prateik
Full Member
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2005
- Messages
- 42,472
They have sold all the Di Maria shirts they were going to.
We had Park in many of those games and he was also not the quickest. Januzaj is deceptively quick and regularly beats his man with pace and skill so don't know how you think he is not ideal. I think he is easily quicker than Giggs of the last 5 years. Also, Mata is not a slouch. Don't think in terms of pace there is much difference between him and Tevez of that time. Now obviously Ronaldo was the best player in the world at that time but someone like Di Maria would help us with that blistering pace and ability to run with the ball that we have lacked ever since Nani decided he likes the treatment table more than the pitch.
Point is the system can work and work well if we do decide to carry it forward. You have decent pace in 3 of the 4 players at the top and one with blistering pace in Di Maria. Bayern have two players on the wings who are absolutely lethal in their ball control and speed. But up top they still had the likes of Muller/Gomez who are nowhere near quick. In the midfield too they had the likes of Kroos/Bastian/Lahm. Again not people with a lot of pace.
Pace in a team is not only about what top speeds players can achieve. It's also about how quickly the ball can transition from one end to another. That famous 4-5 touch move from our pen box for our third goal against Arsenal in the CL semis included just 3 players. Ronaldo/Park/Rooney. Barring Ronaldo, neither of the other two were very quick. Yet we moved the ball with pace and that was aided because we were quick in our thoughts and not ponderous with the ball at the feet. That is the main thing which even you have alluded to.
We need players with quick thinking. Not players like Valencia and Young, who are perhaps one of the quickest if you ask them to have a foot race, but are absolutely dull as feck with the ball at their feet and take ages to take a decision and move the ball forward (which they rarely do nowadays anyway).
That was also one of the major reasons why his Bayern side took the upturn they did. AdM for me is Van Gaals Robben type player.Honestly, a major part of Van Gaal's 3-5-2 being so successful at the WC was that one of the strikers was Robben, pelting about at 37kph.
That's only valid when the opposition doesn't have a quick back line or who aren't putting additional numbers in midfield.
We aren't severely lacking it, I'm not disputing the benefits of Di Maria's pace its this assertion that you must have speed demons on both wings. A. Madrid proved you can be a very good team on the counter without having Olympic Sprinters on the wings.
I don't believe the €75m fee that is coming from the Spanish media. Real Madrid love to lie about fees they pay/receive to suit their agenda. When this broke the fees from here stated €50-60m.
And why would we up our bid from a few weeks ago when quite frankly our position has strengthened? PSG have admitted openly that they can't afford him, no-one else has put in a bid and Di Maria has told Madrid that he wants to come to us. They're even leaving him out of squads, there would be no need for us to chuck another €25 on our offer.
Di Maria was amazing last season for Real playing in that position. I actually cannot wait for this to be finalised and buy my shirt!I'd be surprised if Di Maria's purchase led to a formation change. Van Gaal told the Sundays if he switched to 4-3-3 he'd have to drop RVP or Rooney, which he doesn't want to do.
Di Maria will probably play in centre midfield, as he did for Real Madrid last year. There will obviously be games where Van Gaal changes it and he plays wide. However, I think Di Maria has been brought to give us drive in midfield.
I like this. Di Maria and Herrera would provide plenty of energy in the centre, with the former playing as a midfield shuttler with freedom to drift to the left wing, like he's excelled at doing with at Madrid. Rooney, RvP and Mata stay in their best positions. Would definitely need another DM, someone like De Jong would be smart and could make a huge difference.The problem with that is you have Di Maria, Mata and Rooney all playing in positions that are not their best. We all know Rooney is best at CF, Mata is best at CAM and, as we saw last season, Di Maria can be incredible as part of a midfield three.
The best formation to include all of them has to be a 41212, which LVG has used in the past, where Rooney and RVP are up top, Mata is CAM, Di Maria and Herrera are the two CMs and Fletcher/new DM as the defensive mdifielder.
---Rooney RVP
-------Mata
Di Maria Herrera
------Fletch
.
The €75m isn't coming from Spain. It's coming from rumours from PSG and City. But it's very unlikely Madrid will be selling (or even talking) for €50m. The Spanish press think we're looking at €60m to €70m.
Madrid do some straightforward deals: Ronaldo, £80m cash, for example. But they also do immensely complicated ones as well. How many years, what currency, appearances, trophies, even things like a player ending up on a Ballon D'Or top three. The key thing is Madrid (Perez) pulled him out of the Supercopa squad because he thinks United are in the right ballpark.
