Retro Football Fantasy Championship Final - Team Polaroid vs Team Gio

Who will win based on players in their prime, team tactics, balance & bench strength?


  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .

Polaroid

New Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2003
Messages
2,703
This is a Fantasy Football Team competition. Managers are required to assemble their fantasy squads by selecting players BASED ON THE LEVEL THEY WERE AT IN THEIR PRIME. The limiting conditions are that the players must be born in the 1960s (from 1 Jan 1960 to 31 Dec 1969) and not named Diego Maradona. As this is meant to simulate a real match, team formation, balance, tactics and bench strength also plays a part. Hence please carefully consider the abovesaid factors and evaluate the merits of both teams before voting for the team which in your opinion is more likely to win the match.

Stadiums assigned for each match merely add colour to the game and do not have any material impact on the competition ie there is no influence (home advantage, crowd support, familiarity etc) on the players and the match at all.

Polls will last 1 day, except for the semi-finals and final which will last 2 days. Polls are open to all Redcafe members to vote. However, managers and assistant managers must not vote in their own matches or matches that provide their immediate next round opponent. Non-compliance could result in expulsion from the competition. To enforce this, the votes in polls will be made public.


The spotlight of the world's media and the eyes of over a billion TV viewers are on the grand final tonight at Old Trafford. The fat lady has sung and the fireworks has begun. The atmosphere is electric and crackling in this famous stadium as the capacity crowd of 75,811 greet the two teams emerging from the tunnel with fluttering banners and flying confetti, their full-throated rip-roaring chants are like claps of thunder swaying the giant stands. Team Polaroid vs Team Gio, two great teams on the cusp of making history and facing the biggest night in their career as they prepare to engage in an epic tussle that will undoubtedly add to the illustrious legacy of memorable contests witnessed in this historic stadium. This is footballing war, sweat and tears will be shed, blood maybe...but only one will survive, only one will savour the sweet reward of victory - the glimmering trophy of the Retro Football Fantasy Championship and the right to be called champions. You, the all-powerful voter, shall judge and decide

All members of the Redcafe are eligible to vote (see above for voting restriction on managers and assistant managers). Voters are encouraged to comment on both teams and share with us the reasoning behind their choice. Thanks!
 
Team Polaroid

Polaroid said:
312522_Manchester_United.jpg

Subs:
Thomas Haessler
Mauro Silva
Raí
Ronny Johnsen
Amedeo Carboni

My back four has the perfect complementary blend of footballing intelligence, defensive savviness, athleticism and technique - Paolo Maldini, Franco Baresi, Des Walker and Jocelyn Angloma. Walker will man-mark Van Basten with Baresi playing the covering role. Rijkaard is the defensive anchor, pitting him directly against Gullit. The imperious powerhouse duo of Matthäus and Effenberg function as the heartbeat and engine of the team. Effenberg will dictate proceedings from centre midfield with his vision and range of passing looking to play balls in behind for Suker and Weah to exploit the lack of pace in the opposition's centre defense. Effenberg will also check the forward runs of Brehme while Angloma focuses on Hagi. Matthaus has more freedom to bomb forward with driving runs through the centre or as a midfield runner arriving late in the box to score. Michael Laudrup is the primary creative playmaker of the team with the freedom to roam and work his magic anywhere, essentially a floating role where his superlative skills, sublime dribbling and visionary passing will string up play and orchestrate the attacking transition into the final third, supplying the devastating trio of George Weah, Davor Šuker and Matthaus to cut defenses into ribbons. Weah is given a deeper role from where he can run at the defense with his powerful dribbling at pace, attack the channels or go wide to link up with Maldini, fluid to the situations that unfold in the game. Suker will play the predatory poacher role, centre-right (hanging on Sammer's shoulder and ready to pounce on any window of opportunity) where he can cut in and shoot.

