Top Ten Summer Signings

Bestie07

Full Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2008
Messages
8,032
Location
He went by the name of Wayne Rooney
10. Samuel Eto'o to Chelsea
Although Eto'o featured in the Top Ten Underwhelming Signings, it's difficult to argue that the striker isn't a bargain on a free transfer. A move for Wayne Rooney would have generated much more of a buzz at Stamford Bridge, but Jose Mourinho's faith in Eto'o suggests the forward may have enough left in the tank to lead the line this season. The 32-year-old is no longer at the peak of his powers but, with Chelsea's many and various attacking midfielders providing support, he could prove to be a shrewd stop-gap signing before a renewed move for Rooney next summer. Let's hope he's here for one last hurrah rather than an overstayed welcome at the top level.


9. Sascha Riether to Fulham
This may be the most boring suggestion imaginable, but Fulham's decision to make Sascha Riether's loan move permanent is one of the more sensible deals in a summer of splurging. Martin Jol has had to make the most of a limited budget and a £1million move for last year's Mr Dependable is money well spent. Indeed, there was talk of Schalke offering Fulham double their outlay for Riether just two weeks later. The 30-year-old will do little to lower the Cottagers' alarming average age, but he is one of the Premier League's unsung heroes and can be relied upon for another season of consistency.


8. Jonathan de Guzman to Swansea
After De Guzman helped Swansea to the League Cup and ninth place in the Premier League last season, agreeing another deal for the Dutchman was high on Michael Laudrup's list of priorities. At first it was reported that Villarreal were demanding £8million for the 25-year-old, who picked up his first international cap last season, but eventually another season-long loan was struck. Considering how important he has proved to Swansea's style of play, De Guzman could be an even more crucial signing than the club's £12million acquisition of Wilfried Bony.


7. Nathan Redmond to Norwich
Although not as exciting as the capture of Dutch duo Ricky van Wolfswinkel and Leroy Fer, Redmond's arrival from Birmingham could turn out to be Norwich's best bit of business in a busy summer. The Canaries paid just £3.5million for the England Under-21 star and he has already chipped in with the winning goal in the club's first victory of the season against Southampton. Redmond adds zip and incision to a Norwich side that were often quite ponderous in Anthony Pilkington's absence last season and he has completed the highest number of dribbles in the Premier League so far. It's a no-lose deal for Norwich and should Redmond continue to show promise, they can expect his sell-on value to soar over the course of the season.


6. Gary Medel and Steven Caulker to Cardiff
As Daniel Storey wrote here, defence is often a manager's blind spot when it comes to strengthening for a survival bid, but Cardiff have reinforced the spine of their team with two quality recruits. Paying £8million for an England international defender is a particularly shrewd piece of business and whatever happens to the Bluebirds this season, they will still be able to recoup their outlay on Caulker. Medel was more expensive at around £11million, but I'm a huge fan of the Chilean after watching him marshal the midfield for the national team and Sevilla. If Malky Mackay can keep Medel fit and focused Cardiff stand every chance of survival. They won't top any fair play leagues, mind.


5. Tom Huddlestone to Hull
After spurning several opportunities to leave Spurs over the past three years, it was strange to see Huddlestone turn up at relegation candidates Hull earlier in the summer. The move to the KC Stadium was surely not what Huddlestone had been holding out for, but alongside fellow new signing Jake Livermore, the 26-year-old has immediately provided more backbone in Steve Bruce's midfield. The duo's composed performances against Norwich were instrumental in Hull holding on to their 1-0 lead after Yannick Sagbo's dismissal for a head-butt and much of the Tigers' survival hopes will be pinned on Huddlestone maintaining his early form.


4. Erik Lamela to Tottenham
The first time I saw Lamela play was at the Under-20 World Cup in 2011. Although a precocious talent with superb technical ability, the then River Plate forward was often betrayed by his decision-making as he strived to make a name for himself. A move to Roma followed and just two years later Lamela finds himself at Spurs on the back of his most impressive season to date. Now a much savvier forward, the 21-year-old grabbed 15 goals and five assists in Serie A last year and he should prove to be the pick of Spurs' signings. It's now up to him and fellow new arrival Christian Erisken to provide the service Roberto Soldado requires.


