Rugby Union 23/24 Discussion

I watched England Wales yesterday with my mate and his dad was over from Wales….said he’d stopped doing to the national games in Cardiff because the shite atmosphere wasn’t worth the hassle and expense

The drone of people talking is audible.
It sounds like a large train station
 
Sheehan has a ridiculous amount of tries considering his position.
Hookers and wingers….always the leading try scorers. If any other position does it you know they’ve done well :lol:
 
I miss Sexton. Feels like he never missed a kick. Whoever this fella is needs to practice more.
 
Hookers really? I didn't know that. You'll have to explain the why to me sometime.
Always get the ball from driving mauls. Hookers score loads in mauling teams

Think Harry Thacker at Bristol topped the Premiership a few seasons ago? I’d have to check
 
Ireland have the BP already so now they just have to run through the motions and hope for no injuries.
I was at the game in Rome last year and it was a lot closer.
 
Always get the ball from driving mauls. Hookers score loads in mauling teams

Think Harry Thacker at Bristol topped the Premiership a few seasons ago? I’d have to check

Is it because of their position in the mauls?
 
George Turner’s head injury assessment came after ‘smart’ mouthguard alert

Scotland hooker first elite male player to be taken off for HIA after gumshield detected impact

George Turner, the Scotland hooker, made history in Saturday’s Six Nations game against France by becoming the first elite male player to be sent for a head injury assessment after his “smart” mouthguard flagged a potentially concerning level of head impact in a tackle.

This championship is the first time that elite male players have worn “instrumented” mouthguards that ping alerts to an app being tracked by an independent medic whenever a “head acceleration event with G-force that exceeds 70G and 4,000 radians per second squared” is detected.

https://archive.is/A9d64
 
Yeah, they throw the ball in to the lineout then join the maul at the back. Ball usually gets filtered back to them and they're the ones to touch it down if the maul gets over the try line.
True but Sheehan still gets more than his fair share of tries. Super player.
 
George Turner’s head injury assessment came after ‘smart’ mouthguard alert

Scotland hooker first elite male player to be taken off for HIA after gumshield detected impact



https://archive.is/A9d64

Great idea.

My young fella has been playing club rugby this season for the first time. I’m much more used to being on the sideline of football pitches so this is all a bit new to me. I’’ve been really impressed how seriously they take any potential knocks to the head. No messing around. Game stops immediately. Player assessed and (almost always) subbed off. You can tell everyone involved really wants to do their bit to make it safer.

Doesn’t stop me shitting myself when his 55kg frame is crashing into 100kg second rows though. Can be hard to watch. Similar vibes when Casey got absolutely levelled by one of the Italian forwards. Couldn’t believe how quickly he got up. Tough little bastard.
 
Great idea.

My young fella has been playing club rugby this season for the first time. I’m much more used to being on the sideline of football pitches so this is all a bit new to me. I’’ve been really impressed how seriously they take any potential knocks to the head. No messing around. Game stops immediately. Player assessed and (almost always) subbed off. You can tell everyone involved really wants to do their bit to make it safer.

Doesn’t stop me shitting myself when his 55kg frame is crashing into 100kg second rows though. Can be hard to watch. Similar vibes when Casey got absolutely levelled by one of the Italian forwards. Couldn’t believe how quickly he got up. Tough little bastard.
I reckon the coaches are more shitscared of injury than the parents :lol:

One of my colleagues coached and reffed youth teams for years. He told me he used to say a little prayer every time a scrum collapsed. Doesn’t bear thinking about
 
Yup, an offside player can only be put onside by the kicker or a player who was behind the kicker when the kick was made.
It’s much better, no incentive to run the ball as things stand
 
It’s much better, no incentive to run the ball as things stand

The next step is to ban the caterpillar ruck. The 'use it' law should be altered. Instead of getting 5 seconds to use the ball, teams should be required to use the ball immediately after the ref says 'use it'.
 
I reckon the coaches are more shitscared of injury than the parents :lol:

One of my colleagues coached and reffed youth teams for years. He told me he used to say a little prayer every time a scrum collapsed. Doesn’t bear thinking about
Saw the ambulance come on to the field twice near the end of the season for head injuries when my kid was playing in the u-14s, back in the day.
My son left the team at the end of the season so not sure if those two came back next year. As a parent I’d have 2nd thoughts for sure.
 