Player profiles

Santiago Cañizares
One of the top 3 goalkeepers in the world during the turn of the millenium, Cañizares represented Spain and his clubs, in particular Valencia, with great distinction, leading to acclaim from Peter Schmeichel that he was possibly the best goalkeeper in the world (BBC Sport Academy | Football | Features | Schmeichel's top Euro keepers). A 4-time winner of the Ricardo Zamora trophy for having the best goals-conceded-to-games ratio in Spain, Cañizares has also won La Liga 4 times, the Champions league once (out of 3 finals), the UEFA Cup, the UEFA Supercup, the Copa Del Rey twice and the Spanish Supercup twice. He was also an Olympic champion with Spain in 1992.

Jocelyn Angloma
Quick, strong and defensively astute with first-rate anticipation, Angloma was one of the best right backs in the world throughout the 1990s and was chosen by European sports journalists in their Team of the Year 3 times - no mean feat considering that he was up against the likes of Cafu, Thuram and Javier Zanetti. His early career took off with Marseille with whom he won the Champions League, beating AC Milan in the 1993 final. On the international stage, he had an outstanding tournament at the European Championship in 1992, where he was chosen in the Team of the Tournament, before retiring prematurely in 1996. He ended his club career with Valencia, playing 5 seasons for them and reaching 2 consecutive Champions League finals.

Paolo Maldini
Il Capitano (the Captain), a leader of leaders and Italian Maestro who has perfected the art of defending. Possibly the most complete defender in the history of the game - technically, physically, mentally, he is the definitive finest thoroughbred there ever was, excelling in every footballing aspect from his immaculate technique to his supreme athleticism and telepathic reading of the game. A legend in the truest sense of the word, his glorious exploits with AC Milan (5 Champions League, 7 Serie A titles, 2 Intercontinental Cups) has rightfully earned him an exalted pedestal in the pantheon of footballing greats.

Franco Baresi
The greatest defender of his generation and one of the finest of all time, Franco Baresi was the defensive rock and leader of the AC Milan side which ruled world football two decades ago. His footballing intelligence was a marvel to behold - a prescient reading of the game, unmatched speed of thought and flawless decision-making, meaning that his game went beyond impeccable defensive nous as he was also a master at initiating attacks from the back. His authority in leadership and capability in organisational skills were a force-multiplier, making the defense greater than the sum of its individual parts. One of his finest performances came in the 1994 World Cup final where he shut down the Brazilian attack to the point of asphyxiation. Romário who had the quietest game of his career on the world's biggest stage called it "The most ruthless monitoring of my entire career". Chosen as Player of the Century separately by the Italian Football Federation and AC Milan (who retired his number 6 jersey in his honour), there will not be many like him in the next hundred years.

Des Walker
Circa 1990, Walker was one of the top 3 centrebacks in the world, marrying immaculate tackling prowess to searing pace and a salmon-like leap. Walker played a starring role as defensive lynchpin in England's run to the semi-finals of the World Cup in Italia 90, where his consummate man-marking skills snugly kept the world's premier strikers such as Van Basten and Klinsmann quiet in his pocket.

Frank Rijkaard
Without doubt the greatest defensive midfielder of his generation and a candidate for the finest of all time, Rijkaard would be the ideal defensive midfielder complete in every technical, physical, mental aspect if we are to construct one using a dream machine. Quite simply, he has the lot - with the pace of a Ferrari and the power of a Rolls Royce combined with his formidable tackling prowess and towering aerial strength, he is the ultimate unparalleled ball winner. What elevates him another level higher is that he is not only the best at winning the ball, he is also a master at using it - technically accomplished with exemplary ball control, polished technique and impeccable passing ability, his immaculate composure and flawless reading of the game enables him not only to retain ball possession but also immediately launch the transition into counter-attack, throwing the sucker-punch at opponents where it hurts most before they have a chance to re-group and organise. A peerless defensive midfielder who reached the acme of perfection and has not been surpassed since.

