Very hard to prove that Barkley rolled over like that intentionally to kick at Ander when he was blatently dragged him down. I think it was the right decision to book him for getting up so aggressively and getting into Ander's face but def not a red card.
Scholes threw some kind of mma style spinning punch at Alonso I think, he always had a hair trigger of a temper on him that was laughed off due to his class, he had to go for violent conduct that time.
Only hard to prove if you don't watch the footage. Clearly a kick out. Herrera deserved a kick for fouling him like that but barkleys reaction, while understandable, was a red. By the laws of the game that is, rather than my opinion.
