Played Beta for a bit, didn't really like it. I'm a big WoW fan and things are almost identical to WoW, from the roles, UI, layout, everything - which is certainly something they sold it is.
However, the thing that bothered me was the graphics.
I don't think with a PC MMORPG you can realistically go for a good-looking game based around realism. WoW is quite cartoony, and hence the graphics aren't the best but that's okay because it's cartoony. Trying to be realistic and have crappy graphics isn't going to work.
And I know it can look very good, but the thing is with the PC player-base, not everyone has great computers - mine is by no means shoddy, but it is not top-, top end either. And you need to cater to all, and if it looks really awful for those players, it's gonna be a turn off.
It also seems to take itself quite seriously. I don't want that too much in a game. I like that WoW makes fun of internet meme's, popular culture and itself.
Where else would you find a semi important quest where you have to save an Orc called Jack Bauden from being tied to a chair in a derelict old barracks where he complains that the last day has been lasting for years! HA.
Great stuff.
WoW > Rift
