To make a such a list will contain more of attacking players or attacking minded players at the expense of the less attacking minded players but very very good in their roles.
I feel the different sections of the field need certain types of talents to really excel.
Players like Buffon, Neuer, Schmeichel, Maldini, at a point Casillas, Nesta, Carlos, Cafu, Lahm, Scholes, Xavi, Iniesta, Modric, Even Yaya Youre and Debruyne all deserve to be mentioned in the conversation of most talented players.
I think 'Top Ten Most Talented Players By Position' should see a more inclusive list of players.
For me it is 'Messi' as the best and most talented player in the world and Ronaldinho as the most flair player I have ever seen in pro football.
My list goes thus
Most talented Keepers
Oliver Kahn
Neuer
Schmeichel
Buffon
Casillas
De gea (I know I know his legs)
Ter Stegen
...
...
...
Most talented CB
Baresi
Beckanbeaur
Cannavaro
Nesta
Ferdinand
Van dijk
Boateng
...
...
...
Most talented Fb
Maldini
Carlos
Lahm
Cafu
Alaba
Dani Alves ( I Kno I know)
...
...
...
Most talented DM
Makelele
Robson
Pirlo
Busquets
Kante
Roy Keane
Edgar David's
...
...
...
Most talented CMs
Xavi
Iniesta
Scholes
Modric
Kroos
Fabregas
Schweinsteiger
Yaya Toure (that one year at City)
maybe Pogba
Beckham
Most talented AMs
Maradona
Ronaldinho
Messi
Zico
Zidane
Kaka
De bruyne
Hazard
Deco
...
...
...
Most talented Left Wingers
C.Ronaldo
Best
Nedved
Rivaldo
Ribery
Henry
...
...
...
Most talented RW
Messi
Messi
Beckham
Robben
...
...
...
Most talented SS
Messi
Johan Cruyff
Di Stefano
Platini
Batistuta
Totti
Del Piero
...
...
...
Most talented CF
Ronaldo
van Basten
Bobby Charton
Romario
C.Ronaldo
Henry
David Villa
Luis Suarez
Owen
Lewandoski
Notable mention
Zlatan
Rooney
Gerard
Lampard
Da Silva
Simeon
Vidic
Varane
Casemiro
Xabi Alonso
Ramos
Pique
Jordi Alba
Dennis Bergkamp
etc