Which Zep Track?

Hoof the ball

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2008
Messages
13,881
Location
San Antonio, Texas.
Babe I'm Gonna Leave you VS Since I've Been Lovin' You (Blues)

Trampled Underfoot vs The Crunge (Funk)

Stairway To Heaven vs When The Levee Breaks (Epic)

Going To California vs The Battle of Evermore (Acoustic/Folk)
 
Babe I'm Gonna Leave you < Since I've Been Lovin' You (Blues)

Trampled Underfoot > The Crunge (Funk)

Stairway To Heaven > When The Levee Breaks (Epic)

Going To California > The Battle of Evermore (Acoustic/Folk)

Hope this helps
 
Babe I'm Gonna Leave you < Since I've Been Lovin' You (Blues)

Trampled Underfoot > The Crunge (Funk)

Stairway To Heaven > When The Levee Breaks (Epic)

Going To California > The Battle of Evermore (Acoustic/Folk)

Hope this helps

Oh, it did, more than you'll ever know :)

I agree with all them choices, except I would take Battle of Evermore over Going To California. I know that majority opinion will go with Going to california but i prefer Battle.

Feel free to add more to the list, folks.
 
Babe I'm Gonna Leave you VS Since I've Been Lovin' You (Blues)

Trampled Underfoot vs The Crunge (Funk)

Stairway To Heaven vs When The Levee Breaks (Epic)

Going To California vs The Battle of Evermore (Acoustic/Folk)
That's my three favorite Zep songs.
 
cant believe the ocean isnt up for debate yet - IMO the greatest Zep song along with Good times Bad times!
 
Here's some vids from the O2 reunion concert from 2007 :-

Good Times, Bad Times


Kashmir


Whole Lotta Love


Stairway To Heaven


I've got most of the rest of the entire set if you wanna see it, folks.
 
Since I've Been Lovin' You (Blues)

Trampled Underfoot (Funk)

When The Levee Breaks (Epic)

The Battle of Evermore (Acoustic/Folk)

fantastic tracks.
Love Sandy Denny on "The Battle of Evermore"
 
When The Levee Breaks is a delta blues about the Mississippi flood of 1927.
Possibly my favourite Led Zep cover.
 
Those vocals on that song are straight out of the blues book. Going To California is folk.

The riffs on Page's guitar alone are BB King-influenced (Page admitted so in Rollingstone Mag).

its a folk song re-interpreted...but id say its a stretch to say its a blues song in the style of since ive been loving you or I cant quit you babe...obviously jimmy knows what hes talking about...but for the life of me i cant think of which parts of it are BB king influenced.
 
its a folk song re-interpreted...but id say its a stretch to say its a blues song in the style of since ive been loving you or I cant quit you babe...obviously jimmy knows what hes talking about...but for the life of me i cant think of which parts of it are BB king influenced.
Song Review by Bill Janovitz

From their 1969 debut self-titled LP, "Babe, I'm Gonna Leave You" lays out the road map for what Led Zeppelin would be about for the next decade: a blues-based hard rock/ heavy metal band that was interested as much in acoustic guitars as they were in screaming amplifiers; Celtic, Middle Eastern, and other folk music traditions as much as the American blues tradition; heavy drumming as well as quiet interludes; and using the recording studio and experimentation to the full advantage -- resulting in rich, hard-hitting, multi-layered, and multi-faceted records. The song is based around a Jimmy Page minor-key acoustic figure over which vocalist Robert Plant croons a well-worn warning about being a rambling man. The rhythm section -- one of the greatest and most influential in rock & roll history -- of John Paul Jones on bass and John Bonham on drums, kicks in on an almost flamenco pre-chorus riff and, finally, a descending, syncopated, and hard-rocking chorus that incites Plant into his trademark upper-register howl. Perhaps only Jimi Hendrix and the Experience, who also worked with engineer Eddie Kramer, had as versatile a sound at the time, varying from soft acoustic balladry to pounding hard rock -- many times within the same song. Indeed, the drastic swoops of dynamics within their songs laid out a game plan for rock music that could still be heard in the post-punk and alternative rock scene as the 1990s gave way to the new millennium. For Led Zeppelin, "Babe, I'm Gonna Leave You" helped propel their debut into the Top Ten in the U.S. at a time when album oriented rock radio was in its infancy. One bothersome issue about Led Zeppelin is that, unlike their colleagues in the Rolling Stones and other British bands that took a great deal of influence from traditional music and often went to great lengths to pay respect to older artists and writers -- Led Zeppelin often placed their own names on works that can easily be attributed, at least in part, to other songwriters. Thus you have "Babe, I'm Gonna Leave You," which on the album is credited as " traditional, arranged by Jimmy Page" when it was in fact written by Anne Bredon (aka Annie Briggs). Apparently, it took legal action to change the credit to " Bredon/ Page/ Plant." There is quite an extensive list of other instances where it can be argued that Led Zeppelin went far beyond merely incorporating their blues and folk influences. Joan Baez did a mournful version of "Babe, I'm Gonna Leave You" in 1962, well before Led Zeppelin, on the live record Joan Baez in Concert, Pt. 1, based on the 1950s Bredon version. Great White, who was almost a Led Zeppelin tribute band, covered the Zeppelin version.
 
From Rolling Stone.


Subtlety would play a much larger part on later Zeppelin works; for now, the mission was to create a music of extremes, one that appealed to hard-core album buyers rather than the Top Forty marketplace. That was never more true than on "Babe I'm Gonna Leave You," a moody folk song until the dam bursts, Bonham cuts loose and the shape of things to come - most famously, a ditty named "Stairway to Heaven" - is glimpsed.

GREG KOT
 
From Rolling Stone.


Subtlety would play a much larger part on later Zeppelin works; for now, the mission was to create a music of extremes, one that appealed to hard-core album buyers rather than the Top Forty marketplace. That was never more true than on "Babe I'm Gonna Leave You," a moody folk song until the dam bursts, Bonham cuts loose and the shape of things to come - most famously, a ditty named "Stairway to Heaven" - is glimpsed.

GREG KOT

:lol: Feck sake, let's just call a stalemate on this issue!

Let us agree that it has elements of both Blues Rock and Folk in it.
 
indeed was gonna suggest the same.


you think its a blues track...id say its more a folk-rock track expanded.

lets just leave it at that











no matter how fecking wrong you are.;):D
 
Apart from the fact that Page said it was blues influence, himself and Robert Plant was practically a blues singer before he was with Zep, then I'd be more than willing to stalemate here............
























Of course, you are wrong ;-)
 
yeah youve said that a few times now....still to prove to me Page actually said that though.

Jimmy takes his reading of the song from world famous folk singer Joan Baez's interpretation of the song written by folk singer Anne Bredon that she learnt from fellow folk singer Janet smith...but its a blues song...obvious when you think about it.

its not as if it follows a folk standard chord sequence before going into the old 25 or 6 to 4 riff...