Agree! The knives are coming out, as predicted. Sod em!So funny listening to some other supporters attempt to discredit Di Maria's influence for Real last year. For me, he was their most consistent performer in all the key games. His workrate and creativity were phenomenal.
He was also the best player on the pitch when Madrid came to OT a couple of years back. Guy is an absolute menace!
I've dabbled in this thread a bit but after seeing a few slightly odd oppo posts I guess its time to throw my full weight behind a post about this potential signing and what I think about it.
First off he's a world class player, we all should know that, however there seems to be a small divide between the fans here from what I can see.
There's those who have become disillusioned with the way the club has gone in the past few years (despite winning a title) and to whom signing a world class player has become something of an oracle, the idea of signing this player who was one of the best in a Real Madrid side that won the CL is a dream for those, despite the fact he is a world class player he has instantly become in the top 5 in the world to those and money is no object throw whatever they want at them, just sign that world class name.
Then there are those who are a bit more level headed and are concerned about what implications this has for the future.
United have been struggling lately in the transfer market, and almost every signing made has been vastly overpriced. They also have not been selling that well either so not a lot has been coming in, in the future clubs will know they can sell United average or decent players at a premium whilst top players can go for astronomical fees.
Had United bought Vidal and Benatia for say 80 or 90 million, I would have said it was very very good business and actually tip United as comfortable favourites for the top four at least as in the past 3 or more seasons these two areas have been the weakness for United.
I feel personally Di Maria is more of a statement than actually a player United are craving, a way of showing power over building the team in the correct order, this almost always leads to problems.
He will improve the side no doubt, but now it seems the thought is that with this world class player we can plug the other gaps with mediocrity such as De Jong and Blind and that's job done, I'm not so sure.
Its easy to dismiss any rival fan looking negatively upon this transfer as jealousy, which to some it may be, but not to all, there is clearly an element of truth to what some oppos say, in the same way there would be if we were to sign him. Yes he would improve our team too, but when you have the array of attacking mid-fielders we do, by how much?
Plus theres no guarantee he will make the transition quickly or easily and then will people get on his back because of his huge price tag and wage bill?
In short it's a bit of a risk, you pay a lot of money for a luxury player in the hope that the whole team will click better and that he will continue last seasons form seamlessly. Of course it may happen that way, theres no saying it wont, but it might be worth some being a bit more humble and not losing themselves too much, hes a great player but remember its team first then names on paper.
So why the disapproval of having Mata on the left side of a 3 behind the striker, citing his pace as the reason for it?Di Maria has just had probably his best season playing behind Ronaldo and Benzema in CM, his classification as a winger is due to his previous use. It is however not his only use and we all recognise that it's time to move away from the traditional winger system, even Moyes tried it after the signing of Mata.
I've dabbled in this thread a bit but after seeing a few slightly odd oppo posts I guess its time to throw my full weight behind a post about this potential signing and what I think about it.
First off he's a world class player, we all should know that, however there seems to be a small divide between the fans here from what I can see.
There's those who have become disillusioned with the way the club has gone in the past few years (despite winning a title) and to whom signing a world class player has become something of an oracle, the idea of signing this player who was one of the best in a Real Madrid side that won the CL is a dream for those, despite the fact he is a world class player he has instantly become in the top 5 in the world to those and money is no object throw whatever they want at them, just sign that world class name.
Then there are those who are a bit more level headed and are concerned about what implications this has for the future.
United have been struggling lately in the transfer market, and almost every signing made has been vastly overpriced. They also have not been selling that well either so not a lot has been coming in, in the future clubs will know they can sell United average or decent players at a premium whilst top players can go for astronomical fees.
Had United bought Vidal and Benatia for say 80 or 90 million, I would have said it was very very good business and actually tip United as comfortable favourites for the top four at least as in the past 3 or more seasons these two areas have been the weakness for United.
I feel personally Di Maria is more of a statement than actually a player United are craving, a way of showing power over building the team in the correct order, this almost always leads to problems.
He will improve the side no doubt, but now it seems the thought is that with this world class player we can plug the other gaps with mediocrity such as De Jong and Blind and that's job done, I'm not so sure.