3. Mamadou Sakho to Liverpool
Kolo Toure's first two Premier League appearances for Liverpool prove that he was worth taking a punt on as a free transfer, but Sakho's arrival says a great deal more about the club's long-term philosophy. Make no mistake, for £12million Sakho is a statement signing that shows Liverpool are serious in their quest to build a squad worthy of the top four. The former PSG captain provides fierce competition for Daniel Agger on the left side of Brendan Rodgers' defence and he will expect to play a big part after taking a step down from the Ligue 1 champions. With Victor Moses also joining on a season-long loan, the Reds wrapped up some impressive business on deadline day as they look to maintain their brilliant start to the campaign.


2. Romelu Lukaku To Everton
When I wrote that Everton were struggling for firepower in Winners and Losers, I didn't expect the Toffees to go out and sign a striker of Lukaku's quality on Monday. The Toffees had a brilliant deadline day and a solid window overall with Lukaku the pick of several quality additions. West Brom will be gutted that they missed out on bringing the Belgian back to the Hawthorns after his 17 Premier League goals last season and it's a surprise that Chelsea have allowed him to leave when they are so short of convincing options in the centre-forward role. The Blues' loss is Everton's gain and following two matches without a goal, Roberto Martinez now has the striker he requires to fire the Toffees up the table.


1. Mesut Ozil to Arsenal
"What excites Arsène isn't necessarily what excites you," was Ivan Gazidis' warning back in June when he spoke of an escalation in financial firepower. While that may be true of free transfer signings Yaya Sanogo and Mathieu Flamini, the £42.4m deal for Mesut Ozil is a massive coup for both Arsenal and the Premier League. There is surely not a fan in the country who isn't looking forward to watching him play for the Gunners. There is a case that Arsenal haven't strengthened the right areas or as much as they needed to, but when a player of Ozil's talent becomes available it's hardly irresponsible to focus all your efforts on securing that one blockbuster deal. The 24-year-old has already provided an enormous boost to the club, with Jack Wilshere and Santi Cazorla tweeting their excitement and Wenger, who Ozil has emphasised was a key part of his decision, vindicated for not throwing his budget at the first big name that became available. Ozil provided 67 assists during his three years at Real Madrid and played a crucial role in the club's recent success, with fans chanting "Don't sell Ozil" at Gareth Bale's unveiling on Monday. This will surely be a deal that Florentino Perez lives to regret, but for Arsenal it could prove a game-changer.

http://www.football365.com/faves/8904157/F365-s-Top-Ten-Summer-Signings...

I'm surprised that us finally adding a midfielder fails to get a mention over the likes of Huddlestone or Riether. Reckon Fellaini will give us a solid base in midfield which will give our creative players more freedom. Something which we have lacked in recent years. Think Erikson should have also been there. Mine would be, not in any particular order after the first one:

Ozil
Lamela
Erikson
Fellaini
Wanyama
Lukaku
Jovetic
Sakho
Negredo
Soldado
 
No chance that Fellaini for 27.5m is one of the top ten summer signings... The list is not bad at all though the inclusion of Riether is a bit surprising. And we'll see about Eto'o: who knows how much he might have lost while chasing the money.
 
For me:

1) Ozil
2) Sakho
3) Fellaini
4) Lukaku
5) Lamela
 
No chance that Fellaini for 27.5m is one of the top ten summer signings... The list is not bad at all though the inclusion of Riether is a bit surprising. And we'll see about Eto'o: who knows how much he might have lost while chasing the money.

When you look at the signing in terms of what we've needed in midfield for a long time, I think that it's definitely in the top 10. The price is hardly anything shocking either, especially in today's market.

