said:
put er on the end of a word ryhming with bank from your quote....
there you go.....
describes you perfectly.
Livvie said:
he was Livvie
so for me Crerand and Charlton
Bloody hell this ones hard, I kind of want to vote for only two but it may have to be 4 maybe 5
Sir Robert Charlton
Roy Maurice Keane
Roy Maurice Keane
Keano, Robbo and Sir Bobby
Keane and Charlton.
Hated having to leave out Robson and Scholes.
Hated having to leave out Robson and Scholes.