Its easy to dismiss any rival fan looking negatively upon this transfer as jealousy, which to some it may be, but not to all, there is clearly an element of truth to what some oppos say, in the same way there would be if we were to sign him. Yes he would improve our team too, but when you have the array of attacking mid-fielders we do, by how much?
Plus theres no guarantee he will make the transition quickly or easily and then will people get on his back because of his huge price tag and wage bill?
In short it's a bit of a risk, you pay a lot of money for a luxury player in the hope that the whole team will click better and that he will continue last seasons form seamlessly. Of course it may happen that way, theres no saying it wont, but it might be worth some being a bit more humble and not losing themselves too much, hes a great player but remember its team first then names on paper.
I've dabbled in this thread a bit but after seeing a few slightly odd oppo posts I guess its time to throw my full weight behind a post about this potential signing and what I think about it.
First off he's a world class player, we all should know that, however there seems to be a small divide between the fans here from what I can see.
There's those who have become disillusioned with the way the club has gone in the past few years (despite winning a title) and to whom signing a world class player has become something of an oracle, the idea of signing this player who was one of the best in a Real Madrid side that won the CL is a dream for those, despite the fact he is a world class player he has instantly become in the top 5 in the world to those and money is no object throw whatever they want at them, just sign that world class name.
Then there are those who are a bit more level headed and are concerned about what implications this has for the future.
United have been struggling lately in the transfer market, and almost every signing made has been vastly overpriced. They also have not been selling that well either so not a lot has been coming in, in the future clubs will know they can sell United average or decent players at a premium whilst top players can go for astronomical fees.
Had United bought Vidal and Benatia for say 80 or 90 million, I would have said it was very very good business and actually tip United as comfortable favourites for the top four at least as in the past 3 or more seasons these two areas have been the weakness for United.
I feel personally Di Maria is more of a statement than actually a player United are craving, a way of showing power over building the team in the correct order, this almost always leads to problems.
He will improve the side no doubt, but now it seems the thought is that with this world class player we can plug the other gaps with mediocrity such as De Jong and Blind and that's job done, I'm not so sure.
Its easy to dismiss any rival fan looking negatively upon this transfer as jealousy, which to some it may be, but not to all, there is clearly an element of truth to what some oppos say, in the same way there would be if we were to sign him. Yes he would improve our team too, but when you have the array of attacking mid-fielders we do, by how much?
Plus theres no guarantee he will make the transition quickly or easily and then will people get on his back because of his huge price tag and wage bill?
In short it's a bit of a risk, you pay a lot of money for a luxury player in the hope that the whole team will click better and that he will continue last seasons form seamlessly. Of course it may happen that way, theres no saying it wont, but it might be worth some being a bit more humble and not losing themselves too much, hes a great player but remember its team first then names on paper.
Apparently he wanted to sign for City. Hope this isn't true.
If I understand correctly he was offered to City but didn't want to go there.Apparently he wanted to sign for City. Hope this isn't true.
Saying goodbye?Di Maria was late more than 30 minutes to training, And he left 5 minutes ago. My friend is in Valdebebas.
I've dabbled in this thread a bit but after seeing a few slightly odd oppo posts I guess its time to throw my full weight behind a post about this potential signing and what I think about it.
First off he's a world class player, we all should know that, however there seems to be a small divide between the fans here from what I can see.
There's those who have become disillusioned with the way the club has gone in the past few years (despite winning a title) and to whom signing a world class player has become something of an oracle, the idea of signing this player who was one of the best in a Real Madrid side that won the CL is a dream for those, despite the fact he is a world class player he has instantly become in the top 5 in the world to those and money is no object throw whatever they want at them, just sign that world class name.
Then there are those who are a bit more level headed and are concerned about what implications this has for the future.
United have been struggling lately in the transfer market, and almost every signing made has been vastly overpriced. They also have not been selling that well either so not a lot has been coming in, in the future clubs will know they can sell United average or decent players at a premium whilst top players can go for astronomical fees.
Had United bought Vidal and Benatia for say 80 or 90 million, I would have said it was very very good business and actually tip United as comfortable favourites for the top four at least as in the past 3 or more seasons these two areas have been the weakness for United.
I feel personally Di Maria is more of a statement than actually a player United are craving, a way of showing power over building the team in the correct order, this almost always leads to problems.
He will improve the side no doubt, but now it seems the thought is that with this world class player we can plug the other gaps with mediocrity such as De Jong and Blind and that's job done, I'm not so sure.