In saying that, I do think these lists are a bit pointless before any of them have kicked a ball, but what can you do.
 
When you look at the signing in terms of what we've needed in midfield for a long time, I think that it's definitely in the top 10. The price is hardly anything shocking either, especially in today's market.

In saying that, I do think these lists are a bit pointless before any of them have kicked a ball, but what can you do.

By that logic, you could say almost any midfielder who's decent or more would be regarded as a top 10 signing - which I don't think is the right way to look at it.

When you look at all the signings made this window, you'd have to be looking through United specs to call Fellaini one of the top 10.
 
These lists are always ridiculous when made early on. No way of telling how good any signing is, cheap expensive or otherwise.
 
James McCarthy is a good coup. Considering he's British, which usually inflates prices, £13million seems like a solid fee for a player of his ability. I think his potential is still very high too. I think he'll improve as his experience grows.

I think the McCarthy deal is probably overshadowed by getting Lukaku. That's a good deal, but it's only a short term fix. McCarthy is very young, and could easily become the focal point of their midfield for a long time if they can keep hold of him. A midfield 3 of McCarthy, Barkley and Gibson could be excellent in a couple of years.

I dunno. Maybe I'm overrating McCarthy. I think he's excellent.
 
No chance that Fellaini for 27.5m is one of the top ten summer signings... The list is not bad at all though the inclusion of Riether is a bit surprising. And we'll see about Eto'o: who knows how much he might have lost while chasing the money.


Bollocks. He fills more than a few needs and considering the market value of players these days (Bale) He is DEFINITELY a top ten signing
 
By that logic, you could say almost any midfielder who's decent or more would be regarded as a top 10 signing - which I don't think is the right way to look at it.

When you look at all the signings made this window, you'd have to be looking through United specs to call Fellaini one of the top 10.

What? I'm looking at it in terms of our needs and the fact that I rate him higher than most seem to on here. It's obviously not just because he's a midfielder that I'd put him in the top 10. That'd be quite delusional alright.
 
People look at Fellaini and see him as an unsinspiring signing, but as far as I am concerned, a Fellaini-Carrick combo in midfield gives us a solid base to build from, something which we have lacked ever since Fletcher's injury. We may be able to field the muppet dream front four of Kagawa - Rooney - Nani - RVP which we hadn't seen previously because of doubts over defensive workrate of Kagawa and Nani. And Fellaini is not just a destroyer, he is a good passer, and he irritates the hell out of the opposition, he'll be our twat in midfield, and for that alone he should be in the top ten.

McCarthy should be up there as well.
 
Bollocks. He fills more than a few needs and considering the market value of players these days (Bale) He is DEFINITELY a top ten signing

It was a very obvious signing which everyone predicted we would make, and we signed him for 4m higher than his release clause. It's very doubtful that he can make the step up to this level and it's still uncertain what his best position is. At first glance it's nowhere near a top 10 signing.
 
Bollocks. He fills more than a few needs and considering the market value of players these days (Bale) He is DEFINITELY a top ten signing

I don't get it.
 
Seems very hard to do really when any fair/real guess would have to take into account their effect on the club they are at... For example, Sakho probably has a lot higher ceiling than Fellaini, but in terms of this season and what we got from what was paid and hopefully the impact he has to the team, I would expect to be greater.
 
What? I'm looking at it in terms of our needs and the fact that I rate him higher than most seem to on here. It's obviously not just because he's a midfielder that I'd put him in the top 10. That'd be quite delusional alright.

You never said anything about rating him, your original argument was "If you look at the signing in terms what we've needed in midfield for a long time" - and let's be fair, a lot of people would argue that we needed someone like Fabregas/Modric in our midfield more then we need Fellaini - which implies that because he fills a gaping whole in our squad, he's automatically a top 10 signing, which I don't think is the case, as there are better targets - either through quality or affordability that we have been linked too/might have got instead.
 
