Lawsuit: Show us the Money, or Pull the PlayStation 3

esmufc07

Brad
Scout
Joined
Aug 7, 2007
Messages
50,071
Location
Lake Jonathan Creek
Last Wednesday another no-name company with a suitcase full of patents opted to fling one at Sony in another attempt to cash in on Sony's Blu-ray technology. According to Edge, which obtained the court filing, Orinda Intellectual Properties USA Holding Group (bet you'd never guess what they do) is alleging that Sony violated their patent number 5,438,560, titled "Apparatus and method for recording/reproducing optical information and optical disk-shaped recording medium."

Named as defendants: Sony Corporation, Sony Entertainment Inc., Sony Computer Entertainment America Inc., and Sony Electronics Inc.
Orinda apparently wants a jury trial, the cessation of PS3 manufacturing and sales, as well as pretty much anything else containing Blu-ray technology. The company also wants royalties.

Of course others have already tried...and failed. In May 2007, Target Technology sued Sony in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana for violating patent 7,018,696, titled "Metal alloys for the reflective or the semi-reflective layer of an optical storage medium."
The result? Dismissed, just a few months later.

What's different this time? The lawsuit was filed with the Texas Eastern District Court, which earlier this year denied Nintendo's appeal to scuttle a $21 million patent-infringement verdict favoring Anascape Ltd., which had claimed NIntendo violated a dozen controller-related patents related to its Wii and GameCube systems.

http://blogs.pcworld.com/gameon/archives/007629.html

I can't see them succeeding to be honest, Sony have already defended cases against this so why it is being brought up again I don't know.
 
Sony are right ferocious cnuts when it comes to court cases, I could never forgive them for what they did to Lik-Sang.

They spend most their efforts ensuring that it's illegal for us European gamers to import their products overseas instead of actually improving entitlements in Europe.
 
Why was it illegal in the first place though?

They were importing PSP's to the UK before their official release date there, which Sony said was an infringement on their Trademark Rights, the courts agreed and Lik Sang was no-more.

I didn't really follow the case though, only heard bits of it, so I may not be entirely right.
 
Lik-Sang did it because Hong Kong laws allow free trade of items once they're available anywhere in the world, so in essence they were legal. Sony just had to use it's intimidating monopoly to ensure that UK gamers wouldn't get PSPs early so instead they could charge us alot more several months down the line for when it was eventually released.
 
Lik-Sang did it because Hong Kong laws allow free trade of items once they're available anywhere in the world, so in essence they were legal. Sony just had to use it's intimidating monopoly to ensure that UK gamers wouldn't get PSPs early so instead they could charge us alot more several months down the line for when it was eventually released.

It isn't Sony's fault the UK have VAT and all that nonsense, costs have to be recovered.

And a quick look on Wikipedia shows that Nintendo and MS also filed lawsuits (Along with Sony) against Lik-Sang in 2002.
 
The case in 2002 was different though and totally justifiable, that involved microchips and pirating and to be honest I dont blame the big three for taking action against that since piracy IS genuinely illegal. But in the end Lik-Sang agreed to stop selling the microchips and it was settled at that.
 
Just ask yourself these questions.

Would you chip your PS3? And would you be happy with others chipping theirs? (unless if the console is manufactured by EA)

and

Would you consider ordering a PSP from a site if it's cheaper and since you'll grab it months before it's supposed release in your region, allowing you to play games the Japanese and Americans are currently playing?
 
Just ask yourself this?

Would you chip your PS3? And would you be happy with others chipping theirs?

No, I wouldn't, I have never chipped any console I have owned, and I never will.

and

Would you consider ordering a PSP from a site if it's cheaper and since you'll grab it months before it's supposed release in your region, allowing you to play games the Japanese and Americans are currently playing?

That is besides the point, SCEE (Not Sony), are losing money on each imported PSP and are well within their rights to stop that from happening. They are a business at the end of the day, they need to maximise their revenues. Surely from a business persepective you can understand that?
 
That is besides the point, SCEE (Not Sony), are losing money on each imported PSP and are well within their rights to stop that from happening. They are a business at the end of the day, they need to maximise their revenues. Surely from a business persepective you can understand that?

Then it's simple, don't release their products months late in Europe, then people wont see the need to import.
 
What's actually in a development kit? Can you send me one?:p

Well usually it consists of a PC set up to run like what the final console should perform like. The Gamecube one had PC versions of all it's components, plus obviously controller ports and the like.

The stuff I got from Liksang was mostly to do with the Gameboy advance and PS2, things like flash cards/carts and harddrives. They were faster and more reliable (especially more so than the sony gear).
 
Well usually it consists of a PC set up to run like what the final console should perform like. The Gamecube one had PC versions of all it's components, plus obviously controller ports and the like.

The stuff I got from Liksang was mostly to do with the Gameboy advance and PS2, things like flash cards/carts and harddrives. They were faster and more reliable (especially more so than the sony gear).

Ah I see, not got any Dev Kits for the latest batch of consoles? Or are they too expensive/time consuming?

(Sorry if I sound like an idiot:lol:)

You got a few thousand to spare? :smirk:

No, but I feel with a little time and effort I could become one of the best developers in Europe.
 
Ah I see, not got any Dev Kits for the latest batch of consoles? Or are they too expensive/time consuming?

(Sorry if I sound like an idiot:lol:)

I don't have any of dev kits as such, but then it's not all about the hardware...



No, but I feel with a little time and effort I could become one of the best developers in Europe.

:D
 
My brother actually wants to become a Character Designer, some of his drawings are amazing.

Whether he will actually achieve it or not is another question.

And I hope you're not doubting my developing abilities lambs.
 
My brother actually wants to become a Character Designer, some of his drawings are amazing.

Whether he will actually achieve it or not is another question.

It's much easier for an artist. Can he draw with photoshop? Does he do character animations? There are a number of things he can get into.


And I hope you're not doubting my developing abilities lambs.

Not at all! I'm sure you have some good ideas.
 
It's much easier for an artist. Can he draw with photoshop? Does he do character animations? There are a number of things he can get into.

I imagine he does, he spent a crazy amount of money on a computer so it could run all those sorts of programs. He lives away from home though so I don't see him much.

Not at all! I'm sure you have some good ideas.

Believe it or not I have had the thought of playing as a single player in football games (Like FIFA and PES have introduced) since about 2001. When I heard they were bringing it in I felt like I should have had a share of the profits.

Bastards.
 
Believe it or not I have had the thought of playing as a single player in football games (Like FIFA and PES have introduced) since about 2001. When I heard they were bringing it in I felt like I should have had a share of the profits.

Bastards.

Nintendo already did that in the late 80's ;)