Zoo
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 21, 2010
- Messages
- 30,305
Yeah he made a lot of difference when he came on despite carrying a knock.
Nope, we need a better first choice. You must've missed when he failed to make a simple pass and they ended up getting a chance or when he miscontrolled the ball into traffic or when he failed to set up crossing opportunities.He's our number 1 right back, we need better back ups.
Need him to be at his best against Leicester.
Bissaka Network.
It's painful watching him with the ball.
It's painful watching him with the ball.
Defensively it doesnt get any better than him, offensively he is so frustrating to watch. He struggles with the ball and misses even simple passes.
Definitely. Which meant that spending 55m in his was tragic, especially considering that we want to play from the back (this Smalling was sixth choice or so).The amount of abuse and stick I got early season on this thread for saying he's a good tackler and that's it.......guess I was right boys.
He's a dreadful footballer. CL football is going to expose him even more. Not good enough for us.
We should have kept Smalling and play him as RB. As good a defender, as bad with the ball.
In all honesty, if we sign a CB, I would probably prefer giving to Lindelof some games in RB. And Laird should definitely get a good shot on making RB position his own within the next 18 months.
Because people see things differently and value parts of the game differently. I think that he has been comfortably the worst of the back four.His value was immense when faced with attacking wingers like Sterling. I don't understand the sudden abuse here. After Maguire, he's been the persistent name on the team sheet ever game.
Because people see things differently and value parts of the game differently. I think that he has been comfortably the worst of the back four.
I am judging him on the entire season, as I am doing with any other player. He is one of the players with the poorest technique I have seen in United's shirt, and that was and is gonna be a problem. I didn't understand the praise even at the beginning of season, it was the typical praise any new signing gets (Darmian for example was suddenly a classical Italian defender at the beginning).I wouldn't really judge him on the last few games when every over used player had been fading. Bruno for all his technical prowess couldn't string a simple 10 yard pass for the past couple of weeks. He was making good progress around January in attacking contributions and I'd venture to give him another full season before judging him one way or another.
It truly is. Every time he plays one touch football with Greenwood and Pogba, I’m waiting for him to f it up somehow, and half the time he usually does.It's painful watching him with the ball.
This is the part I have issues with and why I was wary of us signing him.Overall he had a decent season, but this is another instance where we splash 50 millions and getting unfinished product at the end.
Same thing with Fred, 50m and still trying to find his way to his Shakhtar form.This is the part I have issues with and why I was wary of us signing him.
If I am paying £50m for a fullback, I want the complete package.
You can work on your game but this guy looks naturally limited with the ball at his feet.
I am judging him on the entire season, as I am doing with any other player. He is one of the players with the poorest technique I have seen in United's shirt, and that was and is gonna be a problem. I didn't understand the praise even at the beginning of season, it was the typical praise any new signing gets (Darmian for example was suddenly a classical Italian defender at the beginning).
Agreeing with your opinion for the first time in a long while.He looks good for us when we are under siege as he's a tremendous 1 on 1 defender.
When we have majority of the ball he's a huge issue. He's just not good enough. Never will be either.
Agreeing with your opinion for the first time in a long while.