You never said anything about rating him, your original argument was "If you look at the signing in terms what we've needed in midfield for a long time" - and let's be fair, a lot of people would argue that we needed someone like Fabregas/Modric in our midfield more then we need Fellaini - which implies that because he fills a gaping whole in our squad, he's automatically a top 10 signing, which I don't think is the case, as there are better targets - either through quality or affordability that we have been linked too/might have got instead.

Well I implied it by saying that he's the type of player that we've needed in midfield for a long time. I wouldn't have said that if I didn't rate him somewhat.
 
1. Ozil
2. Soldado
3. Erikssen
4. Lamela
5. Canas
6. Negredo
7. Navas
8. Bony
9. van Wolfswinkel
10. Fellaini

In no order and according to value.
 
It was a very obvious signing which everyone predicted we would make, and we signed him for 4m higher than his release clause. It's very doubtful that he can make the step up to this level and it's still uncertain what his best position is. At first glance it's nowhere near a top 10 signing.


Very doubtful huh? He has scored against all the top clubs for Everton, he is established in a strong Belgian team and now he is surrounded by better players in a better team and yet you think its very doubtful.
 
You dont get that a player who fills a lot of a teams needs isnt a top signing? His value is about right in the current market. Tbh a lot of people on here will be eating humble pie soon.


When his value was 4m less no one wanted to buy him, including yourselves. You paid a desperation tax of 20% on top of the fee you didn't bother paying earlier in the summer. That obviously doesn't reflect value in the market.

That you have been crying out for a midfielder and he was the one you ended up with doesn't make him any better of a signing.
 
Very doubtful huh? He has scored against all the top clubs for Everton, he is established in a strong Belgian team and now he is surrounded by better players in a better team and yet you think its very doubtful.

All that was true about Ashley Young as well. Okay, he's not Belgian but he was pretty much an England regular when we signed him.
 
For me:

1) Ozil
2) Sakho
3) Fellaini
4) Lukaku
5) Lamela

Probably go along with that, splitting hairs with these lists and the likes of McCarthy and Caulker could be up there as well but thats a good effort

Fellaini is going to surprise a few on here
 
1. Fellaini - Big midfielder, bigger fee, biggest hair
2. Varela - 5th choice right back
3. Janko - 6th choice right back
4. Apollo Tyres - Giving Indians the stopping power they deserve.
5. Bulova - Because Hublot didn't want us anymore.
6. Pepsi - Not as good as Coke.
7. Federal Tyres - F*** you Apollo.
8. AFB - Credit cards for Kenyans
9. Kagome - Shinji Kagawa
10. Aeroflot - Safety first
 
The Ozil fapfest is getting rather tedious. At 40m, is he really the best buy of the summer. Basically Arsenal would have to win the league in order for that to be the case, and that's likely.
 
Why would they have to win the league?

Arsenal were way more than £40 million off even challenging for the title. They'd need another £40 million on top of Ozil just for that
 
Why would they have to win the league?

Arsenal were way more than £40 million off even challenging for the title. They'd need another £40 million on top of Ozil just for that


If Ozil doesn't improve them significantly (ie winning the league or making the CL semis or better), it would be hard to say the 40m they just spunked on him could be regarded as the top signing of the summer.
 
If Ozil doesn't improve them significantly (ie winning the league or making the CL semis or better), it would be hard to say the 40m they just spunked on him could be regarded as the top signing of the summer.

Oh as the top signing. Yeah they'd have to have a great season but I think you're being a bit extreme. Consider how much money they've made in the past few seasons selling all their best players and spending a lot less replacing them. They needed that £40 million just to show some signs of life and push on from 4th spot. Without it they wouldnt even have got that. So a really good season for Arsenal is 2nd-3rd
 
Any of Spurs' signings apart from Chadli, seeing as they managed to attract those players without the lure of CL football.

I think Bony will be great for Swansea. He was only £12m, which is a bit of a steal for a guy who scored 38 goals in 39 games last season.
 
Isco for £20M-23.5M (depending on whom you choose to believe) by a country mile for me.