Lothar Matthäus
One of the greatest players the game has ever seen, Matthäus was a complete Tour De Force not unlike the almighty forces of Nature that can both create and destroy, a one-man Panzer army who unfailingly steamrolled all obstacles and launched pulverising attacks that ruthlessly crushed opponents into submission. This description may come as a surprise to football fans who only caught the tail-end of his career but in his prime, Matthäus was the definitive all-round midfielder who excelled at both ends of the pitch, hitting double digits in goals scored for 8 consecutive seasons, including 23 in the 90-91 season. Long-time rival Maradona described him as the best rival he ever had, a fitting testimony to a fearsome winner who captained West Germany to victory in the 1990 World Cup, scoring 4 goals in the process. Ballon D' Or winner (European Footballer of the Year) in 1990 and FIFA World Player of the Year in 1991, at his peak, Matthäus was quite simply the unstoppable Tour De Force.

Stefan Effenberg
A bona fide midfield general who commanded the pitch with Kaiser-esque authority, Effenberg's all-round ability and leadership made him the best box-to-box midfielder of his generation alongside Roy Keane. Bone-crunching tackles, pinpoint long passes, powerful driving runs and thunderbolt goals were regular features of his game. Effenberg has won numerous honours in the game but his crowning glory came in 2001 when he captained Bayern Munich to the Champions League and Intercontinental Cup titles, winning UEFA Club Footballer of the Year along the way.

Michael Laudrup
The ultimate footballing artist of supreme genius, fantasy and inspiration
What fellow professionals said of Michael Laudrup
Roberto Galia: "I have played against Maradona, Platini and Baggio. But the player I saw do the most indescribable things was Michael Laudrup."
Ronald Koeman: "Michael was possibly the most skilful and elegant player I ever played with. Few could dribble like he could. He could sense when a game was ready to be seized and transformed by a moment of individual brilliance."
Raúl González: "The best I have ever played with."
Luis Figo:"I think maybe Laudrup was the best player I ever played against."
Romário: "The best player I have ever played with and the 5th best in the history of the game"
Andres Iniesta:"Who is the best player in history? Laudrup."
Jorge Valdano:"He has eyes everywhere"
Jose Mourinho:"He was phenomenal in Barcelona. He was a fantastic player whom I would love to have on my team today."
Johan Cruyff: "When Michael plays like a dream, a magic illusion, determined to show his new team his extreme abilities, no one in the world comes anywhere near his level."
Franz Beckenbauer: "Pelé was the best in the 60s, Cruyff in the 70s, Maradona in the 80s and Laudrup in the 90s."

Davor Šuker
Flair, finesse, finishing - Šuker was absolutely top-draw and one of the premier strikers in world football during the 90s. From 92-98 his record stood at 38 goals from 44 internationals for Croatia and 114 goals from 211 appearances for Sevilla and Real Madrid. At the European Championship in 1996, he was picked in UEFA's Team of the Tournament. He moved to Real Madrid that summer and subsequently won La Liga, the Spanish Supercup, the Champions League and the Intercontinental Cup with them. He was also the Golden Boot winner at World Cup 98 in France with 6 goals, firing Croatia to 3rd place - their highest ever placing. That year, Suker was placed 2nd in the European Footballer of the Year Award and 3rd in the FIFA World Player of the Year Award.

George Weah
An athletic phenomenon and footballing Rolls Royce with a frightening blend of speed, power, control and skill, Weah was voted African Footballer of the Year, European Footballer of the Year and World Footballer of the Year in 1995. The following year, he was placed second to the Brazilian Ronaldo. Weah started his career in Europe under Arsene Wenger at Monaco before excelling at Paris St-Germain, starring in their run to the Champions League semi-final. He then moved to AC Milan and played an instrumental role in their Serie A triumphs. To this date, Weah's stupendous goal against Verona, where he started his run from inside his own box to score at the opponent's end, remains one of the best, if not the best goal scored in Serie A history.

