Ruben Amorim - Manchester United Head Coach

The Mitcher said:
The point is lost and he looks like he's losing it and throwing the players under the bus.
Click to expand...
Not to me. He repeatedly said it was difficult for the players to adapt to the style of play he wanted of them.

Give one example where he threw a single player under the bus?
 
I don't believe this narrative that all players are shit and they don't suit any formation.

Is the below formation bad ? Bad enough to be on bottom half ?

----------------Zirkzee-------------
Garnacho- Bruno ----Amad
--------Ugarte ---Eriksen ----------
Dalot- De Ligt- Yoro - Mazroui

Something is wrong and it's not just the players.
 
Lentwood said:
Whilst I agree to a certain extent, it doesn't seem to matter than Mazraoui is at wing back or Dalot is on the wrong side against teams like Liverpool or Arsenal...or that we have made changes.

Again, its very simple for me. When we have to play on the front foot, we are appalling. Our fowards are young and inexperienced, or lack the quality needed.

Under Jose, we looked good and finished 2nd when we played conservative football. Under OGS, we looked good and finished 2nd when we played conservative football. Both times, the wheels fell off when we tried to be more progressive.

I go back to my point...and I don't know the answer by the way...is it better to stick dogmatically to a system and hope it clicks...or is it better to bunker down and accept our 60-70pts ceiling playing like a "normal" team, and pursuing 'evolution' not 'revolution'.
Click to expand...

In my opinion, the PL is better now - certainly than it was in Mourinho's time and possibly since Ole. There are lots of good sides who'll want to play on the front foot - Brentford, Brighton, Bournemouth come to mind, plus the usual "bigger" clubs. We need to be able to match sides in attack, and that's the issue for me - the attacking players aren't good enough, and opposition coaches can see that.

The club made a decision to bring in a coach who plays a certain way and has had success with it. He needs to be given the tools to do the job.

I don't think "revolution" is possible - because the players aren't good enough and it'll take three or four transfer windows to sort that out.
 
The Mitcher said:
The point is lost and he looks like he's losing it and throwing the players under the bus.
Click to expand...

That's my feeling too.

I don't know if Amorim is a great coach or not. But part of managing a top team is public relations, ie. knowing what to say to reporters and the public and how to build the image of a prestigious club. So far, it seems to me that Amorim cannot handle that.
 
bond19821982 said:
I don't believe this narrative that all players are shit and they don't suit any formation.

Is the below formation bad ? Bad enough to be on bottom half ?

----------------Zirkzee-------------
Garnacho- Bruno ----Amad
--------Ugarte ---Eriksen ----------
Dalot- De Ligt- Yoro - Mazroui

Something is wrong and it's not just the players.
Click to expand...
Yes, Ugarte already doing running to cover for Mainoo, to do it for Erikson would be worse. many times this season 3 CB's have covered goal saving opportunities.

Last season in that formation we were very bad relying MC Tominay's goals tompaoer over the cracks. He's not here anymore and the cracks are visible. They are the players.
 
The Mitcher said:
The point is lost and he looks like he's losing it and throwing the players under the bus.
Click to expand...

He is clearly taking a risk. Lot of players are overpayed and many have big egos. If they feel that their ego is taking beating they will react. In bad way. We have seen how they have put down tools when it comes to our previous managers. Not that they are exactly performing. Amorim wouldn't be the first one.

It is not hard to get that point. He is talking about collective and not individuals. It is all about how players take it and how strong support he got from those above. People that have lot to learn about football and leadership. One thing is for sure. Ground is shaking. Pressure is on.
 
bond19821982 said:
I don't believe this narrative that all players are shit and they don't suit any formation.

Is the below formation bad ? Bad enough to be on bottom half ?

----------------Zirkzee-------------
Garnacho- Bruno ----Amad
--------Ugarte ---Eriksen ----------
Dalot- De Ligt- Yoro - Mazroui

Something is wrong and it's not just the players.
Click to expand...

It’s still not a very good team, in no time you’d be complaining Eriksen can’t run and full backs can’t attack, or Yoro and Zirkzee aren’t good enough.
 
bond19821982 said:
I don't believe this narrative that all players are shit and they don't suit any formation.

Is the below formation bad ? Bad enough to be on bottom half ?

----------------Zirkzee-------------
Garnacho- Bruno ----Amad
--------Ugarte ---Eriksen ----------
Dalot- De Ligt- Yoro - Mazroui

Something is wrong and it's not just the players.
Click to expand...

That formation could easily become-

Onana
Maz - de Ligt - Yoro
Amad - Ugarte - Eriksen - Dalot
Bruno - Garnacho
Zirkzee
​
I'm afraid it's not the formation.
 
Bring a 3-4-3 manager and not back him for 3-4-3 formation.
Our board is brainless...
 
TheGame said:
He’s shitting himself 3 months into the job. He needs to get a fecking grip of himself like he carries no responsibility for the poor results.
Click to expand...
Door swings both ways, if we're the worst United team in history, he's amongst the worst coaches.

