70s Fantasy Draft - Cold_Boy v Crustanoid

Who will win based on players in their prime, team tactics, balance & bench strength?


  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .
Code:
Crustanoid basically has 3 strikers and three midfielders on the pitch, out of which only one provides any sort of width. I've not seen many teams play that sort of system before.

It was quite commonplace a decade or so ago. Milan used it in various guises, usually along the lines of:

Code:
       Gattuso - Pirlo - Seedorf
           Rui Costa/Kaka
Shevchenko - Tomasson/Inzaghi/Rivaldo

And Madrid rarely played with out-and-out wingers:

Code:
McManaman/Karembeu - Redondo - Seedorf
                      Raul
          Anelka/Guti - Morientes

While Rangers under Advocaat used it effectively as well:

Code:
Reyna - Ferguson - Van Bronckhorst
                Albertz
 
That's true. But both midfielders on the sides are more than capable of playing out wide in all those formations. It essentially becomes a diamond at times I would think.

Oh and KM you can go ahead and vote in this one since Crustanoid also has an assistant in DE.
 
DE is Crustanoid's assistant?
Didn't knew that, guess I'll put my vote then!

If DE is not Crustanoid's assistant, then my vote shouldn't and wouldn't count/
 
Are people seriously rating Sheva ahead of Del Piero, Raul and Ruud?

Considering Sheva is the only one out of the four who has won a Balon'd and has also appeared in Balon'd top three players, I don't know why that's so hard to believe?
 
Considering Sheva is the only one out of the four who has won a Balon'd and has also appeared in Balon'd top three players, I don't know why that's so hard to believe?

So has Michael Owen. Is he better than them as well?
 
tumblr_lizcf0Y6TW1qzfxxeo1_500.jpg


Shakes head at the sheer stupidity of people voting against me on some innocuous internet vote that I really shouldn't be bothered about! If any of you haven't seen Raul, Ruud and Del Piero their peaks I suggest you do before basing your decision on some Wikipedia list of POTY winners you found on the internet
 
At their respective peaks I would do, based on entire career then it is a different story.

I think sheva is a fantastic player, don't get me wrong but at their best I would probably only put him ahead of Ruud in Crustanoids trinity. I just think at their best Del Piero and Raul were basically capable of everything you could want from an attacking player. I rate their ability to pick a pass, ability at set plays (more Del Piero), ability to come up with something extraordinary and ability to adapt to different attacking roles ahead of Sheva. In my opinion though Shevchenko was consistently great for Milan, his highest level is below that of Del Piero and Raul.
 
DE if you can think of a formation / personnel change to convince these spazzers that my players are superior then it's all yours - I'm outta here!

Coldboy here's my after match e-handshake whatever the outcome

handshake.gif
 
I think sheva is a fantastic player, don't get me wrong but at their best I would probably only put him ahead of Ruud in Crustanoids trinity. I just think at their best Del Piero and Raul were basically capable of everything you could want from an attacking player. I rate their ability to pick a pass, ability at set plays (more Del Piero), ability to come up with something extraordinary and ability to adapt to different attacking roles ahead of Sheva. In my opinion though Shevchenko was consistently great for Milan, his highest level is below that of Del Piero and Raul.

TBF there is definitely a good argument for saying Raul is the best on show in this match - he was deadly at his peak and had a wider range than Sheva but I just remember Shev being unstoppable for 3 or 4 seasons at Milan. I dont remember Del Piero reaching that high level though.

BTW I have already said that I think Crust's front 3 is better than ColdBoys so it is not me you need to convince!
 
That's true. But both midfielders on the sides are more than capable of playing out wide in all those formations. It essentially becomes a diamond at times I would think.

Oh and KM you can go ahead and vote in this one since Crustanoid also has an assistant in DE.

Good multi-thread lobbying mate. As it stands, even if Crustanoid edges it he will probably be out and you'll go through.

Interesting... do I want to play you or Cold Boy? Mmmmm...
 
I've to laugh at the sheer stupidity of people who insult those who dare to vote against them. Its just a game.
 
Considering Sheva is the only one out of the four who has won a Balon'd and has also appeared in Balon'd top three players, I don't know why that's so hard to believe?

He's not the only one to have appeared there in the top three. But it's just an award. Xavi has only come in third and Iniesta has only appeared in it once. Torres came third once but I'd still rate Ruud higher or Del Piero. No doubt.
Saying that, Shevchenko was of course a brilliant player. It's not that people aren't rating him. It's that therse three players are together.

Why is it just Ballon d'Or that's rated? It's only journalists that vote. FIFA World Player of the Year was voted on my players and managers. Now of course it's both.
 
I'm not even debating who is better and who isn't. DE's post was implying that as if it's utter madness that Sheva can be better than the other three. Even if there is a difference (which I don't think there is) it's negligible.
 
Squeaky bum time!! Late in the game, scores are tied, I'd put my money on a team with Ruud, Raul and Del Piero ahead of one with Sheva, Litmanen and fecking Wiltord.
 
I'm not even debating who is better and who isn't. DE's post was implying that as if it's utter madness that Sheva can be better than the other three. Even if there is a difference (which I don't think there is) it's negligible.

tumblr_lizcf0Y6TW1qzfxxeo1_500.jpg



Let the wind-ups continue!

Ask yourself if you really want to vote for this guy:

Michael_Ballack_280_798021a.jpg
 
I'm not even debating who is better and who isn't. DE's post was implying that as if it's utter madness that Sheva can be better than the other three. Even if there is a difference (which I don't think there is) it's negligible.

Yea. I get that. There are more players on each team however.
 
If this was a real game it would end with one of those dugout fracases where members of staff get red cards
 
Squeaky bum time!! Late in the game, scores are tied, I'd put my money on a team with Ruud, Raul and Del Piero ahead of one with Sheva, Litmanen and fecking Wiltord.

I bring on DI NATALE for WILTORD.

Di Natale has 80 goals in the last 103 matches for Udinese.