Substitutes
Thomas Haessler
One of the best free-kick takers and greatest German midfielders of all time, Haessler was an effervescent and irrepressible pocket dynamo whose dazzling dribbles, sparkling creativity and spectacular goals bewitched countless opponents. Haessler enjoyed illustrious success with the German national side, lifting the World Cup and European Championship in 1990 and 1996. He was also the best player of the tournament at the European Championship in 1992, leading Germany to the final with a series of outstanding displays and fabulous goals. That year, he was placed third in the FIFA World Player of Year award. By the time he retired, he was only the 5th German ever to collect over a century of caps for his country.

Mauro Silva
One of the finest defensive midfielders of his generation, Mauro Silva was a Spanish Champion, a South American Champion and a World Champion, being the midfield kingpin of the Deportivo side that won La Liga (and finished runners-up in 4 other seasons) as well as an important member of the Seleção Brasileira, starting every match of Brazil's triumphant World Cup campaign in 94. While general first impressions of him are that of a tough tackler with a bottomless reservoir of stamina, observers of his game also appreciate his smooth footballing technique and flawless distribution. His best assets though are his almost telepathic reading of the game and impeccable positional sense, snuffing out smouldering danger before they have a chance to ignite. Undoubtedly a formidable rock that you could depend on in the midst of a thunderous storm.

Raí
Raí was an exceptionally gifted midfielder who was multi-faceted in his attacking talents and had a prolific goalscoring record at both club and international level. He starred for Sao Paulo, winning 2 Libertadores Cups and 1 Intercontinental Cup, before moving to Paris Saint-Germain and leading them to domestic and European success. He also won the World Cup with Brazil in 1994.

Ronny Johnsen
One of the most under-rated players in United's glorious treble success of 1999, Ronny Johnsen was a composed and pacey centreback who was equally comfortable playing in centre midfield with his sound reading of the game, fine positional sense and steady distribution. I particularly enjoyed his performances against the Brazilian Ronaldo in France 1998 and Zidane in Turin 1999.

Amedeo Carboni
A nippy left-back with four lungs, Carboni was an intelligent defender savvy in the Italian art of defending and prolific in overlapping to support the attack. In a storied career spanning 22 years, Carboni captained Roma and represented Italy at the European Championship in 1996 before moving to Valencia, winning multiple trophies including the Cup Winners Cup, UEFA Cup, and La Liga twice.
 
Team Gio

Gio said:
310930_Dream_Team.jpg


Tactics - The best international team of the era, Germany, provide the entire back four. Should Sammer stride regally forward into the middle, Hierro will naturally drop back into centre-half. Otherwise Hierro, Prosinecki and Gullit will pull the strings from the middle of the park, finding unpressurised out-balls in Brehme and Berthold. Hagi will drift into the inside left channel to link up with Bernabeu colleague Hierro, allowing Brehme's attacking game to be fully exploited on the overlap and two-on-one situations against Angloma. The best club team of the era and perhaps all time provide the bulk of the attack. Effervescent width of Donadoni is complemented by Gullit who renews his world-beating partnership with Van Basten. Both forwards will feed off the penetrating crossing positions which my wide players will find themselves in, capitalising on their fantastic aerial ability to expose Polaroid's fairly short central defensive partnership. World-class goalsmiths in Zamorano and Bebeto wait on a talent-laden bench to offer an alternative and additional threat

Vitor Baia - The most expensive goalkeeper in the world following his transfer to Barcelona in 1996. Considered amongst the top three or four in Europe during the mid-1990s, latterly voted as goalkeeper of the year during Porto's treble success of 2004.

Thomas Berthold - An important player for West Germany both in 1986 and 1990, his pace and overall defensive game ensured a well protected right flank. Classy full-back spent four seasons in Serie A before joining Bayern Munich.

Jurgen Kohler - One of the greatest man-marking centre-halves of all time and a pivotal figure for the Germans.