Its easy to dismiss any rival fan looking negatively upon this transfer as jealousy, which to some it may be, but not to all, there is clearly an element of truth to what some oppos say, in the same way there would be if we were to sign him. Yes he would improve our team too, but when you have the array of attacking mid-fielders we do, by how much?
Plus theres no guarantee he will make the transition quickly or easily and then will people get on his back because of his huge price tag and wage bill?
In short it's a bit of a risk, you pay a lot of money for a luxury player in the hope that the whole team will click better and that he will continue last seasons form seamlessly. Of course it may happen that way, theres no saying it wont, but it might be worth some being a bit more humble and not losing themselves too much, hes a great player but remember its team first then names on paper.
Apparently he wanted to sign for City. Hope this isn't true.
Di Maria was late more than 30 minutes to training, And he left 5 minutes ago. My friend is in Valdebebas.
That basically sums up my thinking.
It reminds me a bit of Arsenal buying Ozil last year. They were in dire need of strengthening in 3 or 4 positions, and they ended up buying a world class player in a well-stocked area. It was a huge statement, and it gave them a lift. Ultimately it wasn't enough to improve upon their previous league position.
I'm still very excited by us signing him - who wouldn't be? I'm just not exactly sure it's the most thought-out transfer, especially given that it's unclear where he'll play.
If I understand correctly he was offered to City but didn't want to go there.
Saying goodbye?
Did he train or was it just a 'pop-in session'/goodbye?
In any case, who cares.I don't think it's clear whether he wanted to got City or not, but City turned down the chance to try and sign him. Similar how City and United turned down the chance to sign Ozil last summer.
Apparently he wanted to sign for City. Hope this isn't true.
Even if he did, who cares as long as he signs for us now?Apparently he wanted to sign for City. Hope this isn't true.
I've dabbled in this thread a bit but after seeing a few slightly odd oppo posts I guess its time to throw my full weight behind a post about this potential signing and what I think about it.
First off he's a world class player, we all should know that, however there seems to be a small divide between the fans here from what I can see.
There's those who have become disillusioned with the way the club has gone in the past few years (despite winning a title) and to whom signing a world class player has become something of an oracle, the idea of signing this player who was one of the best in a Real Madrid side that won the CL is a dream for those, despite the fact he is a world class player he has instantly become in the top 5 in the world to those and money is no object throw whatever they want at them, just sign that world class name.
Then there are those who are a bit more level headed and are concerned about what implications this has for the future.
United have been struggling lately in the transfer market, and almost every signing made has been vastly overpriced. They also have not been selling that well either so not a lot has been coming in, in the future clubs will know they can sell United average or decent players at a premium whilst top players can go for astronomical fees.
Had United bought Vidal and Benatia for say 80 or 90 million, I would have said it was very very good business and actually tip United as comfortable favourites for the top four at least as in the past 3 or more seasons these two areas have been the weakness for United.
I feel personally Di Maria is more of a statement than actually a player United are craving, a way of showing power over building the team in the correct order, this almost always leads to problems.
He will improve the side no doubt, but now it seems the thought is that with this world class player we can plug the other gaps with mediocrity such as De Jong and Blind and that's job done, I'm not so sure.
Its easy to dismiss any rival fan looking negatively upon this transfer as jealousy, which to some it may be, but not to all, there is clearly an element of truth to what some oppos say, in the same way there would be if we were to sign him. Yes he would improve our team too, but when you have the array of attacking mid-fielders we do, by how much?
Plus theres no guarantee he will make the transition quickly or easily and then will people get on his back because of his huge price tag and wage bill?
In short it's a bit of a risk, you pay a lot of money for a luxury player in the hope that the whole team will click better and that he will continue last seasons form seamlessly. Of course it may happen that way, theres no saying it wont, but it might be worth some being a bit more humble and not losing themselves too much, hes a great player but remember its team first then names on paper.
Saying goodbye?
That basically sums up my thinking.
It reminds me a bit of Arsenal buying Ozil last year. They were in dire need of strengthening in 3 or 4 positions, and they ended up buying a world class player in a well-stocked area. It was a huge statement, and it gave them a lift. Ultimately it wasn't enough to improve upon their previous league position.
I'm still very excited by us signing him - who wouldn't be? I'm just not exactly sure it's the most thought-out transfer, especially given that it's unclear where he'll play.