Neither is true, of course.
 
You cannot make gold out of grey stone. He has an impossible task. He got shite forwards, maybe the worst we've had in 40 years. Zirzkzee wouldnt start for Everton or Fulham. We dont have a midfield and our defence is midtable. Onana is no better than the likes of Ramsdale. There are none of our players who would start for City or Liverpool. Maybe one for arsenal, maybe.

How can he compete against them?
 
I really thought he was more flexible and innovative with this 3 at the back formation. I wasn't expecting him to just play five defenders with the same players playing the same positions every game for 90 minutes. Mazraoui has been pitiful at wingback.

The most disheartening thing is that it will still be the same thing next game and the performance will still be as painful. No changes, no effort to find something that works. It looks like he has given up on the job already.
 
MinGin said:
Bring a 3-4-3 manager and not back him for 3-4-3 formation.
Our board is brainless...
Click to expand...
I don't know what Wilcox, Berrada and the other higher ups are doing, honestly speaking. A couple of wingback, a CM and another forward could help stabilize this team. Can't we search the loan market for a couple of players?
 
Ineos doomed the season from the moment they didn't sack Ten Hag after the Cup final. Forget what the fans wanted in the moment, that changes like underwear, the underlying metrics from last season were so astonishingly awful that they couldn't be disregarded or chalked up to injuries.

Total negligence to keep him in the job, and then to hand a manager with a clearly defined style, that he is fixated on, a squad entirely unsuited to it, only one way that was going to go.
 
Among all of this Liverpool are about to equal our 20. Already got friends messaging ‘20 times 20 times’ and ‘we're rolling round anfield with twenty’. It can’t get any worse
 
The Mitcher said:
The point is lost and he looks like he's losing it and throwing the players under the bus.
Click to expand...
Whether I agree with you or not, I at least appreciate your consistency here. Many of the fans who were attacking Rangnick for his comments about the squad are now praising Ruben for his, which strikes me as an incoherent set of views to hold.
 
I'm looking at the squad and I seriously think he needs at least 7 starters to make it work.

I don't see how the club can provide him with that.
 
The situation isn't ideal, but if we trust his vision and style of play—and clearly, we do, given we hired him despite the squad not fitting his approach—we should give him time. Our primary focus should be on restructuring the squad, moving on players who aren't contributing enough or are earning disproportionately high wages. This includes players like Rashford, Casemiro, Eriksen, and Antony.

That said, offloading these players won't be easy, and as a result, we might face difficult decisions, such as selling talents like Garnacho.

If Amorim leaves, he'll likely land another top club very quickly. The real issue over the last two months has been the devaluation of the players' stock, which has impacted the team's prospects significantly.
 
bond19821982 said:
I don't believe this narrative that all players are shit and they don't suit any formation.

Is the below formation bad ? Bad enough to be on bottom half ?

----------------Zirkzee-------------
Garnacho- Bruno ----Amad
--------Ugarte ---Eriksen ----------
Dalot- De Ligt- Yoro - Mazroui

Something is wrong and it's not just the players.
Click to expand...
Yes. There's 10 better first XIs in the PL than that.
 
TheGame said:
Funnily enough Erikson was actually playing well at the beginning of this season.
Click to expand...

He had a few good games, especially in the cups. But people would be up in arms if he was playing regularly. As ever he is now seeing his reputation enhanced by not playing, and the last time he started he was awful.
 
waza7111 said:
That formation could easily become-

Onana
Maz - de Ligt - Yoro
Amad - Ugarte - Eriksen - Dalot
Bruno - Garnacho
Zirkzee
​
I'm afraid it's not the formation.
Click to expand...
That team as you put it has a lot more potential for goals than the team that was on the pitch today
 
Idxomer said:
I'm looking at the squad and I seriously think he needs at least 7 starters to make it work.

I don't see how the club can provide him with that.
Click to expand...
Early on, when he came in, I faresaw this and stated that if he doesn't supplement the squad with youth he is done here because we don't have the money to buy all that he needs at once and he won't survive multiple windows having to rely on these players.

Say we sign 5 players in the summer, if survives to the summer that is, they still won't be enough to cover all the holes in the squad. He looks like he needs a couple of faster CBs, a couple of wingbacks, a CM, a striker and another 10. That's at least 7 players, some of whom will cost north of £60m and even at an average of £40m each that's still £280m.

However if he could bed in a couple of academy players with better attributes that the dross we are putting out maybe you need about four new players immediately. Let's say you have Gore, Collyer, Amass and a few No.10s from the youth and they play at an acceptable level, you mitigate the need to sign a whole new team, something we know he won't get.

If he doesn't do this, he is dead in the water.
 
TheGame said:
He’s shitting himself 3 months into the job. He needs to get a fecking grip of himself like he carries no responsibility for the poor results.
Click to expand...
He's been taking the blame for weeks, he has been taking responsibility. It's time he puts these players in the firing line- they should be embarrassed at where they at.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.