Matthias Sammer – Consummate libero who is second perhaps only to Franz Beckenbaeur and complements Kohler beautifully. Ballon D’Or winner in 1996, he ran the show at Euro ’96 leading Germany to the title as the tournament’s second top scorer despite operating out of defence.

Andreas Brehme - In Europe's three major leagues, Brehme is one of only two full-backs to have won player of the year in the last four decades. Brehme achieved this in 1989 - when Serie A was at its fearsome best. Defensively robust, two-footed and a set-piece expert, has also scored three goals in World Cup semi-finals and finals.

Fernando Hierro – Very few deep-lying midfielders have combined defensive nous with such attacking verve as the Real Madrid and Spain captain. Imperious in the air, Hierro was equally comfortable on the ground, displaying savvy positioning at both ends of the park and commanding a delightful range of passing. Netted an outrageous 29 goals for club and country in 1991/92 alone.

Robert Prosinecki - Gifted playmaker, driving force and architect of Red Star's European Cup triumph in 1991.

Roberto Donadoni - One of the trickiest and most industrious wingers of the early 1990s, Donadoni was an important cog in the all-conquering Milan team.

Gheorge Hagi – Along with Andreas Brehme, probably possesses the best left peg in the competition. A majestic player in his pomp who orchestrated the talented Romanian team which captured the global imagination in 1994.

Ruud Gullit - An outstanding physical specimen, Gullit was famed for his cerebral playmaking talents and ability to operate anywhere along midfield or in attack. From 1987 to 1989, Gullit was widely regarded as second only to Maradona, winning a Ballon D'Or along the way.

Marco Van Basten - Three-time Ballon D'Or winner and the standout striker in the competition. Technically perfect with supreme mental attributes, he was unplayable in 1988.

Subs:

Ivan Zamorano - A classic number nine and unstoppable goalscorer with Real Madrid and Chile, he twice broke the 30-goal barrier for the Spanish side.

Bebeto - The fifth highest Brazilian goalscorer of all time with 39 international goals. South American footballer of the year in 1989, Bebeto formed a scintillating partnership with Romario as Brazil won the 1994 World Cup.

Fernando Couto - A beast of a centre-half in his mid-1990s pomp. Would go on to amass 110 caps for the national team.

Alemao - Anchored the Brazilian midfield through the 1980s. One of the few Brazilian central midfielders to enjoy a successful career in Europe, Alemao was a key man in Napoli's Serie A and UEFA Cup successes and earned EFE's South American Player of the Year award whilst at Atletico Madrid in 1988. More than capable of bolstering the midfield should Hierro be required in defence.

Alexei Mikhailichenko - Talented and versatile attacking midfielder who was part of the great Soviet team of the late 1980s where his exploits saw him reach 4th place in the Ballon D'Or in 1988.
 
Gio, you can make further adjustments if you wish to. When you are ready, I will add the poll. During the match, any point in in time, you can make further changes.
 
Why does Gio not have a new player? I was expecting to see a Van Basten - Romario partnership.
 
I will be going overseas in around 12 hours time so I will not be able to see through this match

Will be away for some time so you guys can kick off the 70s fantasy tournament without me. Cheers!
 
I hereby invite applications for someone to take over my team when I leave
 
He has a new player - Matthias Sammer


Fair enough, but why does he have a midfielder in his defence and a defender in his midfield? I know they both had a couple of secondary positions but that seems a little odd.
 
Fair enough, but why does he have a midfielder in his defence and a defender in his midfield? I know they both had a couple of secondary positions but that seems a little odd.

I concur, I would have swapped them around like what you said with Sammer being a better attacker and Hierro the better defender.
 
Fair enough, but why does he have a midfielder in his defence and a defender in his midfield? I know they both had a couple of secondary positions but that seems a little odd.

