Mainoldo
New Member
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2004
- Messages
- 22,965
Messi, Robben, Ben Arfa... the rest are potential pretenders if we are just isolating dribbling.
Scary thing is he isn't even the best dribbler of the ball at Real madrid.Isco's close control and dribbling ability is absolutely ridiculous. Best in the world at it along with Messi for me.
Maradona > Pele at dribbling.The best ever? Messi, Pele behind him and then Maradona.
Maradona > Pele at dribbling.
Pele wasn't even the best dribbler on that Brazil side (Garrincha)
Hazard surely massively underrated on that list @Raees. He quite often plays in the hole for Chelsea, and therefore does a lot of dribbling from midfield. One only needs to watch a highlight video to see that he dribbles from central areas almost as often as he dribbles from the left. Messi 1, Hazard 2, then the rest, I'd say.
He certainly did so against top teams in the PL last season. (I'm leaving it at that because that's the only season I watched him extensively.) But doing it in the CL is missing in his portfolio so far, that's true.Yeah the list isn't definitive - still a work in progress. Technically Hazard would be right up there but his lack of big match prowess to date and the fact he was not great when deployed as a 10 have counted against him for me. Not enough evidence of him destroying the best sides but signs are he can do it this season. His performance against Atletico already has me thinking he can score higher.
He certainly did so against top teams in the PL last season. (I'm leaving it at that because that's the only season I watched him extensively.) But doing it in the CL is missing in his portfolio so far, that's true.
Hazard is above Messi.
Feels like pedigree has been omitted from a lot of these lists.
Messi and Neymar aren't only great dribblers - they've proven they can do it on stages bigger than run-of-the-mill domestic footballers, and can and will make fools of top defenders and units in games and moments when the pressure is on to deliver. 'Clutch' as the Americans call it.
I still find Hazard overrated on here. For his supposed profile, what has he actually done in the CL or for his NT? There's no doubt he's a menace in the PL, but that hasn't been a strong league in and of itself for a long time and the number of players who have shone outside it in the aforementioned categories in the last few years... Well.. It's not many, is it?
There are a few dribblers who are great at making mugs of the faceless hordes but get themselves shut out when the levels rise and they're faced with peers who can run and track their movements, feints and intentions, or, when faced with a team who have a plan in place to double or triple up on them, they get exasperated and make increasingly bad decisions.
I think @totaalvoetbal has merit with the categories as ball retention for the sake of the team is very different from penetrative or wide, pace based dribbling and it's rare that a player can do 2 from 3 let alone all 3.
When people talk about 'dribbling' it usually pertains solely to penetrative as that's the hardest and most exciting to do and is also the one that any player with excellent ability in will be on for a hard time as teams lay out specific tactical plans to stop him for a career - that too is a credential for a truly great dribbler; for the opposition to plan for him and he still goes out there and does what he wants ala Messi and Robben in particular.
Messi is easily the best penetrative dribbler on the planet. Easily. It takes an off day or a team playing astutely for 93 minutes for him to not get in.
Robben may be winding down now but how many times has he cut in from the right with seemingly the same moves at the same pace to drive into his trademark position to shoot? That's testament to how good he is at dribbling with intent.
Neymar is like a roll of the dice - compared to the other two, his success rate in big games in taking men on is up and down, but a lot of that comes down to decision making and ego rather than his ability. It's within him mature and make smarter, less individualistic conclusions with the frequency someone like him should have.
Carrasco and Fekir were names that came to mind for penetrative dribbling, but I've been beaten to it by @giorno. Fekir has nothing of repute to say he can do it at the highest levels, but his dribbling talent makes it look a certainty. Carrasco is erratic but when he's on it he's a match for any man 1on1. Not sure how he'd turn out with a profile worthy of being earmarked for specialist treatment though.
Rententative dribblers who basically negate pressing or calm a game and allow others in their team to regain composure are the most fun to watch, for me. They don't tend to hurt the opposition in terms of going through them, but they demoralize them massively and instill great confidence and allow others to orbit them and run ahead with pure belief that they won't lose the ball. Maradona, to my mind is the best dribbler of all time because he could hold the ball for his team until he was fouled, basically, allied to the ease he could go straight through a team on a penetrative run makes him peerless. He had the strength of Zidane, the nimbleness and slight of feet of Iniesta at his peak, the vision of Valderrama and an unparalleled consistency to go with it. In terms of penetrative it's he and Messi at the top of the chain.
