I didn't think he was good enough for us at the start of the season and wanted him gone, he's been good defensively but i don't understand the praise he is getting, he constantly gets the ball with acres of space to run into, any half decent winger would have a field day with the likes of Rooney, Mata, Falcao and Rvp as the targets for crosses, he either hits the defender, or when he crosses he doesn't seem to pick anybody out, he just crosses into a dangerous area, if he overhits it like he did today, it turns out to be great shot but thats about it. For a team playing 3-5-2 and the onus is on him to create chances, we will have similar days like today and against Villa away, i thought he was good midweek, but was terrible against Villa and today, the amount of times he gets into that space and either hits the first man or overhits or doesn't pick somebody out is criminal.