Based on the criteria it's a straightforward decision for me. Both players spent their prime in those positions. Sammer played as sweeper as the dominant force at Euro 96; Hierro spent his early-to-mid-20s largely as a central midfielder from where he scored 29 goals in 91/92, probably the best goalscoring season of any central midfielder in the draft. It was only from his mid-20s did he retreat back to the defence on a permanent basis. Both players as you say are equally comfortable in midfield or defence and I would fully anticipate Sammer to carry the ball forward into the midfield as he did so devastatingly at Euro 96 with Hierro dropping into the back line accordingly - much like Dieter Eilts did at those championships.

I did mull over selecting Romario. But when you already have a proven world-beating partnership in Van Basten and Gullit, it's just indulgence really. And it would mean weakening the five-man midfield - particularly when there's so already so many goals from that area: in their most productive seasons, Hagi got 31, Gullit 30, Hierro 29, Prosinecki 19, Brehme 12.
 
Based on the criteria it's a straightforward decision for me. Both players spent their prime in those positions. Sammer played as sweeper as the dominant force at Euro 96; Hierro spent his early-to-mid-20s largely as a central midfielder from where he scored 29 goals in 91/92, probably the best goalscoring season of any central midfielder in the draft. It was only from his mid-20s did he retreat back to the defence on a permanent basis. Both players as you say are equally comfortable in midfield or defence and I would fully anticipate Sammer to carry the ball forward into the midfield as he did so devastatingly at Euro 96 with Hierro dropping into the back line accordingly - much like Dieter Eilts did at those championships.

Good call, I as well found it odd at first but Hierro had a cannon in his foot and is a very serious goal threat and useful alternative when facing a sturdy defence.

Could a mod turn this into a poll?
 
PM from Gio and updated in post above


Gio said:
Tactics - The best international team of the era, Germany, provide the entire back four. Should Sammer stride regally forward into the middle, Hierro will naturally drop back into centre-half. Otherwise Hierro, Prosinecki and Gullit will pull the strings from the middle of the park, finding unpressurised out-balls in Brehme and Berthold. Hagi will drift into the inside left channel to link up with Bernabeu colleague Hierro, allowing Brehme's attacking game to be fully exploited on the overlap and two-on-one situations against Angloma. The best club team of the era and perhaps all time provide the bulk of the attack. Effervescent width of Donadoni is complemented by Gullit who renews his world-beating partnership with Van Basten. Both forwards will feed off the penetrating crossing positions which my wide players will find themselves in, capitalising on their fantastic aerial ability to expose Polaroid's fairly short central defensive partnership. World-class goalsmiths in Zamorano and Bebeto wait on a talent-laden bench to offer an alternative and additional threat.
 
Poll added

Before I leave, i would just say a few points
1. Berthold is not much of a threat going forward and in the event he ventures forward, Weah will exploit the space he vacates.
2. Brehme is a threat going forward hence I have detailed Effenberg to check his runs and cut off his supply of crosses while Angloma focuses on Hagi. No 2 on 1 situation here.
3. Gio seems to have forgotten about Rijkaard when he talked about Gullit capitalising on his aerial ability. As I have said in post #2, Rijkaard is pitted directly against Gullit, Walker is marking Van Basten and Baresi is playing the covering role. Walker is not a giant by any measure but his salmon-like leap has enabled him to out-jump taller forwards to win headers. In any case, he does not have to win all the headers, he just has to prevent Van Basten from connecting cleanly and Baresi can help to sweep up. Walker came up against Van Basten only once in a major tournament, that was at World Cup 1990 and from these match highlights (probably by Dutch fans going by their usernames), you can see how quiet a game Van Basten had.




I have a plane to catch and will be leaving now. I will not be able to see through this match. Goodbye.
 
I'm the same. My first instinct tells me Polaroid. But then sinking into the thinking and really taken only their prime into account it changes a bit.

But the fact is that Polaroid's team has 9 players that everyone don't doubt how good they were in their prime. Des Walker has been a question mark for some and not everyone knows much about Angloma.

