Dropping him completely from the squad in the 2011 final is still the most bizarre thing I've seen during my time supporting this club.
I get not starting him, but not even getting on the bench? I know a good chunk of his goals were scored in, well, chunks, and he didn't score in the CL at all that season, but he was still our top goalscorer and one of our best players from a technical POV, which would've been vital as we could barely keep the ball against Barca.
I think dropping Nani - who was our best player that season - was a mistake, too, as, like Berbatov, he was one of our better technical players, and could keep the ball under pressure, but at least he made the bench.
I think what's even more surprising is that he stayed for another season. You'd have thought he was done here after that.