Isco is the most fun to watch with retention and also Modric. Veratti seems to have dropped a beat from a couple of seasons ago. I'm glad Moussa Dembelele got a mention.
Of the up and comers the other Dembelele is the player who entertain me the most. I hope he realises his potential and that neither his knees or ankles give up on him. Shame Reus is a broken man now. He would've been in the conversation a couple of years ago.
Tier 1: Messi, Hazard, Neymar, Martial, Dembele, Pogba, Isco
Tier 2: Marcelo, Douglas Costa, Saint-Maximin, Fekir, Mané, Sanchez, Brahimi, Sterling, Sané
Tier 3: Mbappe, Dybala, Iniesta, Bernardo Silva, Verratti, Coman, Modric, Asensio
There are a few dribblers who are great at making mugs of the faceless hordes but get themselves shut out when the levels rise and they're faced with peers who can run and track their movements, feints and intentions, or, when faced with a team who have a plan in place to double or triple up on them, they get exasperated and make increasingly bad decisions.
Indeed. Meant to tag you but went off on a Maradona tangent and forgot.Great post but my table did take into account effectiveness on the big stage.
Has anyone noticed the evolution in dribbling? Back in the 2000's and even the early 2010's, a lot of the dribblers employed tricks and flicks. Stepovers, elasticos were commonplace [obviously not to the same degree] among the flair players. These days, dribbling is all about close control and body feint. Players just don't bother with tricks anymore.
I feel it's down to two factors:
1) The general speed of the game has gone up, players just don't have the time to engage in step overs. They'd either go past the player using speed or control or just pass it to the nearby player and keep the game fluid.
2) Messi's influence. I honestly feel that most young players these days have Messi and his game as influence. While they still do use tricks sometimes, their dribbling has become a lot more close control oriented.
I might be way off the mark here, but this is what I noticed.
You see that with someone like Depay, has all those tricks
Inverted dribblers/takibg on multiple opponents/drive to goal:
Messi
Neymar
Hazard
Sancho
Sterling
Sane
Salah
Coutinho
Dybala
Isolated dribblers/one on ones
Coman
Mane
Douglas Costa
Vinicius Junior
Pace dribblers
Mbappe
Sane
Dembele
Lucas Moura
Werner
Aubameyang
Midfield dribblers/pressing resustance
Modric
Bernardo Silva
Thiago
Arthur
David Silva
Isco
Verratti
de Jong
Gündogan
Too lazy to make any in Detail Analysis but I agree with 2 statements:
1. Messi is on a complete other Level compared to anyone else
2. Martial is our best dribbler by quite some margin and maybe the best in the PL.
What's Rashford then, a dribble the ball out of play dribbler?
The lad United have signed, Dan James, is probably as quick as Mbappe, possibly even quicker over the first ten yards. He doesn't look that great when he needs a trick to beat a man but when it's open space no one can catch him. I've not seen a player close down defenders like he does before either, the defenders just don't expect it.
Also I think Loftus Cheek (depending on how he comes back from his Achilles injury) will be one of the best dribblers through midfield. I thought he bossed it against Frankfurt in the Europa League semi final in that regard.
Martial can also pull off some crazy skill based dribbles when he's in the mood.
Wow, that's crazily fast. Do you think he'll grab a starting spot?
Yes, Martial can be great and has all the potential but right now I don't really think he ranks among the very best. However, he definitely had some incredible runs. That assist vs Germany comes to mind.
Will keep an eye on Loftus Cheek, haven't seen that much of him TBH. But I think he belongs in an even different category alongside Pogba, Naby Keita, Milinkovic Savic etc.
No, not even close, and he's far from a great dribbler in general. He is very smart with it though, which makes him appear better than he isAnd then there's also Mohammed Salah who had aMessi-esque season in 2018 and a very good one in 2019. Style-wise probably the closest to Messi as it gets.
It's not odd at all, Ben Arfa has always been a ridiculous dribbler. Too good at it for his own good in factA rather odd suggestion could be Ben Arfa, who's statistically one of the best in Europe.
Salah and Dybala are smart dribblers. They don't belong on that list, they're not even closeInverted dribblers/takibg on multiple opponents/drive to goal:
Messi
Neymar
Hazard
Sancho
Sterling
Sane
Salah
Coutinho
Dybala
He’s actually quite poor. It’s the reason why you see him 80% of the time shielding the ball with the defender sitting on his back in possession. He has fancy flicks and long strides here and there but definitely not a ‘dribbler’ that can keep himself off contactI haven't seen Pogba mentioned here much, incredible midfield dribbler.