Saw the ambulance come on to the field twice near the end of the season for head injuries when my kid was playing in the u-14s, back in the day.
My son left the team at the end of the season so not sure if those two came back next year. As a parent I’d have 2nd thoughts for sure.
Terrifying. I was on both sides of it when I was a lad. Went into a tackle wrong, caught a knee, everything went black. Off to hospital to have my eyebrow stitched back on. A season or so later tackled a lad, his lower leg went one way and his body went the other. Knee blown.

My lads playing rugby league now and I don’t know what’s worse tbh. There’s no scrums or rucks, so less chance of injury there. The high/cheap shots though, feck me some of the tackling has me raging but it’s the convention even at a lower level
 
Last edited:
Terrifying. I was on both sides of it when I was a lad. Went into a tackle wrong, caught a knee, everything went black. Off to hospital to have my eyebrow stitched back on. A season or so later tackled a lad, his lower leg went one way and his body went the other. Knee blown.

My lads playing rugby league now and I don’t know what’s worse tbh. There’s no scrums or rucks, so less chance of injury there. My high/cheap shots though, feck me some of the tackling has me raging but it’s the convention even at a lower level
Knee to the head in a bad tackle is what I did too at that age. Got a proper concussion, had a full 15mins or so missing where I apparently kept playing as normal. I found myself just hanging out in the changing rooms after the match not knowing how I got there.

In that same season I also saw a lad get his neck broken in a collapsed scrum, a horrific broken leg, a horrific broken wrist and forearm, and broke my own collarbone.
 
Knee to the head in a bad tackle is what I did too at that age. Got a proper concussion, had a full 15mins or so missing where I apparently kept playing as normal. I found myself just hanging out in the changing rooms after the match not knowing how I got there.

In that same season I also saw a lad get his neck broken in a collapsed scrum, a horrific broken leg, a horrific broken wrist and forearm, and broke my own collarbone.
It’s the double-edged sword with tackle height….so many head injuries are from the tackler catching a hip/knee to the head
 
It’s the double-edged sword with tackle height….so many head injuries are from the tackler catching a hip/knee to the head

Aye, my young fella’s club are making a big emphasis on chop tackling (all the rage in Ireland now it’s such a feature of the national team’s defending) but every time he goes in to chop down a massive forward I’m imagining the damage a knee to the temple or face could do. Rugby can be such a tough watch for parents. Never feel anything like that sort of anxiety in his football matches.
 
First round of super rugby done for the year and I can report that there were no prolonged kicking duels but there was 1 penalty correctly for an offside player making himself active in the play despite not being put onside by the kicker or a teammate who was behind the kicker. Oh and the Queensland Reds thumped the New South Wales Waratahs so all is well in the world.
 
Aye, my young fella’s club are making a big emphasis on chop tackling (all the rage in Ireland now it’s such a feature of the national team’s defending) but every time he goes in to chop down a massive forward I’m imagining the damage a knee to the temple or face could do. Rugby can be such a tough watch for parents. Never feel anything like that sort of anxiety in his football matches.
Yeah I understand. I actually have a lot against the chop tackle as I think it’s very dangerous for the lower limb health of the ball-carrier. Not so much as youth level but when you see adults throwing their full weight at that knee joint region….it only takes a bit of miss-timing to be a career-ending ligament tear.

Why do we do this game again? :lol:
For me, I just had bad technique. Head on the wrong side.
You and me both mate….im from the Luke Cowan-Dickie school of tackling :lol:
 
Yeah I understand. I actually have a lot against the chop tackle as I think it’s very dangerous for the lower limb health of the ball-carrier. Not so much as youth level but when you see adults throwing their full weight at that knee joint region….it only takes a bit of miss-timing to be a career-ending ligament tear.

Why do we do this game again? :lol:

You and me both mate….im from the Luke Cowan-Dickie school of tackling :lol:
Josh Adams joining our club just now against Aki :lol:
 
I don’t want to be too critical but even in the last few years of Ireland being so dominant in rugby, whenever they’re throwing in at the lineout I’m never confident that it’s going to go right.

The more I watch them the more it seems a persistent issue amidst all the wonderful open-play rugby