On the other hand you have Berthold, Donadoni and Prosinecki. Sure the latter two are well known but how much did you really see Prosinecki play to be able to effectively compare him to Gullit or Effenberg and how good was Donadoni in his prime.

Berthold is the only player I have no recollection of seeing so I have to base my opinion on what I'm given my Gio and wikipedia.
 
I originally thought Pol would run away with it, personally I'd have taken Cantona or Bergkamp to play behind Weah and kept the same midfield.

Will think about it for a while and see how this goes...
 
Polaroid for me. Maldini, Baresi, Effenberg, Matthaus, Rijkaard; too many winners in that side to lose.
 
On the other hand you have Berthold, Donadoni and Prosinecki. Sure the latter two are well known but how much did you really see Prosinecki play to be able to effectively compare him to Gullit or Effenberg and how good was Donadoni in his prime.

Berthold is the only player I have no recollection of seeing so I have to base my opinion on what I'm given my Gio and wikipedia.

Prosinecki was the outstanding midfielder in the 1990-91 European Cup, putting in stellar performances against Rangers, Dynamo Dresden and running the show in a superb semi-final against Bayern Munich.

Donadoni was an elusive and inventive winger, able to operate on both flanks. I'd have him well established in the top half dozen wide midfielders during the late 1980s and early 1990s.
 
Still damn hard this one. Seems like Polaroid would be dominant but would face a very reliable and settled back four. I never thought much of Baia though...

But then Gio has genuine width and would be deadly on the counter.

You can see that game going either way.
 
I'm still undecided here. I prefer Gio's tactics and team shape. Polaroid's counter-tactic of Effenberg covering Brehme's runs seems risky to me. If Gio enjoys any substantial period of possession then Effenberg gets marooned on the right wing while Angloma presumablycompromises the shape of the back four by attempting to track Hagi as he drifts infield. With Effenberg out of position the midfield battle becomes alot more winnable for Gio. He's got the best goalscorer on the field in Van Basten, and I like the proven partnerships of the all-German backline and Donadoni-Gullit-Van Basten axis up front. Both managers have plenty of quality on the bench, but Gio has more goals and more scope for tactical variation imo. But Polaroid has so much individual quality and the tie hinges on whether or not that powerhouse midfield of Rijkaard-Matthaus-Effenberg could steamroll the likes of the incredibly talented but comparatively lightweight Prosinecki and Hagi. On balance I'm edging towards voting for Gio.
 
Actually i reckon team Poloroid would be a more consistent team but if team Gio turned it on, your Hagis and Prosineckis for example they could feck shit up.

Agreed. Polaroid would surely win in a league format but assuming a cup final with all players playing at the top of their game Gio's attack would be devastating.

He's got the best goalscorer on the field in Van Basten, and I like the proven partnerships of the all-German backline and Donadoni-Gullit-Van Basten axis up front.

Same here. They way I'm seeing it, the all-German backline may as well be a better proposition than the rival collection of individuals, despite these including two of the best ever.

And Gio has one of the best in Brehme as well, who will have Effenberg all over the shop tracking him and diluting the effectiveness of that midfield.

I'm plumping for the more attractive attacking proposition here.
 
310947_Dream_Team.jpg


With the game still in the balance, I'll move to a classic 3-5-2 with Sammer, Brehme and Gullit all to push on and go for the winner.
 
Pol edges it by one vote to win his 2nd fantasy trophy!
 
310947_Dream_Team.jpg


With the game still in the balance, I'll move to a classic 3-5-2 with Sammer, Brehme and Gullit all to push on and go for the winner.

Ouch! That didn't work. You unsettled the back four to go all out and Weah shagged you on the counter.
 
I voted for Gio because with similarly good teams his formation would win him the game. That's just what 4-5-1 should do vs 4-4-2
 
Congrats to Polaroid. Picked up players who would make it into all-time XIs never mind just the 80s/90s in the knockout stage which allied to some savvy selections during the draft (Angloma, Suker, etc) made his team almost unbeatable.