Transfer system overhaul

Neil Thomson

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 21, 2001
Messages
13,228
Location
Hippydom
Not sure where to put this story, but it heralds a much needed change to English football.

<a href="http://sport.independent.co.uk/football/news/story.jsp?story=323647" target="_blank">The Independent</a>

Football chiefs plan revolution to save the game
FA aims to take control of all transfers. Clubs may have to cap players' salaries

By James Lawton, Chief Sports Writer
12 August 2002

The Football Association is planning a revolution for the national game with much tighter rules governing players' wages, transfer dealing and the activities of agents.

The measures will be announced in the next few weeks and come as the game is facing unprecedented financial problems. They follow a large-scale survey by Mori commissioned by Adam Crozier, the FA's chief executive, soon after his appointment two-and-a-half years ago.

The survey, involving thousands of interviews at all levels of the game, delivers the chilling verdict that only a dramatic – and draconian – restructuring of the game's finances can head off a disastrous decline in its role as a cornerstone of national life.

The first result of the Mori findings will be the setting up of an American-style clearing house to monitor and supervise all transfer deals. It will also monitor the role of players' agents, who have over recent years been driving up the wages of individual players while often flouting the terms and the spirit of existing contracts.

There will be discussions between the Premiership, Football League, the FA and the Professional Footballers' Association on the pressing need to cap salaries and general budgets, which is a concept long accepted in the multi-million-dollar professional sports industry in the United States.

In an exclusive interview, Mr Crozier told The Independent: "Football has gone through a period of monumental growth and it has to be recognised that no business can ever keep going like that. It has to level off at some point. The trick is to sort yourself out before it does."

Ironically, the Mori report, which in essence tells football to change its financial thinking or die, arrived at the FA's Soho Square offices just before the collapse of ITV Digital, which is costing Football League clubs about £140m of largely mortgaged income and threatening the survival of at least half of them.

Mr Crozier added: "This whole survey took nine months and it leaves no doubt that one issue, whether you are a Sunday morning player or someone right at the top, stands above all – it is finance and its effect on football.

"It has confirmed our belief that the long-term viability of the game has to be at the top of our priorities. There are lots of people in football who want it to work and what we have to do is get together with all elements in the game and find a way that works for everybody.

"Maybe this won't be in the way everyone envisages, and certainly not the way it has always been, but life is changing for everyone these days and football cannot hope to be an exception.

"We have to start this whole exercise from the position that football is the national game and people love it. So we have got to make it work in new conditions. The instinct here at the FA is to create a sense of controlled change. Rather than seeing the need for change as a bad thing, it has to be embraced by everybody who grasps that football matters so much to so many people. We should know now that in a few short weeks only God knows how many things can happen in football.

"We can't just sit around saying we want everything to stay the same. That's just not going to happen. It can't happen."

Mr Crozier, the former chief executive of the Saatchi & Saatchi advertising company, recognises that he faces his biggest challenge. He has to lead the fight to rationalise the wild economics of English football.
 
It wont work in Europe the way it works in the states. There are multiple countries with different currencies, which would make it impossible.
 
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>It wont work in Europe the way it works in the states. There are multiple countries with different currencies, which would make it impossible.</strong><hr></blockquote>
For sure it will have to suit our own setup, but the FA are very serious about this. Its vital imo, wages and transfer fees, and agent cuts, have spiralled out of all proportion.
 
everyone got greedy. Pound signs flashed before all their eyes as the TV companies got involved.
The premiership teams should start taking stock too. Imagine where theyd be if Sky was for some reason to suddenly pull the plug? Doesnt bare thinking about..
 
Originally posted by golden_blunder:
<strong>everyone got greedy. Pound signs flashed before all their eyes as the TV companies got involved.
The premiership teams should start taking stock too. Imagine where theyd be if Sky was for some reason to suddenly pull the plug? Doesnt bare thinking about..</strong><hr></blockquote>
2 years left on the Sky deal, and no chance it'll be for as much next time round.
 
Originally posted by Neil Thomson:
<strong>
2 years left on the Sky deal, and no chance it'll be for as much next time round.</strong><hr></blockquote>

It seems to me that financially the football world is declining except for some teams in England and one team in Spain...
 
It wont work in Europe the way it works in the states. There are multiple countries with different currencies, which would make it impossible. <hr></blockquote>

errrmmmm mainland Europe has the Euro as the currency, so all "major" footballing countries have one currency except for the Brits.
 
Originally posted by mr_hestinks:
<strong>

errrmmmm mainland Europe has the Euro as the currency, so all "major" footballing countries have one currency except for the Brits.</strong><hr></blockquote>

correct, and the Brits have one of the biggest and most profitable football leagues in the world so it obviously wouldn't work. Furthermore, Euro sides routinely buy players from South American clubs. Another glitch with the idea.
 
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>

correct, and the Brits have one of the biggest and most profitable football leagues in the world so it obviously wouldn't work.</strong><hr></blockquote>

Do you know what the word 'obviously' means? It isn't obvious at all.

The English (not the Brits) have a league which maybe is second or third in Europe. England has 50 million people, the EU has 400.

If the other 350 million decide to make something work, the Brits will come scampering after them. Not the other way round.

Do you know what 'profitable' means? British football never has been profitable and surely it is glaringly obvious that it isn't profitable right now.
 
Very nice sarcasm. Unfortunately, it still doesn't explain how the system would work with multiple currencies, nations who aren't part of the EU, clubs from South America or Asia etc. There's obviously a problem if you look at the bigger picture.
 
Yet the FA are behind the idea, and we'll see proposals soon enough. It will be quite easy with domestic transfers - the tricky bit may well be international transfers, but I'm sure that they can make some progress regarding agents at least. Anyway, we'll have to wait and see what they come up with. There can be no doubt that something is needed. The idea of a public register of salaries is a good idea.
 
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>Very nice sarcasm. Unfortunately, it still doesn't explain how the system would work with multiple currencies, nations who aren't part of the EU, clubs from South America or Asia etc. There's obviously a problem if you look at the bigger picture.</strong><hr></blockquote>

How exactly will it not work? How does currency come into the picture in messing things up?
 
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>Very nice sarcasm. Unfortunately, it still doesn't explain how the system would work with multiple currencies, nations who aren't part of the EU, clubs from South America or Asia etc. There's obviously a problem if you look at the bigger picture.</strong><hr></blockquote>

What's the problem with the currency? Just convert it, it isn't even a difficult mathetmatical function.
 
Currency wont matter. Clubs will only be allowed to spend a certain % of their income on wages eg 50% (or 85% if you are Blackburn) so that costs are kept at manageable levels. If a club overspends and gets relegated and looses their "cash cow" eg Bradford, they are in danger of folding. If this was any other industry half the clubs would already have been liquidated but because clubs are community based etc etc they get given a longer period to sort themselves out (and for the supporters whe get screwed in the 1st place) to raise more cash to help the club survive. Clubs like Real being bailed out by the Spanish Govt wont happen again because of EU anti competition laws (the airlines are no longer able to be bailed out by Govts and this will spread) and it will be interesting to see how they change their structures when they get skint again.