Yeah, but I don’t really care on what he says publicly, I saw the gestures he did live, it’s all I need to see to make a judgment. We read pointless declarations by all players after each loss saying we will be better next game bla bla, this is the same from Antony. He needs to show he can sacrifice for the team, not say it.
Antony at leftback / LWB …
- Thread starter IrishRedDevil
- Start date
Yeah, but I don’t really care on what he says publicly, I saw the gestures he did live, it’s all I need to see to make a judgment. We read pointless declarations by all players after each loss saying we will be better next game bla bla, this is the same from Antony. He needs to show he can sacrifice for the team, not say it.
Can someone create the 'Bruno at CB' thread?
How do we even know for sure it was exactly about that ?
We don’t. That’s my interpretation of it, free to feel otherwise.
Just trying to keep an open mind tbh
Need to get the caf lip readers on the case
I think he is better at LB than Lindelof.
Lindelof did ok yesterday in his natural position at CB, but boy he was appalling at LB.
Next time Shaw/ Dalot/ AWB get injured I'd rather see Antony at LB than Lindelof again.
Lindelof did ok yesterday in his natural position at CB, but boy he was appalling at LB.
Next time Shaw/ Dalot/ AWB get injured I'd rather see Antony at LB than Lindelof again.
Sell him. Left back my tailfeather.
And we know this how?
At that moment, with all that was at stake, whatever it was you just suck it up and get on with it.
He did it thought
He went on an played left back and as always gave his all. So i dont care to much about the reaction beforehand.
He went on an played left back and as always gave his all. So i dont care to much about the reaction beforehand.
Given how shite he's been on the right wing (was ok yesterday) since we've signed him, he has a cheek moaning about being played at left back. If he was decent and more consistent in the position he should be playing, then there's no way ten Hag would even think about playing him out of position.
Having said all of that, due to the changes ten Hag made to try and level the game, it was always going to leave us unbalanced. Bruno had to play centre back and just got on with it.
Having said all of that, due to the changes ten Hag made to try and level the game, it was always going to leave us unbalanced. Bruno had to play centre back and just got on with it.
The body language was pretty obvious. But who cares? Antony is an attacking player and he understandably wasn’t thrilled about being asked to defend when we were still chasing a goal. There is nothing out of bounds here.
He finally looked like he was finding some confidence and form yesterday. There was a zip and purpose to his passing.
So why was he put at LB? Because Rashford equalised and no need for suicide 4 wingers approach?
Again in the Arsenal game.
Left back in the changing rooms..
I'd genuinely think about it. We bought him for a ridiculous amount, there isn't much chance anybody will take him from us and he isn't going to accept stepping down. We may as well try to get something out of him. He obviously isn't a defender, but he is gritty and has good workrate. I'd give it a shot against teams, that aren't expected to have too much fire power up front. He could play the FB behind Bruno on the right for example, providing an outball and allowing Bruno or Mount to move more inside.
I never have been a fan of him and was against that transfer. But he is part of the squad now and probably for at least another, probably two years. Our fullbacks don't add anything to our attack, I'd try my chances adding him there. And if things don't work out, there is no real damage done.
I never have been a fan of him and was against that transfer. But he is part of the squad now and probably for at least another, probably two years. Our fullbacks don't add anything to our attack, I'd try my chances adding him there. And if things don't work out, there is no real damage done.
Couldn’t help but notice he looked pretty unhappy about going over there…
Even if could do it, which he can't, then he won't want to.
We could have also have had a thread for Casemiro playing a CB, well that went well.
We could have also have had a thread for Casemiro playing a CB, well that went well.
I have passed my notes to Amorim.
Antony at LB / LWB incoming.
Antony at LB / LWB incoming.
He may actually be more effective in that inside forward role that Amorim plays with. No more stuck on the wing, stopping and passing back.
But in all likelihood, he's going to spend a lot of time on the bench.
But in all likelihood, he's going to spend a lot of time on the bench.
To be honest he's shown nothing to even be given a place on the bench this season. Fully expect him to be frozen out and moved on in January or the summer.
Antony cant be sell
my guess is he'll be one of the first out the door - even if just on loan to start with
What is this?!!
Mazraoui at 10 = ten hag is clueless
Antony at LB = Caf tactical genius
Just stop. Fred wasn’t the answer at LB and neither is this guy.
Mazraoui at 10 = ten hag is clueless
Antony at LB = Caf tactical genius
Just stop. Fred wasn’t the answer at LB and neither is this guy.
Antony's problem is that his dribbling speed is terrible. He often gets caught by the defender even if he gets past him from the halfway line. So he'll never be PL level winger.
As a wingback, if all he has to do is run up and down the line and deliver crosses on his favorite foot, there is a chance for him to get some game time under Amorim as we basically have zero options there. Whether he actually has the ability and character to completely change his game to suit the team is a huge question mark. Basically he has to pull a reverse Bale to actually have a future at United.
As a wingback, if all he has to do is run up and down the line and deliver crosses on his favorite foot, there is a chance for him to get some game time under Amorim as we basically have zero options there. Whether he actually has the ability and character to completely change his game to suit the team is a huge question mark. Basically he has to pull a reverse Bale to actually have a future at United.
No, sell.
Thanks
How long is his contract, and what is his salary?
He has 0 defending awareness, he is not even an intelligent player, he will never adapt to play at LB, especially in a league like this. Being tenacious and running without a purpose is not enough to become a defender.
Not everyone is Antonio Valencia.
Not everyone is Antonio Valencia.
An attacking LWB, maybe in Amorins 3-4-3. It's possible with Shaw and malacia both still out it would give us a bit of balance.
Hopefully be a temporary measure if it happens until we bring in a specialist LWB.
Hopefully be a temporary measure if it happens until we bring in a specialist LWB.
He wouldn't do it for a manager he was close to in ten Hag, why would he do it for a new manager.
He is has the sort of attitude we need rid of at the club and he isn't alone.
He is has the sort of attitude we need rid of at the club and he isn't alone.
Antony is an attacker and that's where he should be played - ie. in his best position.
Agree. His best position is on the bench
An 'attacker' who has registered a whooping 5 goals and 3 assists at his time with the club. He's welcome to hone his 'attacking' talents elsewhere, though as long as he's here he'd do well to keep quiet and do what he's paid to do.
If Amass isn't ready yet and we need a short term LWB then I wouldn't be against trying it for a few games.
Would work if the player is willing. Worked with Young and Valencia, eventually leading them to play as full time full backs. Whether he's big enough to take a manager telling him he'd not good enough to play as a forward at this level but I'd good enough to play further back is the real question.
Anthony should be left back at the hotel on game days. He shouldn’t be playing left back.
Yeah it worked with those 2 because they had footballing brains, and were selfless, they were for the team.
Wasn't he stretchered off against Fenerbahce or am I imagining it?