Who should stay and who should go?

Sharpe

Guest
OUT:
Butt- totally replaceable. Scholes can do the same job 10 times better. And it really annoies me that he thinks he has become somewhat of a playmeker like veron etc. He's NOT

Chadwick- he's nowhere near Man Utd material. Birmingham, Ipswich tops! Too old to be labelled a talent anymore..

Ricardo- simply cannot have a keeper that gives away a penalty each game.

Bartez- don't chop my head off here. A really good keeper, but also very replacable. Sell him while we still can get a decent amount of money for him...

May- need arguments?

...Anuway. This is my wiew. What do you think?
:p
 
Chadwick, Ricardo, May, and may be Stewart.

Butt is a good backup midfielder. We shouldn't sell him except a very, very good offer comes in.
 
My God. I forgot fortune!!
Sorry. Seems like the gaffer has a thing for him though... :o
 
my god are u guys mad!!!!!!!
Butt- i think he is superb, he does not create much but still doesnot look like a liability ask Eriksson. he is a great guy to have the fact him being United through and through and he also doesnot mind sitting on the bench.
Fortune- give him a few starts in the centre of midfield and i am telling you you will start loving him. He is always fired up and likes getting stuck into challenegs and also is decent going forward. We as Man Unt should have 4 central Mfs -> Keano, Seba, Butty, Fortune(as scholesy plays upfront).
OUT-
Ricardo- If he was 4-5 years younger it was Ok. To be fair to him he hasnt had a chance to prove himself. but he is 30-31 after Carroll in Fergies view things dont seem to be going right for im.
Chadwick- Well has pace but restricted to short passes and can be easily shrugged off. Quaresma should be the Right Winger after Becks as even Ole is 30 and he is our only out and out forward after Ruud. So lets preserve him for that role by bringing Quaresma.
May- At 31-32 he should not be in the reserves let him go.
 
Butt-simply has not looked good all season tho few may argue with me.definitely not as good as he was in the world cup.
Chadwick, Ricardo ,May definitely out.
Fortune looks to have great potential and he looked great in the last match
 
Butt - a reliable and worthy deputy for Keane. Good value for breaking down opponents' legs.. I mean moves..

Chadwick - time to go

Ricardo - didn't have much chance to prove himself and unlikely to have more chances in the future. Good value if we can sell him for $3mil

Barthez - great but prone to simple errors. Not commanding enough to guide the young backfour. We need a great leader in defense. Someone who can emulate the presence of Kahn, Buffon, Toldo, Schmeichel..

May - another Blanc worth hanging around to give some guidance to the young

Fortune - let him play a few more games. I like his aggression and we can also use him to back-up Giggsy when we need someone to defend a lead towards the end of a game

Veron - didn't see him excel as much as he does playing for Argentina. Maybe the overwhelming number of star players and playmakers in Man Utd prevented him from wielding his magic wand as much as he wants to. Never see him play well alongside Keano. A conflict of talents perhaps. Don't mind selling him for $20mil and get a talented striker to partner RVN.

Forlan - not suited to the English game's aggressiveness and pace. Possibly more suitable playing for an Italian or Spanish club. I'll sell him for $4mil.
 
Butt - a reliable and worthy deputy for Keane. Good value for breaking down opponents' legs.. I mean moves..

Chadwick - time to go

Ricardo - didn't have much chance to prove himself and unlikely to have more chances in the future. Good value if we can sell him for $3mil

Barthez - great but prone to simple errors. Not commanding enough to guide the young backfour. We need a great leader in defense. Someone who can emulate the presence of Kahn, Buffon, Toldo, Schmeichel..

May - another Blanc worth hanging around to give some guidance to the young

Fortune - let him play a few more games. I like his aggression and we can also use him to back-up Giggsy when we need someone to defend a lead towards the end of a game

Veron - didn't see him excel as much as he does playing for Argentina. Maybe the overwhelming number of star players and playmakers in Man Utd prevented him from wielding his magic wand as much as he wants to. Never see him play well alongside Keano. A conflict of talents perhaps. Don't mind selling him for $20mil and get a talented striker to partner RVN.

Forlan - not suited to the English game's aggressiveness and pace. Possibly more suitable playing for an Italian or Spanish club. I'll sell him for $4mil.
 
G.STAUCE IS VERY GOOD AND CHEAP GOALKEEPER FROM LITHUANIA!!! TRUST ME!!!!!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.